L

Lord Smith of Ranmoor (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 15 October 2026

Debate

Food Security

Contribution

My Lords, I congratulate noble Baroness, Lady Teather, on securing this debate. I look forward to working with her and colleagues across your Lordships’ House on this vital issue. I declare an interest as the chairman of Cranswick plc, a large food processing and farming company. The United Kingdom cannot have genuine food security without profitable domestic farming, resilient supply chains and a thriving food manufacturing sector. Our ambition must be clear: sustainable, affordable, healthy food produced in a system that is fair for all. Our retailers understand that good-quality UK produce matters to their customers, but consumer demand alone cannot secure our food supply. That requires productive capacity, investment, infrastructure and consistent government policy. Food security is national security, and we should treat it accordingly. It is one of those issues we tend to notice only when something goes wrong. By then, the consequences are already felt in our farms, food businesses, supermarkets and, above all, household budgets. We cannot simply stop consuming food when supplies become scarce or prices rise, yet our food system is exposed to conflict, extreme weather, volatile energy, fertiliser costs, cyber attacks, trade disruptions and pressure on domestic production. The real test of food security, therefore, is not whether food is available when conditions are favourable; it is whether we can continue to produce, source, process and distribute it when they are not. Nor is a full supermarket shelf proof that a country is food secure. Food may be available but unaffordable. Imports may keep prices down in the short term while concealing an excessive dependence on overseas suppliers. We therefore need to consider four questions: do we have enough food? Can we maintain supplies when production of trade is disrupted? Can households afford what they need? Can people access the food that supports good health? They are not separate challenges. They are interconnected tests of whether our food system is genuinely resilient. Professor Lang, in his report, touches on most of those topics. A resilient food system begins with a productive domestic agriculture sector. If farming is not profitable, it is not sustainable, and if it is not sustainable, our food security is at risk. Farmers need the returns that allow them to invest in equipment, livestock, technology, soil health and infrastructure. They need confidence that government policy will remain sufficiently stable for long-term investment to make sense. That trust matters. We cannot expect farmers to invest for the next generation if they cannot predict the conditions under which they will operate over the next few years. Farms are strategic national assets, underpinning domestic production, traceability, food standards and our own capacity to respond to disruption. How well do we understand the productive infrastructure on which our food supply operates? Do we know where our crucial dairies, critical bakeries, protein processing facilities and cold stores are located? Where were the bananas that you ate today ripened? Do we understand the consequences if a major facility closes or an essential input becomes unavailable, and do we have credible contingency plans? Those questions are not considered optional in relation to energy or other critical infrastructure, so why should food be treated differently? Domestic production alone cannot guarantee food security. International trade remains essential. The answer is to strengthen our own productive capacity while diversifying the overseas sources on which we depend. Imports can supplement domestic resilience, but they cannot be a substitute for it. A country may have productive farms but remain vulnerable if it lacks the processing capacity to turn its output into food on supermarket shelves. Food manufacturing and distribution is not a secondary consideration but an integral part of our national food infrastructure. Yet we risk undermining that capacity through the very policies and constraints that prevent domestic businesses expanding. Consider chicken production. Demand has grown around 4.5% a year in the last three years but planning constraints have made it difficult to build the additional domestic capacity that is needed to satisfy that need. The result is that more of that demand is met by imports, including from Poland, the Netherlands, Brazil and Thailand. Those overseas imports have doubled since 2020, so we should ask why it has proved so difficult to secure investment in additional British production and resilience. There are investors who are ready to commit capital, there are plans, but there are other barriers preventing domestic capacity growing. There is a fundamental contradiction in making food security a policy priority while we obstruct the investment that is needed to deliver it. We cannot secure tomorrow’s food supply by exhausting the natural resources on which that supply depends. Climate change presents direct risks to agricultural productivity. Healthy soils, reliable water, biodiversity and effective land management are not simply environmental aspirations; they are the foundations of long-term productive capacity. We should reject the false choice between food production and environmental protection—neither can be secured sustainably by disregarding the other. Nor can we ignore the trade-offs involved in land use. Decisions about food production, nature recovery, energy generation and development have consequences. Those consequences must be understood and assessed together. Farmers need a coherent, long-term framework that rewards environmental stewardship while allowing viable agricultural businesses to produce food and invest in their future. Otherwise, we risk weakening domestic production in pursuit of objectives that depend, in turn, on a resilient domestic economy. One final important test, the one that matters most to families, is whether people can afford to eat well. Food security cannot be measured simply by national production figures, import volumes or the availability of calories. It must be measured also by whether households can afford a healthy diet. When food prices rise and household budgets come under pressure, the consequences extend well beyond the weekly shopping bill. They affect children’s development, health inequalities, productivity and long-term demands placed on the NHS. This is why food security must connect agricultural policy with public health, household incomes, food prices, public procurement and access to nutritious food. We must not create a false choice between affordable food and healthy food—or between improving nutrition and maintaining viable food businesses. Defra and my noble friend the Minister cannot deliver food security alone. This agenda crosses departmental boundaries, involving health, business, trade, energy, transport, education and local government. It also requires a close partnership between government and the businesses that produce, process and distribute our food. The country needs profitable farms, resilient food manufacturing, diversified international supply chains, a natural environment that sustains production and a food system capable of delivering affordable, healthy food to every household. Food security should not be an aspiration that we rediscover every time a crisis exposes our weaknesses. It must be a permanent test of how we make policy. The true measure of our food security is not whether the system works when everything is going well but whether it continues to work when things go wrong.

More from Lord Smith of Ranmoor (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.