Contribution
My Lords, no Bill this Session will matter more to the health of the nation. I say at the outset that I welcome the Bill and the principles behind it. Whatever the aims in creating NHS England, the way in which it was set up and run makes accountability hard to place. It has added to what was already considerable bureaucracy. That is no criticism of the many exceptional professionals who have worked and continue to work in NHS England, but the Government are right to ask whether a different structure could deliver better outcomes for patients, at lower cost and greater speed.
We should also be honest about the costs of reorganisations. We have had many of them, and each takes longer to bed in than we seem to allow before the next one arrives. There is no perfect structure for the NHS; what it needs is one that is good enough and stable enough to let its people get on with their work. I hope that the Government will now set out plainly how the new system will work in practice and then complete the changes quickly.
I shall focus the rest of my remarks on three things: prevention, patient voice and integrated care boards. On prevention, the main drivers of our health lie well beyond the health system. Our health is shaped largely by the food we eat, the air we breathe, the homes we live in and the work we do. Too often, the poorest communities have the least healthy food, the most polluted air, the worst housing and the most insecure work. The 10-year health plan is clear that prevention must play a far greater role in improving the nation’s health. The plan’s goal to halve the gap in healthy life expectancy between the richest and poorest regions will not be reached via a hospital door.
I worry that the Bill is not yet explicit enough about this. It creates space for preventive work, commissioned by integrated care boards; it brings local authority and mayoral members on to those boards, but it does not make it plain that moving resources towards prevention, broadly understood, sits firmly within the expanded remit of ICBs.
Some will say that that space has always been there, yet time and again, the chance to fund prevention is lost to the demands of ever more expensive clinical care. In his 2024 investigation of the NHS, the noble Lord, Lord Darzi, found that the share of the NHS budget spent on hospitals rose from 47% in 2006 to 58% in 2022. Successive Governments have promised the opposite. Meanwhile, in the last decade, the public health grant was cut by more than a quarter per person in real terms.
The Bill gives the Secretary of State a new duty to promote innovation. It restates the duty to reduce health inequalities. Prevention has no equivalent duty, and this House has no good way to see whether money is moving towards it.
There is a precedent from this House for a clearer approach. In 2022, after pressure from noble Lords, including my noble friend the Minister, the then Government added a duty to their Health and Care Act. Each year, the Secretary of State must now publish whether NHS spending on mental health is expected to rise, both in cash terms and as a share of the total. That simple act of transparency keeps mental health spending in front of Parliament every year. I ask the Government to consider something similar for prevention: a clear duty and an annual statement of what the NHS and ICBs expect to spend on prevention, so that we can all see whether the shift the 10-year health plan promises is happening. Will my noble friend say whether this is something the Government will consider?
On patient voice, I have seen how local Healthwatch organisations up and down the country play a valuable role in raising the concerns of the communities they serve. Bringing that role closer to the centre creates a chance to champion those voices better, but it also carries an obvious risk that fewer voices are heard. The voices most at risk are those that are already heard the least.
I look forward to working with the Government to strike the right balance: fewer bodies capturing patient voice, real independence, the full diversity of voices still heard and a clear line from what people raise to what changes. I have also heard from patients who are worried about how the single patient record will work in practice. They see strong local voices as a key safeguard.
Finally, with the number of integrated care boards being reduced by a third, their running costs to be halved and with new commissioning duties such as screening, vaccinations and the work of local Healthwatches, many ICBs have rightly warned that they risk ending up with more to do and far less capacity to do it. In such cases, experience suggests that things that are deemed discretionary, such as prevention spending and listening to patients, are often the first to suffer.
I would appreciate it if my noble friend the Minister could set out what discussions the Government have had with ICB chief executives and chairs about the enabling measures they need to take a genuinely preventive, community-rooted approach. That is the shift from sickness to prevention that the 10-year health plan promises. This Bill is our best chance to make that shift real.