B

Baroness Cass (CB)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 11 November 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I am sorry that the noble Baroness, Lady Walmsley, is not able to be in her place this evening. I had the privilege of serving on the Childhood Vaccinations Committee, which she very ably chaired. I think it will produce a report which Members of the House will find informative and helpful, and I hope the Government will feel similarly. During the course of that report, we spent a long time talking about the relative impact of problems in access and in vaccine hesitancy. Within vaccine hesitancy, multiple different factors affect how parents feel about vaccinating their child. Among those is medical disinformation. We need to understand more about that and what vaccination and the risks mean to different communities and cultures. Much of that work happens on the ground, on the front line, with community leaders, health visitors and GPs working locally. However, that is not a reason for us not to take a national strategic approach. The second reason I signed this amendment is that it uses the term “medical disinformation strategy” and talks about anti-vaccination and medical disinformation. The Government need to think about how we tackle medical disinformation much more broadly than just within the vaccine arena. I have talked often enough in this House about my review, but I have not on any occasion put on record what it felt like to do that review and, more particularly, what it felt like and has continued to feel like in the two years since. The disinformation about my review started six hours before the report was released. It was a funded disinformation campaign, and it continues to date. One of the extraordinary things that were said was that I did not speak to any trans people during the review. We spoke to the support and advocacy groups every four weeks and I spoke to the gender clinicians working at the Tavistock every two weeks. It was said that we threw out 98% of the papers on the subject, which was clearly nonsense. It was said that we did not publish the name of the author of the review—and what did “CASS” stand for, by the way? That was probably one of the most extraordinary ones. Then there are those that I take less seriously, which are more recent, on why I have supported the puberty blocker trial. These range from my being the victim of a Russian kompromat, having a trans child of my own, and—this is the best one—that somebody has kidnapped my cat and is holding it to ransom. I am not particularly concerned about the personal attacks, of which there are many, but I am concerned about the disinformation that misleads children, young people, families and clinicians who are looking after them. During those last two years after the review, I worked first for NHS England. I declare that I am currently an independent adviser for the DHSC. Colleagues have been supportive, but the burden of what to do about the direct disinformation at the end of the day rested with me. DSIT, as it was, seemed to be the locus of how we dealt with disinformation at that time, but it did not own the strategy, and neither did NHS England or the DHSC—although the DHSC has been very supportive in trying to get a communication strategy in more recent times. My point in going through all this is not as a “poor me” about my experiences, but because it should never come as a surprise to us that there is disinformation, which is going to be an increasing problem going forward. It is no more surprising than bed pressures and flu in winter. Therefore, I suggest to the Minister, who has been exceptionally supportive to me over these matters, that, in thinking about the structures of the NHS, we need to consider strategically how we will be prepared for disinformation strategies, not just in vaccine services or gender services but in many areas as they arise.

More from Baroness Cass (CB)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.