Contribution
My Lords, I thank the Lord Speaker and noble Lords from across your Lordships’ House for the warmth and generosity of their welcome. Entering the House seems a daunting privilege to a new Peer, but the helpful and friendly welcome that I have been accorded should not go unremarked. I thank everyone for reminding me of the importance of this place.
It gives me great pleasure to make my first contribution in this debate on the Second Reading of the Health Bill. Before I do, I beg the indulgence of noble Lords to say a few words of thanks, beginning with the Clerk of the Parliaments, her staff, Black Rod and his team. In my first few days I have been rescued, reassured and pointed in the right direction by staff from across your Lordships’ House, especially the doorkeepers, who have saved me more than once. The highlight, witnessed by mercifully few noble Lords, was on day two, when I strode purposefully into the Chamber and sat on the Opposition Benches. Help was swift and subtle—and I will be very grateful if that level of support continues. I particularly thank my two supporters, my noble friends Lady Batters and Lady Kennedy of Cradley.
I have taken a Sheffield place name—it has been a bit of a day for Yorkshire—and the city and its surrounding countryside have shaped my life. My dad was a PE teacher and mum a teaching assistant. I was delighted that at 92 my mum was here for my introduction, but I must tell noble Lords that she was disappointed to find she was not the oldest person in the building.
I am the only family member who did not follow the family trade of educating young people—that is, until much later when I became the proud chair of Sheffield Hallam University. This excellent post-1992 university has a relevance to today’s debate; it is a significant NHS workforce training institution, particularly for South Yorkshire and the wider Yorkshire and Humber region. Its importance goes beyond nursing; it trains nurses, midwives, paramedics and a large range of allied health professionals.
I had a long career in feeding the nation. My time at the Food Standards Agency took me into the world of protecting consumers from all the risks associated with food: the acute, which is mostly food poisoning, and the chronic, of which obesity is the most significant. Then and now, I was both intrigued and shocked at the insidious impact that overweight and obesity is having on society: and it has not got better. I was a pupil at the first purpose-built comprehensive school in the UK. I invite noble Lords to do as I have recently and have a look at their school class photographs, and then look at their parents’ version and those of their own children, or perhaps even grandchildren. They will notice not just that the picture changes from black and white to colour and then to digital but that there is an alarming shift in the number of children frozen in time who are obviously preventably overweight, or worse. It gets worse the closer we get to today.
I can put some definitive numbers on the evidence of our eyes—the latest UK estimate is that obesity costs the NHS more than £9 billion a year—but, from my food policy perspective, the starkest evidence comes from the health inequalities now being observed. The Government’s own equality assessment specifically discusses obesity in this context. It records that children in the most deprived areas were more than twice as likely to be obese in reception and 2.3 times more likely by year 6 when compared with children in the least deprived areas. An obesity strategy implemented through the restructured NHS will have to be considered against our duty to reduce those inequalities.
Potentially more consequentially, the Bill moves substantial commissioning responsibility towards ICBs, including primary care, and establishes neighbourhood health plans. For obesity, that could mean a shift from nationally specified programmes to locally commissioned prevention and treatment. This matters enormously for obesity, because local variation in commissioning could produce new variation in access to NHS weight management services, weight management clinics, anti-obesity medicines, bariatric surgery pathways, diabetes and so on. Obesity was explicitly discussed during the Bill’s parliamentary scrutiny in the other place, when the Government’s obesity moonshot, weight loss medicines and the need for prevention were highlighted.
We should be in no doubt that the responsibility for the future health of the nation is at least shared with the food sector, which, to my concern, has yet to properly shoulder that responsibility. For your Lordships’ House, the Bill’s architecture potentially affects obesity policy, because the responsibility for population health and prevention sits within the wider NHS commissioning system, as well as in nearly every other government department.
It is a privilege to be one of your Lordships’ number. I look forward to actively contributing to the work of the House in the coming months and years, on both this Bill and our extensive workload.