Contribution
My Lords, I approach this Bill from the perspective of public health and the prevention of ill health, because of my work in the House. First, on children’s health and well-being, and an aspect of prevention to which this Government are committed, I will be joining the noble Baroness, Lady Cass, and others in questioning how the Bill will improve the future health of our children through greater accountability for child health spend and outcomes.
The abolition of NHSE, the return of many of its duties to the department and the Secretary of State, and the commissioning of services to the ICBs when they are being merged and boundaries changed, is a major reorganisation to be done at the same time as reducing costs by 50%. It is very dangerous. I will seek to establish how this reorganisation will actually improve our health, especially that of children.
Clause 4 is crucial and it needs to be strengthened and widened. It specifies the Secretary of State’s duty to
“have regard to the need to … reduce inequalities”
in both access to health services and health outcomes. That is not good enough.
My recent work chairing committees is very relevant to this clear duty. In 2024, I chaired the Food, Diet and Obesity Committee, and the Labour Government have responded positively to many of our recommendations. I currently chair the Childhood Vaccination Committee and I hope for a similar result. That committee will report early next month. While I cannot reveal our recommendations, I can reflect on the public evidence the committee has heard and how it relates to this specific duty on the Secretary of State.
The evidence to both committees was clear about the magnitude of health inequality in our country. We heard evidence about the drivers of this inequality and its relationship to ill health, quality of life, life expectancy, and cost to the NHS and the economy. Unequal access to affordable nutritious food, the ubiquity of cheap, poor-quality food and the advertising power of large food companies were shown to be barriers to poorer demographic groups maintaining a healthy weight. How will the Secretary of State work across government to address these barriers?
The vaccination committee has heard that there are several interconnected drivers of low coverage, resulting in wide differences in the rates of vaccinations received by different groups. This has led to preventable ill health, hospital admissions and deaths, as well as additional costs. I am hopeful that, under Clause 4, the new Secretary of State will be as open to adopting our recommendations about vaccination as her predecessor was to taking action on healthy food.
I therefore ask the Minister: how will this duty be carried out? Will there be a regular report to Parliament about what action her department has taken to reduce health inequalities, such as by improving and equalising access to health services, reducing obesity and increasing coverage of vaccination against preventable diseases? Will the Secretary of State report on the outcomes of these actions? Will there be specific inequalities targets against which the department, the ICBs and health service providers will be held to account? How will the targets be arrived at, monitored and enforced, and what will be the principles on which funding is allocated?
Clause 7 changes the Secretary of State’s duties around training, from maintaining an effective education and training system to ensuring that there are sufficient appropriately trained staff to meet NHS workforce needs. I can say no more than this: evidence is emerging that staff shortages of health visitors, GPs, nurses and midwives are affecting vaccination at various levels in the system. Time pressures mean that health professionals cannot answer patients’ questions, and the training in how to do so effectively is deficient. Training must include how to communicate empathetically with patients to enable them to make informed decisions. This will be a specific challenge under Clause 7.
Evidence is already emerging that the transfer of commissioning is causing confusion, decreasing morale and risks the loss of local knowledge of communities, which is crucial in responding appropriately to variation in vaccine coverage. I therefore ask the Minister how the Government will ensure that the skills and knowledge currently found among NHSE staff are retained and whether crucial budget lines will be protected? Who will monitor the performance of ICBs and hold them to account, and what is the system of quality assurance?