B

Baroness Cash (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 22 October 2026

Debate

Antisemitism in Schools and Colleges

Contribution

My Lords, I thank the Minister for the Statement and Sir David Bell, his team and those who gave evidence, often at real personal cost. We on these Benches welcome the review and the Government’s acceptance of all 27 recommendations. Every school day, British children are abused for being Jewish, in the one place their parents should be able to trust that they are safe. We heard the headlines yesterday: nearly three in five Jewish students have experienced antisemitism and half of Jewish teachers experienced it at work in the past year—racism in their classroom and workplace. It is intolerable. There is worse in the report’s annex; 16% of this racism is inflicted by teachers, and 38% of the antisemitism students witnessed took place during lessons. Only 18% say an antisemitic incident is actually recorded as such. Two-thirds of Jewish respondents said that antisemitism is not even treated as racism in their school. Yesterday, the Secretary of State told the other place that teachers hear “age-old tropes in the classroom” and do not tackle them “for fear of reprisals”. She said: “The fears about not being politically impartial are hampering our teachers and school leaders, preventing them from doing what they need to do”.—[Official Report, Commons, 21/10/26; col. 1151.] It is their job to do this and what they must do, because political impartiality is a statutory duty under Sections 406 and 407 of the Education Act 1996. It is not discretionary. Helpfully, the annex to the Bell report shows us why there is fear about acting against this evil racism. More than half of teacher respondents could not say whether the impartiality guidance helped them. Over a third named fear of a negative response from pupils or staff, and over a third named fear of community tensions. In the wake of this report, we need absolute clarity about what teachers must and will be supported to do. Will the Minister confirm that challenging antisemitism is challenging racism and is never politically partial? Will she confirm that Sections 406 and 407 will be annexed to the letter to be sent by the Secretary of State to every school? The Secretary of State told the other place that the unions are “keen to put things right”.—[Official Report, Commons, 21/10/26; col. 1151.] Within hours, she had been let down by the general secretary of the National Education Union, Daniel Kebede, who had rejected a central recommendation of the review. He called the IHRA definition “the wrong approach” and warned of a “chilling grip” on classroom discussion of Gaza. He deployed the Secretary of State’s own argument against the review. No wonder that 40% of respondents reported negative experiences with education unions. Days after 7 October, this union’s teachers circulated lesson plans asking pupils whether they would fight back if they lived in Gaza—the very definition of political partiality. In 2022, the last Conservative Government suspended all engagement with the National Union of Students over antisemitism. Will the Government now suspend the National Education Union from all departmental engagement on this issue—I know it has to be involved in funding discussions—including communications with the group implementing this review, until it has accepted Sir David’s recommendations in full? In answer after answer yesterday, the Secretary of State turned to the curriculum: citizenship, Holocaust education, Jewish history, media literacy and, again, the curriculum review. But much of this is already in place and Holocaust education is already compulsory. Parents Against Antisemitism has reported endless incidents, including one child being told to his face, “Gas the Jews”, straight after Holocaust Memorial Day. What is missing is enforcement and consequence. Will the Government restore Ofsted’s capacity to scrutinise all areas of the curriculum which are subject to and vulnerable to politicisation? For at least the next three years, will they undertake mandatory inspection of the written records of every school’s antisemitic incidents and the action taken? The importance of this moment is not to be underestimated. It is an issue of national security. Recommendation 8 of the review states clearly that antisemitism in a child can be an indicator of radicalisation risk. With only 18% of incidents recorded as antisemitic, the chance to identify this risk is lost at great cost to our national cohesion and national safety. The Independent Reviewer of Terrorism Legislation, Sir Jonathan Hall, has called attacks on Jews “the biggest national security emergency” in almost a decade. Will the Minister please commit to publishing national data on antisemitic incidents in schools every term, starting this academic year, so we can get to grips with this urgently? I look forward to her responses.

More from Baroness Cash (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.