B

Baroness Maclean of Redditch (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 13 October 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I would like to raise two key issues. First, many noble Lords have spoken about the single patient record, which appears to me to be laudable and sensible, but it is not enough. Around 25 years ago, I had a breast scan that showed an abnormality and I went to see consultant Ian Paterson at Spire Parkway Hospital in Solihull, a private hospital—the only time in my life I have had private healthcare. I had a minor op, but nearly two decades later it emerged that I was one of his many victims. My op had been unnecessary. He practised across the NHS and the independent sector. Like many thousands of women across the West Midlands, I put my faith in him to heal me. I was fortunate compared with many others. Some women were totally mutilated. Their breasts were removed without any justification. It is awful. They have had to wait years to find out the truth about their operations and treatment. Ian Paterson is not the only rogue surgeon. For example, at Great Ormond Street, an independent review found that 94 children suffered harm attributable to the surgeon Yaser Jabbar. The Paterson inquiry reported in 2020. Its first recommendation was a single repository covering consultants’ whole practice across the NHS and the independent sector. It has not been implemented, and I cannot see any plans for it in this Bill. I hope noble Lords can see that that does serve a different purpose to the proposed single patient record. Without it, more criminal doctors could fall through the cracks. I pay tribute to Deborah Douglas, who chairs Breast Friends Solihull. She has campaigned assiduously for the inquiry and has helped so many other victims. The second key point I would like to raise is the need to protect vulnerable young people within the area of gender medicine. Children distressed about their gender deserve compassionate, evidence-based care and rigorous safeguards. As we know, this is not always what happens on the ground. This can be seen in the scandal at WellBN, which was an NHS GP practice in Brighton. An independent patient safety investigation found inappropriate prescribing of puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones to 78 children, some without even a face-to-face consultation. Potential harm and serious failures of clinical governance were found. It was totally shocking, and these young children and their families were badly let down. This was happening within an NHS practice but outside the nationally commissioned specialist pathway. That again adds weight to the argument that I have made about having oversight and governance of clinicians working across different settings. The NHS needs to be able to quickly flag up where this is happening and put a stop to it, because, after all, the NHS will be there—it is the NHS that has to pick up the pieces when things go wrong in private clinics, even for treatments that people have abroad. So, the test for the Government in this Bill is that failures such as these will be quickly identified and those doctors stopped before more patients come can be harmed. In this context, I also want to raise the issue of support for adolescents and young people who have had gender reassignment surgery and who now regret having undergone that life-altering surgical treatment and want to detransition. The Cass review recommended provision for these patients, yet the Written Answer to the Question I tabled says that consultation for the service will begin only in the autumn of 2027, and presumably services are still a few years beyond that. It is much too long for young people to wait when they have already been through so much. We do not have reliable figures for how many this affects, and many struggle to come forward. Some detransitioners describe shame and rejection by communities they had previously felt part of and been supported by. They need help now, so will the Minister say where this detransition service will fit into the new structures? I welcome the Bill. I want to help make it stronger. Patients need independent voices, effective oversight and timely action when things go wrong.

More from Baroness Maclean of Redditch (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.