Contribution
My Lords, I join others in congratulating those who made their maiden speeches and extend my commiserations to the noble Lord, Lord Singh, who has drawn the short straw in speaking as the last maiden speaker—but it is excellent to have another medic in the House. I declare my interest as an independent adviser to DHSC. As a paediatrician and somebody who has spent much of my career advocating for children and young people within the health system, it will not come as any surprise that I wish to focus my remarks on the implications of this Bill for children.
On the broad aims of the Bill, there is a strong case for simplifying structures, improving accountability and making better use of data. Like many others, I welcome the ambition behind the proposed single patient record, but with all the health warnings given by my colleagues, particularly the noble Lord, Lord Tarassenko, and others. None the less, we have to move on from a situation where Alexa knows within minutes that we are thinking about buying a new toaster but our GP may not know for several days that we have been diagnosed with cancer. In particular, there is real potential to improve continuity of care, particularly for children and young people with complex needs.
Many people have discussed all the operational practicalities of the Bill, but for me one particular concern kept recurring: children are largely absent from it. This matters because this Bill arrives at a troubling time for child health. The recently published State of Child Health report, produced by the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health, paints a sobering picture. Across a wide range of indicators, progress has stalled or gone into reverse. Vaccination rates have fallen; rates of childhood obesity are climbing, as the noble Lord, Lord Smith, told us; mental health difficulties have increased; and many health outcomes remain strongly associated with deprivation.
Most troubling of all is that the inequalities begin early and can persist throughout life. Children growing up in the poorest communities experience worse outcomes from the very start. Infant mortality is more than twice as high in the most deprived areas compared to the least deprived, and far too many children continue to face poorer physical and mental health simply because of where they were born and grew up. By the time a child starts school, substantial differences in health and development have often already emerged. So, if this Bill is intended to create a more accountable health system, it should also help us understand whether those inequalities are narrowing or widening.
A health system should be judged not just by how well it treats illness but by how effectively it supports all children to have the healthiest possible start in life. This raises a fundamental question: if the purpose of the Bill is to strengthen accountability in the NHS, accountability for what? Much of the discussion has focused on structures—the abolition of NHS England, the transfer of functions and the relationship between national and local bodies—but structures are not an end in themselves; the purpose of those structures is to improve health outcomes.
As the Bill progresses, I hope we can explore how children’s health outcomes can be made more visible within these new arrangements. We should know whether outcomes are improving, whether inequalities are narrowing and whether children are receiving timely access to the services they need. In that context, I will lay amendments that seek to ensure that waiting times for children are not lost within broader NHS performance measures. Delayed treatment in childhood can have consequences that extend far into adult life. It is right that we consider whether the new arrangements provide sufficient visibility and accountability for children’s access to care.
I also hope that we will consider how children and young people’s voices and interests will be represented within the new structures. Children often have little direct influence over the services they use, yet decisions made during childhood can shape health trajectories for decades. This Bill will reshape how the NHS is governed, and it therefore provides a valuable opportunity to ask not only how the system is organised but what outcomes it seeks to achieve. Children may occupy only a small part of the Bill, but they will live longest with its consequences. So I hope that, as the Bill progresses through this House, we can ensure that improving child health and reducing child health inequalities become a more explicit part of its purpose.