Contribution
My Lords, it is a great pleasure to follow my noble friend Lord Singh. I congratulate all noble Lords who have given a maiden speech today, but I particularly welcome him to our Benches and to explain that, while we have heard about his intelligence and his phenomenal career in psychiatry, he is typically very humble and has not described his true character of kindness and humility and the fact that he really is a true radical, because when he sees an intractable problem, and when he sees received wisdom, he does not hesitate to challenge it. That is why he pioneered the treatment of psychosis, which was one of the greatest mental health reforms since the era of deinstitutionalisation, while his work with young people in the 16 to 24 age bracket has kept people off the streets and many of them from suicide—again, ground-breaking.
Perhaps the greatest courage of all that my noble friend has shown is in challenging another received wisdom that treatment in psychiatry was racist. At great personal cost to himself, he undertook a massive piece of research, studying all the studies to date, to find that the evidence simply was not there. He did that, first, because it was an intractable issue but, secondly, because he was worried that young people of colour and young Black people were not coming forward to seek the treatment they needed. At no small cost to himself, he put them first, yet again. He has enormous expertise in health, and I know he is going to bring great wealth to these Benches.
I turn to the Bill. It is late and we have had a lot of comment on different aspects of the Bill. I want to focus on inequality, with my shadow Minister hat on, in respect of the inequalities that are not addressed by the Bill as currently drafted. The NHS still fails in too many respects to treat patients equally or safely, as required by law. There are too many failures to record data accurately, and it worries me enormously that, while I welcome a single patient record, we still do not record things accurately and have not done the work needed to fix that before embarking on what is really a major change, with all the risks that other noble Lords have raised today. The Bill represents an important opportunity to do something about it, but the record must be consistent and reliable to ensure patient safety for both sexes.
Women are 50% more likely to be misdiagnosed after a heart attack because the textbook symptoms are male. The British Heart Foundation estimates the cost of that to be more than 8,000 women losing their lives over a decade. Screening for aortic aneurysm depends on knowing whether someone is male. Osteoporosis in men goes undiagnosed because it is assumed to be a woman’s disease. Drug doses, side-effects, reference ranges and screening calls all run off sex data. There is a reason why every major research funder in this country now requires studies to account for sex. Yet it is only in the wake of the Sullivan review that the former Secretary of State, Wes Streeting, accepted that we should record biological sex data on patient safety grounds. However, is just not good enough that this protection exists as merely an administrative standard, revisable at any time. The Bill is an opportunity to make the requirement statutory.
The same accuracy should apply to ethnicity. The NHS is still recording ethnicity against categories drawn from the 2001 census. Even then, the Nuffield Trust found recording to be incomplete, inconsistent and least reliable for the patients that it most needs to count. Black women are almost three times more likely than white women to die during or after pregnancy. The parliamentary inquiry into sickle cell care found avoidable deaths and serious failures in hospital care. Services cannot be planned, costed or audited on data of this quality. Equal treatment begins with being seen. We need sex recorded as fact and ethnicity recorded as the patient states it, in current census categories.
Then there is physical safety. Between January 2019 and October 2022, police forces in England and Wales recorded more than 6,500 rapes and sexual assaults in hospitals—33 a week, with one in seven occurring on a ward. Barely 4% led to a charge. Those figures were established by the Women’s Rights Network report written by Professor Jo Phoenix. The law is clear; the Supreme Court has confirmed it. The statutory code of practice about single-sex meaning biological sex is in force, as is the requirement for single-sex spaces, but the NHS is still failing to implement that judgment. Take Sandie Peggie and the Darlington nurses—these women should not need tribunals to secure a safe changing room. There could not be stronger arguments for the need to mandate in statute the provision of single-sex spaces. Women, children and the disabled should not be at risk of rape or sexual assault because hospitals are ignoring the law, and patients and staff should be safe and dignified in single-sex wards, changing rooms and bathrooms.
Accountability is attached to all of this, and I have not yet addressed the issue of children and the elderly. There is so much about the Bill in respect of how we treat people equally before the law at some of the most vulnerable times of their lives. I look forward to working constructively with the Government through the passage of the Bill to address these.