Contribution
My Lords, as speaker 59 of 70, it is a pleasure to have had the privilege to witness no fewer than five very fine maiden speeches. I salute the noble Lord, Lord Singh of Solihull, for his perseverance. He had to sit patiently through over 50 contributions before he was allowed to stand up and make his stunning debut. I welcome him to the House.
This is a critical and complex piece of legislation. Although it is well-intended, there are some potentially very serious gaps—there always are when you reorganise and reverse structures. I will focus on the proposed neighbourhood health plans and Clause 25 specifically, which I feel has considerable scope to be strengthened. First, I acknowledge that I am not a healthcare expert; I am better known in this place for speaking about our economy and our entrepreneurship—which is my background—and the disturbing state of our public finances, on which NHS funding depends.
Three years ago, I tabled an Oral Question on our treatment of migraines and the impact on the workforce. There are 10 million migraine sufferers in the UK, and I am one. I was astounded to discover that this was the first time this House had debated this condition since 1962, despite its £10 billion annual impact on the economy—that in itself tells you something. This, and follow up questions, brought me into contact with the Migraine Trust and the wider Neurological Alliance—the latter representing the one in six people in our population who suffer from conditions such as epilepsy, dementia, Parkinson’s and Tourette syndrome, as well as migraine. We are talking here about a £96 billion annual cost to the UK economy, of which at least £30 billion is potentially avoidable.
As a patient, stakeholder and employer, I have become increasingly concerned about the huge gaps in our healthcare system for those people living with long-term, complex or fluctuating conditions. To illustrate, I refer back to migraines. Some 5 million to 6 million sufferers in the UK still lack a diagnosis, while less than a third of those who have a diagnosis receive any form of specialist care. Many have to see a GP—I should say GPs—six times before they are diagnosed, while huge and fast-growing numbers end up in A&E, representing another inefficient drain on our health resources. The result is that we as a nation lose 55 million working days-worth of productivity every year, at a cost of £5 billion to £10 billion—and that is just for the condition of migraines.
This sort of data is critical when we come to examine how the neighbourhood health plans under Clause 25 will function and operate, and, crucially be held accountable for performance, for it is these NHPs that will be tasked with identifying how the assessed needs of persons with long-term, complex or fluctuating health conditions, including neurological conditions, are to be met. That raises the question of what the measurable objectives and datasets will be for improving access, co-ordination, experience and outcomes, and for reducing unwarranted regional variations. Currently, there appears to be no explicit recognition of complex and fluctuating conditions in the neighbourhood plan guidance. This appears to be a serious omission. Can the Minister please comment? Further, will statutory guidance explicitly cover neurological conditions and co-ordination across primary, community and specialist pathways?
These questions become all the more pertinent if we lack a clear and fully funded home for the national neurological leadership—a point that the noble Baroness, Lady Leaman, made in relation to autism and ADHD. The risk is that health devolution, restructuring or reorganisation—whatever we want to call it—may disrupt joined-up care and actually weaken accountability, especially if NHPs fail to efficiently and promptly connect people with complex conditions to highly specialist services.