Contribution
My Lords, I congratulate the noble Baroness, Lady Teather, on calling this timely and important debate and for her very comprehensive speech. The Prime Minister stated recently that national security must not come before social security, but the tone of this debate already indicates that, without food security, there can be no security at all. Indeed, the noble Lord, Lord Smith, set that out in his very knowledgeable contribution.
Our farmers produce 60% of our food. With government support, over the years they have worked to protect the sustainability of our land so that we can continue to have a reliable food supply in what is now, as we all know, an increasingly volatile geopolitical situation that threatens already fragile international supply chains. Global fuel shortages affect our food production, just as they do all industry. We have real and accelerating climate change deeply affecting—if anybody needs an example—this year’s harvest.
As has already been mentioned, in 2025 the National Preparedness Commission reported on the resilience of our food system. Professor Tim Lang, who has already been quoted, said that, while we continue to import food, our current food system is not sufficiently prepared to withstand inevitable future crises. If there is to be a defence readiness Bill, it must include a long-term plan for a strong and stable food supply system.
There seems to be an idea—I would welcome enlightenment from the Minister later—that the Government have suggested that local authorities might be given the task of providing food stores, as part of a food security plan. I really hope either that I am mistaken or that whoever said it was not speaking with authority, because all of us would agree that local government, being in total flux at the moment due to reorganisation, could not be entrusted with something as complex as a new system of food storage. I remind the House, although it does not need reminding, that we know almost nothing about the structure, functions and, above all, imminence of local government reform right now. If local government is to be given this vital task, those who produce our food should know what form it is likely to take. I apologise to the Minister, who may not be able to answer this—she can; great stuff! This should not need saying but, before we discuss food storage, should we not try to ensure that those who actually produce the food are given as much support and certainty as possible, so that they can continue that food production?
We know that farmers, by definition—people have already mentioned this—are accustomed to working with uncertainty, such as climate conditions and world events that affect supplies and prices. They plan not just for the following year but for several seasons ahead. But they need to be able to invest confidently and for the long term in land improvement, irrigation, water storage and livestock. This is not at all what the present Government have delivered so far for this the very core of our national security—our land, environment and food supply. What the Government have delivered is a series of shocks and policy changes, some of them literally at the last minute, driving farmers from the land and thereby threatening not only our food security but our rural communities. There has been a heavy price from this ill-thought-out policy. Last year saw the closure of more than 6,000 agricultural, forestry and fishing businesses.
A recent survey by the CLA, which has already been mentioned, has revealed what we knew would happen: namely, that the Government’s introduction of the inheritance tax changes on farmers has had a devastating effect on their confidence to invest. The same survey found that almost nine in 10 farmers have paused investment in order to avoid triggering the tax. Many have cancelled the creation of income-earning projects, such as the provision of holiday homes, farm shops and cafés—all of this cutting jobs in rural communities. Others are having to delay vital machinery purchases, irrigation and drainage schemes, farm-building repairs, and renewing animal stocks, resulting in the attrition of farming and our rural areas. I am sorry to say that every aspect of the rural economy, which is the staple of our food security and of the protection of our environment, has been affected by what is perceived in rural communities to be a Government which farmers feel are hostile to them.
This is not the way to improve our national security. That any Government should talk about plans for national security while threatening the livelihoods of those responsible for its main component, food security, is almost beyond belief. These are harsh words, and I know that the Minister has much understanding of the problems that the Government seem to have inflicted on rural communities. I know also that there have been some helpful changes, many of which have been mentioned, but I hope the Minister will be able to persuade her ministerial colleagues that, if they are serious about our national security, they will have to accept that without food security and what that means, they cannot claim to be protecting our nation.