Contribution
My Lords, I thank all noble Lords who have made their maiden speeches today for their contributions, which I have found most enlightening, and I welcome them to this House.
Like the noble Earl, Lord Howe, and other noble Lords, I bear the scars of many of these Bills. For me, this time it is different. For the last five years, I was carer for my wife, who had a very rare neurological condition; she died in June. Over the past five years, I have seen the NHS at its inspirational best and its infuriating worst. I will offer one observation of my five years.
I do not think anybody should be allowed to have a senior position of leadership or management, or the governance of an acute trust, until they have had a carer come and get them washed and dressed in the morning. That carer will probably be somebody who is here on a visa and with a sponsor, and are therefore likely to be at risk of modern slavery. They should then have to get themselves to an appointment at their hospital, in a wheelchair—they are not allowed to walk—and using only patient transport to get them there and back. Then they should have to do it again, another day, as the carer of the person in the wheelchair. Only when you have done that do you begin to understand what the statements and intentions on these websites look like and how hollow they can be.
The second thing I want to say is that everybody talks about care pathways—oh yes—but I do not think many people have ever seen one, and fewer still know who is in charge of them. That is why we should be so careful when talking about the single patient record. In itself, it will not magically transform care. What will transform care is people understanding what the purpose of that information is, whose data it is and who is ultimately responsible for it. Various members of staff, particularly the doctors, are absolutely right: there may be four different answers to who is technically and legally responsible for it—somebody I know has already begun to find that out. It is not going to be any clearer, and it is not going to help with patient care, unless and until those fundamental points are understood by absolutely everybody in the NHS.
I have to say, as a carer, that the noble Lord, Lord Hunt of Kings Heath, was right: the one thing that you dread when you cannot get an appointment is that you will have to speak to 111. I really do not want to sound as if I am in any way at all disrespectful, but my wife was a very complex patient—one of the most complex—and packing her off to 111 was never going to do any good to anybody. We really have to go back and look at that.
I also want to say that it is important that we get all the protocols around the single patient record worked up in great detail with the people who have the experience to understand it. I have a particular interest in HIV and in sex and reproductive health. People in those communities are used to living with difficult information, and sometimes they are more open with it than you might imagine but perhaps not to the people that you might think. They quite often want to go to a specialist clinic rather than to the GP, where the receptionist knows their mum. We need to think quite carefully about what information is included at the person-level SPR, with explicit consent for people to opt out on an episodic basis.
Finally, I talk these days a lot to the Neurological Alliance. Neurology patients know that we are on the brink of some really big discoveries in that field because of technology and medicine. They desperately want to be involved in the research—they understand that that is the way to stop other people suffering—and they really want to be assured that they can do so in a way that does not jeopardise their status and confidentiality or other people’s. If we are going to do anything in the Bill other than rearrange the deck chairs on the NHS “Titanic”, we really owe it to people to put a lot of work into consulting on how this single patient record will work.