Contribution
My Lords, it is a huge privilege to open this debate. Food security is incredibly complex. Addressing it has also never been more pressing. We now face multiple global threats that could create profound food shocks—shocks that will fall unequally on our population. The question is how we can best prepare as a nation and make our food system more resilient.
Planning effective interventions on food security requires us to think systemically across silos—from farming and the environment to foreign and defence policy, international trade, public health, local government, planning regulations, business logistics, behavioural science and much more besides. I am certainly no expert in all these areas, but one thing I have learnt as a new Member is that breadth of expertise is something this House has in spades. I suggested this title for debate because this kind of urgent, vital and knotty challenge plays to the strengths of the House. I am grateful to noble Lords who have given their time and experience to participate, and I look forward to hearing what they have to say.
As the topic is huge, I want to focus my remarks on three areas: first, the threats to our food system and our national response; secondly, efforts to build resilience for the longer term; and thirdly, the need to involve the whole of society in the effort.
Multiple reports in recent years have warned that the UK is dangerously unprepared for potentially catastrophic shocks to our food system. Professor Tim Lang’s impressive report for the National Preparedness Commission last year paints a comprehensive picture of current vulnerabilities. The National Audit Office warned last month that the sector’s ability to withstand events has not been tested. Farmers tell us that climate change is already a reality, creating huge unpredictability. Crops this year have been affected by drought, flooding, excessive rain and extreme heat, which of course has sometimes made it too hot to harvest. While some yields have held up, we have seen the worst cereal harvest on record, and with a supercharged El Niño, it is only likely to get worse. The Joint Intelligence Committee has given stark warnings about the potential for the collapse of ecosystems within five years and the threat to national security and food supply.
In addition, there are new crises emerging. Attacks on international shipping in the Strait of Hormuz have sharply increased the cost of diesel and fertiliser for UK farmers, and threaten critical shortages in Africa and Asia, from which we import. Of course, Hormuz is not the only international choke point we should worry about. We have seen cyber attacks on supermarkets and distributors. This week, the director-general of MI5 warned about the risk of AI-enabled drone attacks on UK soil, a real concern when almost 95% of retail food moves through just 131 distribution centres.
In this new reality, it is naive to assume that private sector switching of supply chains alone will be enough to keep food flowing. It is certainly the case that supermarkets responded with impressive speed to maintain supplies during Covid, but Covid also exposed structural failings in our system, which we have not yet addressed. First, adequate food supply does not equate to all the people being fed. The Food Foundation estimates that one in eight households are already food insecure. I saw during Covid, while I was running a charity for people facing destitution, that global food shocks fall unequally and can have devastating health impacts. Secondly, none of the national food security assessments considers how the public might actually behave in a food shock scenario. The flipside of highly optimised, just-in-time logistics is that very small changes in consumer behaviour can quickly empty shelves. Thirdly, the same efficient logistics have all but eliminated the need for storage. We could have just a few days of food available in the face of a catastrophic interruption to supply.
We import around 40% of our food and more than 80% of our fruit. It is vital that we increase the proportion of food that we grow in the UK, but this is only part of the story. Food ingredients are often passed along lengthy, tortuous supply chains before they end up on the plate, with processing, manufacturing and distribution happening in different locations. Disruptions anywhere can cascade and amplify along the route. Given this context, our national assessment of risk looks dangerously complacent. The national risk register, for example, has very little on the food system and, where it does consider food, the focus is on risk of contamination rather than interruptions to supply or access.
So, what is needed? First, the Cabinet Office frankly needs to up its game and update the way in which we assess and think about food security in the light of the new threats. We need a special national risk register study that includes consideration of public reactions and dynamics. Secondly, the Government’s post-implementation review of the Civil Contingencies Act provides an opportunity to integrate food resilience and to think about the kinds of structures that we need at local and regional level to co-ordinate efforts. Local areas need plans to get food to the vulnerable and an understanding of community assets and networks that could help. We also need a more grown-up conversation with the public than a website telling people to stock up on tins. Thirdly, while there are legal duties to ensure that food is safe, there are no duties to ensure that everyone gets fed. It really is not clear who would hold responsibility for this in a crisis. Finally, we need a rapid assessment of what storage is available at national, regional and local levels and a plan to improve it. This is not an easy fix. Can the Government convene a cross-sector taskforce, for example, to wrestle with it? Other countries, everywhere from Switzerland to China, have national stores and many European nations are developing plans to store food.
A key theme from Professor Lang’s report for the National Preparedness Commission was the need to move our peacetime food system to a more distributed and diverse model, to boost domestic production and to enhance regional food systems. The UK is unusual in having an underdeveloped regional food system compared with, say, France or Italy.
