L

Lord Mawson (CB)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 13 October 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, the new Prime Minister is right to focus his Government on people and place and to encourage collaboration across the sectors, but the practical details really matter. If we review the Bill alongside the Government’s neighbourhood framework, NHS England’s published position on the role of the voluntary, community and social enterprise sector, guidance on the wider determinants of health and recent NHS Confederation and community health partnerships on neighbourhood health and estate optimisation, we see that this Bill, while containing some helpful provisions, does not translate the stated shift from sickness to prevention into sufficiently clear duties, financial commitments or reporting requirements. My colleagues and I, in our working lives, are involved in building with private and public sector partners the new integrated health infrastructure across the country at place that is going to be crucial if we are ever to get beyond the fine words of countless politicians on all sides and get upstream into the prevention agenda—I declare my interests. In the modern world, health is everybody’s business. The present biomedical model is creating a profound dependency culture across the country and is totally unaffordable going forward. Some of us are being practical and attempting to plant in the ground the seeds of these new more joined-up communities that so many talk about, but the challenge is to do it, not to talk about it. Now in the real world, large parts of the public sector are restructuring, so everyone is looking for a new job. Here we have yet another restructure of the NHS, with another Government in danger of restructuring parts of the restructuring that is already taking place. Collaboration, yes, but not chaos. We need to be practical. There is likely to be another election before any of this settles down and can properly function. If we want to deliver, beware of the danger of too many moving parts. For practitioners like me who are trying to be helpful in the real world, it is often like trying to build a house on the sand. So what do we make of the Bill? I invite the Government to consider six practical measures that will save money. First, neighbourhood health plans should be required to address the wider determinants of health, including housing, employment, education and skills, food security, transport, digital inclusion, the environment, loneliness and social connection. This should not displace the responsibilities of local government but should require the NHS to recognise how these factors affect demand and to identify where joint action would improve health. Secondly, each ICB and its partner local authorities should be required to establish a published mechanism for meaningful VCSE participation in neighbourhood planning. There are limits to what the state can achieve. This should include involvement in assessing needs and opportunities, designing responses, identifying underserved groups and reviewing outcomes. It must mean participation before decisions are made, not consultation after the principal decisions have already been settled. Thirdly, every neighbourhood health plan should be informed by a proportionate social capital and community assets audit. This should identify local voluntary and faith organisations, trusted networks, existing preventive services, public and community buildings, and formally void NHS space and accommodation that is paid for but materially underused. It should also identify barriers relating to cost, tenure, accessibility and suitability. It is ridiculous that almost £90 million is spent annually on NHS empty voids in buildings at a time when many community organisations face prohibitive accommodation costs, particularly in London and other cities, despite delivering low-cost activities that address isolation. Fourthly, ICBs should be required to identify transparently what they spend on prevention and community capacity. Fifthly, smaller community organisations need proportionate routes to funding. Multiyear grants, simplified agreements and collaborative commissioning arrangements should be available where continuity and local trust are central to the effectiveness of an intervention. Sixthly, the Bill should introduce a broader public value or best value assessment for preventive investment. The social and business sectors may be cheaper than the public sector. None of these proposals diminishes the importance of clinical services. On the contrary, they are intended to protect those services by reducing avoidable demand and enabling people to remain healthier and more independent. Neighbourhood health must mean more than healthcare delivered near a home. It must mean creating health within neighbourhoods, supporting individual agency and recognising the local organisations that sustain well-being long before statutory services are required. My question to the Minister is: what will the Government do about the £90 million that is wasted on empty rooms in NHS buildings? Will they do deals with the voluntary, charity and social enterprise sectors and open up those spaces?

More from Lord Mawson (CB)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.