B

Baroness Hodgson of Abinger (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 13 October 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I declare an interest as chair of the governance board of ISCAS, the Independent Sector Complaints Adjudication Service. I too congratulate noble Lords on their excellent maiden speeches. These proposed changes create the largest NHS reorganisation in over a decade. While healthcare reform is to be welcomed where it improves patient outcomes, systems alterations can cause confusion. Ultimately, we need to evaluate whether the changes will improve patient care and ensure accountability. There is concern that the Bill will overcentralise decision-making and weaken independent challenge. Indeed, former Labour Minister the noble Lord, Lord Darzi, who led this Government’s investigation into the state of the NHS in England in 2024, said that “a top-down reorganisation of NHS England and integrated care boards is neither necessary nor desirable”. There has been much discussion about the creation of a single patient record and its potential to improve continuity, efficiency and patient safety. Clearly, there are many potential advantages, but only if we ensure robust safeguards around privacy. While medical professionals have a duty of confidentiality, it is important that personal information does not get into the wrong hands. It is a question not just of data security but of public trust. Does the Bill help the GP system, the most vital part of our health system but at present under huge strain? A good GP service with continuity of care is crucial to aid prevention and thus decrease need. Studies show that, where GPs know their patients, admittance to hospital is lower, patients are less likely to die and their health is better. Today, many of our hospital A&E departments are overwhelmed by people who cannot get in to see their GPs, who appear to be asked to take on too many patients. We need to enable GPs to have the tools and time to do the job properly. Like many, I am concerned about the proposed abolition of Healthwatch. An independent patient voice is essential for accountability. Surely, transferring this into an ICB could create a conflict of interest. Indeed, some suggest that it is tantamount to marking their own homework. Complaints need to be used for learning, but there is a tendency in many areas of healthcare not to be open when things go wrong, and challenging a service and addressing issues honestly can be used to improve care. I therefore urge the Minister to ensure that Healthwatch stays independent, and is improved and strengthened. The Bill should be an opportunity to improve the way in which medical negligence is dealt with, in terms of both finance and the patient experience. Inevitably, from time to time, things go wrong, and in those cases patients or their relatives should receive compensation. The National Audit Office estimated that the accumulated clinical negligence liabilities as of 31 March last year were £60 billion. That figure has quadrupled since 2006-07, making it the second largest provision on the government balance sheet after nuclear decommissioning. In 2025-26, medical negligence cost over £3.2 billion. Not only is that a huge amount that could be spent on care, but the years it takes for a patient to bring a case to court add hugely to the stress and distress. The annual cost to settle claims has more than tripled over the last two decades, and often the legal costs for claims under £25,000 vastly exceed the damages payable to claimants. Plans to control claimant legal costs by limiting the recoverable amount in lower-value damages cases have not been implemented following the change of Government in 2024. Can the Minister say why? Surely, we should be setting up a commission under an independent chair which includes clinicians, patient and legal representation to review the present situation and come up with a better model that would cut legal costs and give patients swifter resolution. Of all the negligence costs, a significant proportion—42% in 2024-25, amounting to £1.3 billion—are paid out on maternity claims. The maternity failures highlighted by the Ockenden reviews and the Amos national maternity and neonatal investigations are truly shocking. The 2019 civil partnerships, marriages and deaths Bill required the Secretary of State to prepare a report on whether the law should be changed to enable coroners to investigate babies dying at birth. What happened to this report? It also gave the Lord Chancellor powers to amend the Coroners and Justice Act 2009 to enable coroners to investigate. This would stop the apparent present culture of cover-up in so many hospitals. The negative situation regarding maternity leads one to question how efficiently hospitals function in other specialties and what the situation is regarding unnecessary deaths. It raises questions about the effectiveness of the CQC inspections. Is it really wise to transfer the Health Services Safety Investigations Body into the CQC at this time, potentially weakening the independence of patient safety investigations? We need to make sure that we spend the healthcare budget in the most effective way to meet patients’ needs. Thus we must ensure any changes to healthcare through this Bill actually improve the system, lower costs and deliver results in better patient experiences and outcomes, not just rearrange the deckchairs. As others have already quoted in the other place, Winston Churchill once said: “Healthy citizens are the greatest asset any country can have”.

More from Baroness Hodgson of Abinger (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.