Contribution
My Lords, I, too, congratulate the noble Lords making their maiden speeches today. I also congratulate my noble friend the Minister on introducing this very important Bill with such clarity and commitment.
Having served in the NHS as a front-line doctor for nearly 40 years, I believe this bold and transformative Health Bill offers a significant opportunity to modernise healthcare and tackle our nation’s persistent health inequalities. There is much in the Bill that I welcome and many areas that I would like to expand upon, but in the interest of time, I shall touch on four areas.
First, the abolition of NHS England is long overdue. Transferring its functions to the Secretary of State and integrated care boards removes unnecessary bureaucracy, as we have heard, and brings decisions and resources closer to patients and to where they will have the greatest impact on patient safety. These reforms could save £1 billion annually.
The abolition of NHS England means the abolition of one of the largest quangos. As a consultant who has worked for more than three decades, I have worked closely with NHS England and have seen too many tick boxes, too many checklists, too much bureaucracy and decisions not being made. I welcome this significant step. I am pleased that the direct commissioning functions are being transferred to ICBs with an aim to deliver a population health improvement plan for the whole area. The ICBs that are accountable for this must turn this ambition into action.
The single patient record is the highlight of the Bill. As we have heard from many noble Lords, it will improve patient experiences and outcomes. In my view, it is more likely to help retain doctors and nurses who are leaving the NHS because of the frustration of fragmented notes and the medical legal risk. It could also save around £20 million a year from reduced medical errors, reduced adverse drug reactions and duplicate prescribing, alongside better co-ordination of community services and an estimated 20,000 fewer A&E visits.
Of course, as we have heard, the strongest safeguards must be put in place for security, privacy and public trust. I welcome the reassurances from my noble friend the Minister on this and that clinicians will not be authorised to access an individual’s record without a legitimate clinical need.
However, I am concerned about the lack of clarity around sharing notes from private healthcare. Patients increasingly move between NHS and private healthcare—their medical history should move with them. I therefore ask for reassurances that there will be provision for patients receiving private treatment to have their care data shared for the single patient record.
I particularly welcome the duty to promote and reward innovation within our NHS. We have a proud history of innovation in the NHS. In my own field of women’s health, the development of IVF and the introduction of ultrasound in obstetrics and gynaecology were innovations which transformed lives globally, but now it is difficult for front-line clinicians to innovate. Innovation cannot depend on exhausted clinicians doing research in their spare time. They need protected time, support and opportunities to develop ideas into research that improves outcomes and reduces costs. If Britain wants to remain an innovation nation, the NHS must not simply adopt innovation; it must drive it. We need further clarification on the promotion and rewarding of innovation in the Bill.
Finally, neighbourhood health is an area about which I feel particularly strongly. The plans are welcome, but local health needs can truly be understood only if all stakeholders are involved in shaping those plans. I therefore urge the Government to ensure that voluntary, community and social enterprise organisations are closely involved in these plans and are represented on health and well-being boards.
The Bill can deliver a modern and efficient NHS, it can create growth and prosperity in every region, and it has the ability to tackle health inequalities. I look forward to discussing the Bill in Committee and contributing to the debate, and to supporting the Bill throughout its passage through your Lordships’ House.