Contribution
My Lords, I do not doubt for one moment that the Government are very well intentioned in bringing forward the Bill, and there are measures in it that I support. Like others, my worry is that it is heavy on structural reorganisation without yet a clear sense of how patients will benefit. I want to be fair-minded, and I thought that the Minister set it out very thoughtfully and rooted her comments in patient experience, which was appreciated. However, we know that structural reform does not automatically improve culture. Safety and trust are built by people, and I thought that the noble Lord, Lord Winston, spoke very movingly about the way people experience healthcare when it goes right and when it goes wrong, and we need to remember that.
I genuinely hope that we can improve the Bill to ensure that the patient’s voice is not drowned out and that it genuinely improves outcomes. Obviously, this applies to all patients, but in the time allowed I want to focus on maternity and neonatal services. As the Minister said, the Government have rightly identified maternity and neonatal as an urgent priority, and there are some measures in the Bill which reflect that intent, as referenced by my noble friends Lady Sugg and Lady Manzoor.
The commitment to bring forward an amendment to appoint a maternity and neonatal commissioner is one such measure, but this cannot be the sole solution. As my noble friends have said, this newly created office will need close attention as the Bill progresses, and we will need clarity from the Minister on the exact purpose and powers of that role. I point out that it is an enormous brief, spanning maternity and neonatal. We must ensure that equal weight is given to both services, which are distinct specialisms.
My worry is how long all this is taking. We have to remember why it came about, following the harrowing review by the noble Baroness, Lady Amos, where people bravely came forward. The Government promised a national action plan by this December. The commissioner is due to co-chair the taskforce implementing the plan, but of course there will need to be an appointment process and time for the office to be established. We need precision but also some pace. It would be helpful to know the timetable that has been set for the appointment and how the Minister envisages the taskforce making progress in the meantime.
I turn to the experience of families. Through Clause 19, as amended in the other place, the Bill places a statutory duty on ICBs to promote patient visiting and accompaniment rights. However, I stress that a parent is not a visitor—they are partners in care. To give one example, family integrated care is a model of neonatal care that integrates parents as equal primary caregivers for their baby alongside clinical staff, with strong evidence that this improves outcomes. This model has been implemented very well in units in England, but its implementation is not yet uniform. We need to look at how we can better safeguard family integrated care, and indeed wider parental involvement in care, as the NHS undergoes this transition. My concern is that the disruption brought about by restructuring may mean that we see even more patchy provision, and this is one issue I would like to return to in Committee. This should sit alongside wider efforts to improve accommodation and facilities with parents—an issue that has been raised with the Minister before. I just make the point that there is a lot that the Government could be getting on with alongside the Bill.
I turn briefly to the single patient record, which many have welcomed. I thought it was interesting that the Minister started with this. I recognise and support the Government’s ambition and I am pleased that they are prioritising maternity, and indeed frailty. I hope the Government have thought through how the single patient record will connect maternal health data with neonatal records. Currently, disjointed systems create dangerous information gaps. I genuinely hope this is a vital turning point, but core to this for all patients is trust, as many others have said.
The Minister is of course Minister for Women’s Health and Maternity, and I have genuinely welcomed engaging with her on many occasions. I accept that the Government have made some important commitments, but what is unclear to me is how effectively they are being brought together in a coherent programme of delivery. With over 700 recommendations across multiple inquiries, for women and families what matters now is results.