Contribution
My Lords, I congratulate the maidens. We are a rich nation that allows citizens to miss out on scientific advances. We are not good at preventive medicine, particularly micronutrients. I have checked the latest nutrition survey. There are many losers, but in the main they are women of childbearing age. I will give two examples. The first is iodine. Girls aged 11 to 18 and women of childbearing age—16 to 49—are below the threshold. Good levels are required during pregnancy and are vital for brain formation.
The second is folate—vitamin B9. In women of childbearing age, the figure for low folate was 83%. Folate is crucial to helping prevent neural tube defects in early pregnancy. The neural tube, which forms the spine and brain, closes at 27 days after conception, when many women do not know they are pregnant. Half of pregnancies are unplanned, so it is vital that folate status is improved before pregnancy. It is disastrous that Governments and so-called independent scientific advisory committees have ignored the 1991 Medical Research Council vitamin study, which demonstrated the connection so clearly between neural tube defects and folate deficiency.
The new policy of fortification of flour, agreed by the previous Government and implemented by the current Government, required a change in the Bread and Flour Regulations in January 2025. This means that the UK will catch up next year with over 80 countries that operate mandatory fortification.
The USA adopted mandatory fortification in 1998 and fortifies wheat flour, cornflour and rice. A December 2015 open access paper by JK Morris et al said in its abstract:
“If the USA levels of folic acid fortification from 1998 onwards had been adopted in the UK, an estimated 2014 fewer NTD pregnancies would have occurred”.
The writers concluded:
“Failure to implement folic acid fortification in the UK has caused, and continues to cause, avoidable terminations of pregnancy, stillbirths, neonatal deaths and permanent serious disability in surviving children”.
Since 2015, there has continued to be around 150 to 200 live births per year and 800 terminations following the 20-week scan. The non-economic cost to women and their families is monumental distress. In financial terms, the impact assessment covers a range of situations and conditions, but, generally, the lifetime costs of a neural tube defect live birth are in excess of £2 million.
There are strong grounds for an inquiry as to why this policy was delayed for decades. The Scientific Advisory Committee on Nutrition has, over the years, when over 80 nations were fortifying on the basis of UK research from 1991, put up barrier after barrier to adopting the policy. Following a debate on a Bill on 8 July 2016, the then Minister, the noble Lord, Lord Prior, wrote to me in negative way on SACN’s behalf. I passed the letter to Lord Turnberg, a leading medic, now retired from the House, who wrote to the Minister—and I include just one sentence.
“In summary your advisors”—
that is the committee—
“seem to have ignored much of the scientific evidence that leads to the opposite conclusion to the one they have reached”.
In the BMJ in 2024, Nicholas Wald, who led the MRC study in 1991, quoted among others Sir Harry Burns, the former Chief Medical Officer for Scotland, on the new policy:
“Imagine you have a wound requiring five stitches to prevent infection or further harm. And yet, you are informed that only one stitch will be administered. While admitting that it will close only 20% of the wound, you are told to be content with one stitch because it is ‘better than nothing’ and ‘a good start’”.
The new UK policy from January 2027 is “one stitch fortification”. Nick Wald, whom Ministers and officials refused to talk to, and always have done, concluded in the same article:
“it is not enough. It will result in more deaths and birth defects every year that could have been prevented”.
There is a powerful case for an inquiry into the issue of the failure of professional duty in respect of public health policy, where we have started to adopt a policy half-heartedly, decades after other countries followed the UK research.