B

Baroness Watkins of Tavistock (CB)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 13 October 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, it is a pleasure to contribute to the debate and to have heard the previous maiden speeches. I look forward to the subsequent ones and note the great increase in representation not only from the north but in mental health, which everybody knows is my interest. I am very pleased to see that. I want to say one thing before starting on what I have written. We have talked a lot about patients, but actually the public fund the NHS. The young in particular —people aged 20 to 40—use it relatively little, yet many of them contribute significantly. We are seeing complaints across Europe from younger people because they are not getting what they think they are paying for, either in education or in other areas. We have to be really explicit about what the NHS will provide for everybody from the centre, so that we do not get too much differentiation as delegation occurs. Otherwise, we will lose the commitment that those of us who have been supportive of the service for so long assume that the next generation want. I just want to put that on record. I am really supportive of this Bill. I have some concerns about the ability of the health service to monitor, investigate and learn from its own performance with the new structures. I believe we have a responsibility to do that because, during a period of huge change, the health system needs to have in place the ability to monitor its effects and to flex and change to ensure that two things happen: that our manpower planning is right and that productivity increases because of the use of technology. If we do not, we will not be able to deliver. Although I agree with much of Penny Dash’s review, like many others I do not believe that the HSSIB should be put into the CQC at the moment. Its predecessor, the Healthcare Safety Investigation Branch, was established following the Francis inquiry into Mid Staffs. Its purpose was clear: to provide independent, expert investigations into patient safety and to identify the systematic factors that contribute to patient harm. That independence is fundamental. The body investigates without apportioning blame or liability. It has worked hard to create a safe environment in which healthcare professionals can speak openly about safety concerns. As a nurse, and through my conversations with colleagues across the NHS, I know that the CQC is perceived very differently. I urge the Government to consider whether this is the right way forward. I am pleased that the Secretary of State confirmed that there will be a maternity commissioner but, as the noble Lord, Lord Bradley, said, there may be a need for commissioners in other areas. I would support a further amendment allowing the Secretary of State to appoint commissioners in other areas of healthcare when significant concerns arise. Giving them this flexibility would allow expert commissioners to ensure that lessons are learned and, crucially, that recommendations are acted upon. We are waiting for several reports into severe problems in mental health services; this is an example of where I would like to see that flexibility when those come out. I strongly welcome the commitment to the single patient record. If properly implemented, it could definitely improve continuity of care, reduce duplication and ensure clinicians have the information they require. That would be a significant step forward but, as other noble Lords have expressed, the amount of detailed personal information that will be shared across different parts of the health service, and indeed in legal services, may have to be carefully thought about. I would like to see an opportunity for advanced directives to be fully incorporated into the patient record, so that it is very straightforward in emergency care, and in end-of-life care, to address what patients really want. Finally, I thank the Minister for her letter, which I received this morning and therefore incorporated into my last words. It related to a question I had previously asked about whether the mental health investment standard should be put on a statutory footing. The reply from the Government was clear that this funding is a priority and that it does not need to be stipulated in primary legislation. A probing amendment may be necessary on this issue, because such reassurance may not withstand a change of Administration in future years.

More from Baroness Watkins of Tavistock (CB)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.