Long-term sustainability in our food system depends on protecting the natural resources that farming depends on—soil health and biodiversity—and transitioning from reliance on globally imported fertiliser. Yesterday, the Government published a new Organic Action Plan for England, to boost the share of food farmed organically. My first reading of it suggests that there is much in it that is welcome, including backing organic farming to boost resilience to climate change. We have to support farmers to transition to new ways of farming. That means backing those willing to experiment with organic and regenerative farming models that focus on soil health and are not tied to inorganic fertilisers. We must fund rigorous scientific research into crop yields, soil, nature and profitability and share those lessons widely.
However, the new organic plan also leaves lots of questions. There has been exasperation from farmers at the chaos of the sustainable farming incentive scheme. Small growers told me that, even if the scheme had been well managed, it left them out by design. They are a critical component of a regional food system and often already farming in sustainable ways. For example, Vallis Veg in Somerset, an established small farm, told me that the economics of the food system currently relies on farmers in effect exploiting themselves. Its owners are deeply committed to agroecological farming but do not have the resources to certify as organic, which the organic action plan acknowledges is a problem. Vallis Veg’s commitment to the cause extends to supporting new entrants. It provides a small plot of land for free to a local grower to run a market garden, who is allowed to live on site for below-market rent, but even with all that generosity he struggles to make a living. According to a recent McCain Foods survey, one in four farmers made a loss or barely broke even in the past year, and two in five considered quitting farming altogether. We know that those financial pressures are particularly acute for small farmers. Those who make it work often rely on additional funding streams.
The inspirational Prospects Trust on the Cambridge-Suffolk border includes an accessible nature reserve, organic farm, shop and retail outlet and provides placements for people with learning disabilities or autism, funded through social care. It employs 51 local people part time and grows delicious fruit and veg. Over decades, it has built trusted relationships with a local organic wholesaler and a Cambridge college chef willing to cook veg that it cannot sell elsewhere, reducing food waste. It told me that relationships are key to its ability to adapt to shifting weather, because constant communication allows it to agree with the customer on what it can crop. It is a remarkable success story, but there was frustration that it could not access the agricultural water resilience grant to replace its leaky irrigation system because it could not quickly raise the 50% capital contribution needed. Can the Minister say what the Government will do to support small farms such as these?
Incidentally, Cambridge is an example of a city with a vibrant local food partnership, much enthusiasm and fertile arable land. But without capital investment in the missing middle of infrastructure on storage and distribution, it is difficult to turn ambition into a functioning regional food system. The founder of the fledgling Cambridge Food Hub has been trying to secure investment for that missing middle for 13 years. He illustrated the problem that he is seeking to fix by explaining that, even though one of the largest strawberry farmers in the country is based just outside the city, local businesses must buy their produce from New Covent Garden Market. That means that fruit grown six miles away must travel 120 miles—Cambridge to London and then back to Cambridge—in a refrigerated lorry. That is madness.
It is worth contrasting that with the success of the Welsh Veg in Schools initiative. With Welsh Government backing, Food Sense Wales to broker deals and local infrastructure donated by Castell Howell, local growers have been able to co-ordinate what they grow. More veg is being grown and local farms now supply over half of Wales’s councils.
The new organic action plan restates the Government’s ambitions to use public sector procurement to support domestic growing and it references Sustain’s Bridging the Gap programme, but it is short on detail about how the Government will invest in the so-called missing middle infrastructure to make regional food systems fly. Will the Minister tell me what plans her department has to make good on Labour’s 2024 manifesto pledge to boost local food procurement?
The final theme that I want to touch on is how we can ensure that our efforts on food security involve the whole of society. We have a long-standing problem with food inequality and it is getting worse. The Government announced small pots of funding for the Good Food Neighbourhoods programme to tackle fruit and veg deserts, but what is missing is a coherent national strategy with teeth that draws together public health, planning policy, housing strategies, local government, agricultural policy and public attitudes.
Now is the moment for a good food Bill—something that covers the full arc of the food system, allowing co-ordinated decision-making at national and local levels. It would allow us to set targets on childhood obesity, food security and domestic production and would provide certainty about the direction of travel for farmers, businesses, investors and consumers. It would also kick-start a consultation about what we mean when we talk about a healthy nutritious sustainable diet. What would a reference diet look like? What implications would it have for our agricultural strategy? What needs to shift in public attitudes if we are to consume more of the foods that we can grow here, such as beans and pulses? A consensus on these elements would guide policy-making priorities in peacetime, but it would also be critical in an emergency.
Joined-up policy-making would also give more creative projects a chance, such as peri-urban growing and land for community gardens and allotments. No one is arguing that community growing projects will fill the gap in domestic production, but what it can do is build solidarity, narrow the distance between farmers and urban populations, build knowledge and shape attitudes to what we eat and cook. In the end, in an emergency, it is only communities acting together that can provide civil resilience. Everything we do now to invest in conditions for deeper community bonds will reap dividends.
The need to address Britain’s food security cannot wait. I look forward to the Minister’s response and the debate. I beg to move.