B

Baroness Bennett of Manor Castle (GP)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 13 October 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, it is a pleasure to follow the noble Lord, Lord Bird, and a challenge to maintain the House’s attention after his, as always, formidable and compelling contribution. Perhaps counterintuitively, like many early speakers in this debate, I will take the House back to 2012. I was heavily involved outside Westminster, often far from Westminster, in the resistance and reaction to the Health and Social Care Act 2012. My early years as the leader of the Green Party of England and Wales saw me frequently at protests, rallies and marches, opposing the changes that were brought in by the 2012 Act. It was, as the noble Lord, Lord Hunt of Kings Heath, said, a hugely unpopular reorganisation. One group who did great work alerting the public to its damage was the one affectionately known as the “Darlo”: the Darlington mums who organised the modern-day Jarrow march, which I joined, to highlight the privatisation being hidden under the comfortable mantle of the NHS logo. I have to reflect on the speech of the noble Lord, Lord Winston, noting the issues created by the internal market and the focus on competition rather than compassion and care, in changes made to the NHS over recent decades. That led me back to a joint comment piece by Yanis Varoufakis, John McDonnell and I in the New Statesman in 2021, which called for the restoration of a market-free system that delivers care as a right, not a commodity. It noted rightly that what the British love about the NHS is freedom from the market. In 2015, my honourable friend Caroline Lucas presented in the other place as a Private Member’s Bill, with widespread support, the NHS reinstatement Bill, of which this Bill might be described as a pale imitation. Crucially, Caroline Lucas’s Bill allowed commercial companies to provide services only if they were essential to patient welfare and the NHS could not do it itself. That might have been a model for this Bill; I regret that it was not. I will therefore be seeing how I can amend this Bill to address the continuing privatisation and financialisation of our NHS. There are many issues and so little time, although I acknowledge the words of the Minister that a single Bill cannot solve every challenge facing the NHS. I will begin something of a shopping list that I will be trailing through the aisles of Committee. The Health Bill is currently silent on climate and environmental matters. That matters in both mitigating damage to climate and nature and dealing with the built-in damage on our nature-depleted islands. The state of nature reflects that of our public health, which is parlous, as the noble Lord, Lord Patel, outlined. Healthcare in England is responsible for 4% to 5% of national carbon emissions, and around 40% of all emissions are produced by the public sector. Plastic use is enormous, and not all properly dealt with, despite the determined, innovative efforts by many in the healthcare system. I will ask the current Minister, as I have asked previous Ministers, to visit the County Durham and Darlington NHS Foundation Trust to see the wonderful work made on these issues there. It acknowledges that the environmental impact of care matters, particularly in serving an economically disadvantaged area. Much of our focus will undoubtedly be on the many issues around the single patient record, something that already exists in Taiwan, as I saw on my recent visit there—I declare the support I received for that as recorded in the register—which I will bring to later discussions. The right reverend Prelate the Bishop of Newcastle spoke on the importance of trust in the context of the single patient record. The huge public concern about any involvement from Palantir is something I have raised in your Lordships’ House before, but overall sovereignty over those records—not to have our records and our NHS in the untender hands of US tech bros—is going to be a huge issue. We must ensure that the Bill adequately acknowledges the needs of disabled people, as the innovative and important contribution from the noble Baroness, Lady Campbell, addressed, as indeed did the noble Baroness, Lady Hollins. If we ensure that the NHS caters to the needs of the most vulnerable, we will build a better NHS for everyone. This Bill is mostly about structures, but we need to make sure those structures are dealing with issues such as antimicrobial resistance. That is something that we cannot afford to ignore. Finally, while this is not a public health Bill, I will be interested to see the amendments to which the noble Lord, Lord Patel, alluded, for there is no doubt that, for the future of our NHS, we have to improve the health of the nation.

More from Baroness Bennett of Manor Castle (GP)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.