L

Lord Carter of Coles (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 13 October 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I join others in congratulating noble Lords on their maiden speeches. They were excellent and most interesting, and I look forward to that from the noble Lord, Lord Singh, in a few moments. Last Tuesday, I visited a friend in her local hospital; it was a delight—shiny and modern. She sang the praises of the NHS and had not one bad word to say—it was highly positive. It reminded me that much is superb in the NHS; we should not forget that. However, the difference between good and bad practice is palpable. I think we all recognise the need for continuous reform; we probably have to look at it every 10 or 15 years. I really welcome this Bill because it gives us a chance to take the next step in the modification of the National Health Service, although it will require, as we have heard tonight, significant amendments; as it stands, it will not be effective. The test will be whether it delivers sufficient benefits to pay for the disruption that it has caused and will cause in the next two years. We should not forget for one moment that this is going to do little to improve care or anything else in the National Health Service for three years. We have three more years of challenges as this becomes effective. I draw attention to my interests as recorded in the register. The Bill has two objectives: the single patient record and the need to rationalise the NHS bureaucracy to streamline it to get through. Frankly, neither of these are new. The noble Baroness, Lady Jay, indicated that we have been on this journey for 20 years. I really wonder whether, when it comes into effect in 2027, we should get ready for a sort of silver jubilee to highlight the fact that we have been persistent—we have hung on to it. It is going to make an enormous difference. This is the real cutting edge of technology. It is not going to be easy, but it is critical. Similarly, we have known for years that we need to de-layer the NHS. If we look around the world, we see that the characteristic of failing healthcare systems is layers. The successful systems strip them out and make very clear those relationships between commissioners, the people who actually deliver the care and regulators—it has to be absolutely clear, and that is what we need to do. But perhaps we should ask ourselves: what is the problem we are trying to solve? A little look at where we stand today may be a good starting point. If we speak to patients in the system, as I did the other day, we learn that they are pretty grateful. They are very grateful to the staff for what they are doing. I think people are grateful for the investment where they can see it. If they were to think about it, I think they are grateful for the fact it is free at the point of delivery—we should never forget that. By contrast, if you are not in the system, it is pretty miserable. You are one of 7 million people waiting for treatment, and you cannot see a GP. If people are in pain and are waiting, they are anxious and they cannot go to work and they are also disappointed: “This is not the NHS we were promised”. And the staff are not happy either. If we talk to HR professionals, they tell us that bullying, harassment and high sickness levels are indicators of a dysfunctional workforce; we have the highest in the world. Finally, on the issue of money, where has the money gone? This is the key. In the last seven or eight years, real per capita expenditure in England on the NHS is up 14%. That is £650 per person. But output is down. Money up, output down—that is quite an achievement. If you compare that to Denmark, real per capita expenditure in those years has risen 1%. So, there is some lesson out there. We are clearly not doing things right. But we are where we are, and we need this Bill to go through. The key points for the Minister are: first, patient choice—that is the best guarantee of people meeting those standards. Of course, I totally subscribe to Healthwatch, and I agree with the noble Baroness, Lady Coffey, that we need to make it work better. On staff, the key issue is management: the management needs to be sorted out. With regards to the Secretary of State taking powers to herself to intervene directly, I hope we can make it clear in the Bill later on that we need a better solution than that; we need clarity, so that people can get on with it. Finally, on the issue of money, will the Minister comment on the fact that we should scrap block funding? This is beloved of the Treasury because they can deal it out, but it is really the handmaid of inefficiency. What we need is a return to tariff, so that people are paid for what they do and innovate. I look forward to supporting the Bill. It is a great chance to take this forward, and it presents an amazing opportunity.

More from Lord Carter of Coles (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.