Contribution
My Lords, I also welcome the maiden speeches of noble Lords. I thank them for their wise words and look forward to them contributing to your Lordships’ House in the future.
I come to this Bill as a former NHS manager, which will not endear me to many people—I understand that. I started my career in the early 1990s, and I have lost count of the number of reorganisations since: fundholding, health authorities, primary care trusts, strategic health authorities, clinical commissioning groups, integrated care boards and now the abolition of NHS England. Each arrived promising less bureaucracy and a freer front line. The King’s Fund calls this
“the largest reorganisation of the NHS in more than a decade”,
and it reminds us that structural reform alone can be
“a huge distraction and rarely improves care”.
I have lived through that distraction. Leadership time for years goes on new boards, new boundaries and people reapplying for their own jobs, not focusing on patients and improving health outcomes.
So let us start with simple questions: who is using the NHS and why? What can we do about it and where? Waiting lists remain stubbornly high—above 6 million. Healthy life expectancy has fallen to around 61. Neither is caused by organisational names on a letterhead; the answer lies in social care, in children’s early years and in prevention and early diagnosis. NHS structures are not the answer to those numbers, and any Government or Health Minister who think so are deluded.
So what is in this Bill? First, there is a power grab. The Secretary of State takes many of NHS England’s functions: powers to direct ICBs, even when they are performing well, as well as powers to remove an ICB chief executive and direct the chair on who should replace them. That is not accountability; that is political patronage. It also invites political interference in where capital is spent and directions on operational matters. Any such powers must be targeted, proportionate and subject to robust guardrails. I will test this Bill against those standards in Committee.
Meanwhile, ICBs have been ordered to halve their running costs—some 12,500 posts to be deleted—yet the Bill gives them new duties, not just in commissioning but in other things as well. Who will be able to act on those new powers with half the staff? A whole tier will be hollowed out, asked to do more, with inevitable inability to deliver. And what will happen? A consultancy tsunami and extra cost are on the way.
Then here comes the farce. Last week, ICBs were told that most planned cluster mergers will not go ahead next April; footprints must wait until 2028. The operational model is really still not there. Now we read that NHS England may go into the department or be a stand-alone body. Cut first, plan later. That is not strategy; it will cause health and planning chaos.
Patient safety is my deepest worry. The Bill moves the work of the Health Services Safety Investigations Body into the Care Quality Commission. First, does the HSSIB not have powers to investigate the CQC? How does that work in this new world of the Bill? The CQC itself warned in May of a conflict of interest. Staff speak up because the safe space is at risk. The Minister needs to understand this is a dangerous move and will seriously diminish patient safety. This is an area that I am sure I and others will return to in Committee.
On the single patient record, I support the principle: no patient should have to repeat their story, and technology only transforms care when it reaches the bedside. But trust is earned, not legislated. As reported in the Health Service Journal today, nearly 100,000 people have opted out of NHS data sharing this year alone amid mounting controversy over Palantir. Questions of who controls the data and who is accountable remain deeply unclear. The public need to be reassured on these issues, and the Minister must tell us plainly what role Palantir will play—and how its involvement will not cause further erosion of public trust.
I will judge the Bill through my own family’s experience—does it improve the healthcare and outcomes of people with learning disabilities? The noble Baroness, Lady Hollins, gave the statistics, so I will not go further, but it will be a point I will return to in Committee.
Changing the name of who issues directives will not improve healthcare and outcomes. Only stable leadership, focusing on commissioning the right things, along with true local autonomy and real accountability, will have significant impact. The Bill if left as it is will be another missed opportunity. That is why I will work to amend it in Committee, to make it fit for purpose and to improve healthcare and outcomes.