B

Baroness Boycott (CB)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 15 October 2026

Debate

Food Security

Contribution

My Lords, I congratulate the noble Baroness, Lady Teather, on organising this debate. That was a terrific speech. Many of the things I would like to say she has already said, as indeed have the noble Lord, Lord Smith, and the noble Baroness, Lady Shephard. I agree with the point that the food system is not tested until things go wrong. To offer an anecdotal example, when the ghastly 7/7 attacks happened in London, there was no food because, rightly, the city was locked down. All the commuters who had arrived by train and by Tube were stuck inside London and there was not enough food. The only policy was apparently to ring the head of Marks & Spencer to ask for every single sandwich in the UK to be brought to London. Indeed, that is what happened and every sandwich was eaten and the following day everyone went home. That is an illustration that things can happen and we are not prepared. The noble Baroness, Lady Teather, briefly mentioned freezers. I hope everyone here has been reading about the cyber attack on French refrigerators in supermarkets. I was trying to look it up this afternoon, but they still have not said quite how much real, proper food has been destroyed in this way. In a way, we should not even be having a debate about whether we need more food security; we should be having a debate only about how we achieve that. We are very dependent. Some 80% of fruit, 47% of vegetables and 18 of our top 20 suppliers come from areas that are vulnerable. Just this spring, Sicily, Spain and Morocco were flooded, affecting enormous quantities of imports. These are foods that we have become very lazy about, with the attitude: “If we cannot grow it, someone else can. We can always shop”. Amazon makes it worse with a sense that everything is available to us all the time. But the answer is that it is not. We have to find ways to be more resilient. I am not arguing against trade; I am just arguing for resilience and for a food system that takes food back into communities, back to farmers, and makes decent wages for them. There are reports—these come again from Tim Lang, whom I think we will all quote, and with whom I have worked very closely over the last 20 years—that some parts of East Anglia have 15 or even just 10 harvests left because we have overworked the very precious stuff on which we all depend, and that is the soil. Actually, we have no food, if we do not have the soil—I think James Dyson has an answer about strawberries, but I do not know enough about that except to mention it. I do not think that growing food hydroponically in factories is an answer, either. What I want to advocate for is that the whole of our farming system tips towards regenerative agriculture. Indeed, I have put in a pitch to have a special inquiry on how this could be achieved. While I very much welcome the Government’s support of organic, the thing about regen is that it is not quite as tough as organic and, frankly, many people can get it. What does it mean to farm regeneratively? It means that you no longer go on completely digging the soil one-foot deep. One way of thinking about it is that, if you understand soil, you understand that it is a living community with millions of different interactions going on every second. It is truly magical. It is like being bombed every night. It is like the soil lives in the Blitz: you build your house and we smash it down. Somehow, it keeps on recovering, but only because of the addition of fertilisers, which are—thankfully, I sometimes think—currently stuck in the Strait of Hormuz. One of the things I do is that I am involved with the Groundswell regenerative agriculture festival. When it took place in June this year, when the first impacts were being felt, a number of farmers came to say, “How can I transition my farm? How can I go from this very high level of inputs to a place where I can get the soil and get nature to do the job for me?” Which is, in effect, what we are saying. The answer is that they need help. In that context, I would like to go back to when the Environment Act was going through under the previous Government and there was a big fight in this Chamber about what would be categorised as ELMS, the environmental land management scheme that was put in to replace the common agricultural policy, which, for all its ills and all the things it messed up, was basically a support for farmers for just owning the land. Now, if you get on to the ELMS, you get the SFI, which is soil, pests and biodiversity, you get the Countryside Stewardship scheme, and you get the Landscape Recovery scheme, which you can claim for. But if you just want to get money for growing food, the argument back then was, “You can’t do that because food makes money”. But citing Tim Lang again, the farmer gets roughly 8p in every £1 that you spend on food. It is no wonder that they are, as the noble Baroness, Lady Shephard, said, setting up weddings in their barns and renting out cottages. I have nothing against that, but we should pay for the food we have. Food at its best goes back to communities, and one of the other things that is very bad about the subsidy systems is that you cannot support the small farms. Small farms, intensively grown, can produce both good salaries and a lot of food. I was at Jersey’s regenerative agriculture conference the other day, where I met the nut farmer of Glastonbury. He has only five acres and had enough family money to tide himself over for seven years. He is now supporting four workers and his family on a few acres of production. It is a great story and a replicable story as well. I have chaired Feeding Britain and put together Capital Growth in this city. We have 200 acres of London that were nothing and now produce food. We produce something like 200,000 tonnes of food per year. That is probably an exaggeration, but it really works. I want to see the Government revisit the way in which we subsidise and help people transition across from very traditional farming. I go back to Groundswell as an example. The farm is run by two brothers and it is a great story. It is like a parable. One brother does completely regen and the other brother still does traditional. You can walk from one farm to the other. Over this year, in the drought, the one who did regen farming still had water and crops and had spent no money on his input. His yield was not massive but, on the other hand, the spend on his balance sheet was almost zero. On the other side of the fence, there was drought and there were crops dying. With regenerative, you use animals and everything at your disposal and you do mob grazing, which honestly could be done by a robot, with cattle moving across the land, eating only the top inch of grass so you never wear it out completely. It is revolutionary, because at the same time you get insects, biodiversity and extraordinary food. I have one minute left and anyone who knows me well knows that I constantly bang on about ultra-processed food. We must change the way we eat, localise it and put more abattoirs and local networks in. Someone was talking about how you get access to the City and the lunacy of having to come into Covent Garden. When I chaired the London Food Board, we tried hard to set up hubs mirroring what they do in New York, which has a fantastic centre at the top of New York City that takes produce from all over New York State and distributes it around the city. It is fantastic. It means that farmers get 40p in the pound rather than 8p in the pound. We can do all this stuff with a bit of government thinking, changing the way that we use the money. The point is that everyone benefits. You benefit the kids, you benefit the people, you benefit health and, ultimately, you benefit the soil. The soil doing its stuff is the best carbon sink in the world; there is nothing to beat it for just absorbing carbon and keeping us on a net-zero track. So it seems to me that it is a win-win and the other way is a lose-lose.

More from Baroness Boycott (CB)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.