Hansard·Lords Chamber·Vol. 860

Antisemitism in Schools and Colleges

Thursday, 22 October 2026

51 contributions17 members

Contributions

  1. Statement

    View contribution permalink →

  2. The following Statement was made in the House of Commons on Wednesday 21 October.

    View contribution permalink →

  3. “With permission, I will make a Statement on Sir David Bell’s review into antisemitism in schools and colleges in England. First, let me just apologise for some of the reporting in the media. The full report and government response were laid in the House this morning and were not given to the media first. I have ordered a leak inquiry into this matter.

    View contribution permalink →

  4. Today, Sir David has published this seminal review, exposing the shocking scale of antisemitism in British society and how that is reflected across education. Almost three in five Jewish young people and half of Jewish teachers have experienced or witnessed antisemitism. That cannot continue. Let me place on record my sincere thanks to Sir David for his excellent report and to the reference group for their support.

    View contribution permalink →

  5. Make no mistake: this is a report for every teacher, every staff member, every education leader and every student listening today. All children and teachers should be able to go to school or college free from fear, but there is a wider responsibility for education as a whole to teach our young people British values of tolerance, acceptance and respect for one another. Collectively, we have a duty to educate this generation and the next on what antisemitism is, on why it is wrong, and on what happens when it takes hold in society. Whether or not there are Jewish staff and students in your school or college, this report is for you. This generational challenge belongs to us all.

    View contribution permalink →

  6. We all know that antisemitism is an ancient evil. Today it remains as pernicious as ever, but its modern mutation is in many ways more prominent and more prevalent. Perhaps most concerning of all, that is especially true among young people. Old tropes have found new life in the modern world. The fallacy that Jewish networks control the global economy and other such delusions once confined to the fringes have found a new home on social media. Antisemitism is now normalised and amplified in echo chambers online, reaching directly into children’s bedrooms. I thank my right honourable friend the Secretary of State for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport for her leadership and commitment in tackling this issue, and I am grateful for her collaboration.

    View contribution permalink →

  7. As Sir David’s report also identifies, the conflict in the Middle East has significantly fanned the flames of division here at home. Misunderstanding, ignorance and deliberate misrepresentation can quickly lead to antisemitism—at times casual, at others more serious, and all too often unreported and unchallenged. As a House and a Government, we must be clear: blaming British Jews for the actions of the Israeli Government is antisemitism; assuming British Jews have a particular political standpoint because they are Jewish is antisemitism; and targeting British Jews out of concern for Palestine is antisemitism. When such views and behaviours are expressed in any school or college, whether or not they are aimed directly at a Jewish person, they are antisemitic, and we have a duty to challenge them.

    View contribution permalink →

  8. Sitting at the centre of our communities, schools and colleges have a leadership role in fostering tolerance, compassion and respect for difference. Let me be clear: teachers should not bring their own political views into the classroom. That is a fundamental of education. However, this principle should not lead to a shying away from difficult debates. In fact, as Sir David’s report clearly recommends, schools and colleges should be the place for important discussions, but school leaders often fear reprisals, protests or accusations of political bias, so they avoid discussing and addressing important topics. I want to empower our teachers and school and college leaders to tackle these issues head on. Our young people have to learn how to navigate contentious debates thoughtfully and respectfully, and to understand that antisemitism and other forms of racism are wrong. That is a job for education, but we all have a responsibility to set the tone, here in this House and in the media too—robust debate and challenge matched with respect, tolerance and disagreeing amicably.

    View contribution permalink →

  9. A new approach is needed. Antisemitism is unique in both historical context and its reach today. It demands a unique response. That is why this Government accept all 27 recommendations from Sir David’s review. I thank everyone who contributed their views and experiences, but above all, I want to recognise the Jewish community directly for their bravery in engaging with the review. I do not take lightly the personal cost they have paid in recounting their deeply hurtful experiences. They have not only my thanks but my word that their voices will be heard. Change will come.

    View contribution permalink →

  10. I turn to the report’s recommendations. First, definition matters. Combating antisemitism starts with identifying it. I agree with Sir David that the use of a common and consistent definition will improve understanding and confidence. I will therefore write to all schools and colleges to set out my expectation that they adopt the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance’s working definition of antisemitism. As Sir David recommends, we will strengthen the safeguarding guidance to make it clear that antisemitism is a distinct risk and therefore requires a distinct safeguarding response. I also accept the recommendation that all education settings should record antisemitic incidents as a specific category. Sir David also says that school and college leaders, as well as head and teacher unions, need more support to identify and challenge antisemitism. We will develop and roll out high-quality training, good practice guidance and practical resources, as well as dedicated support for leaders managing complex and serious incidents involving antisemitism and other forms of racism, including support for escalation when it is needed. We will also give schools and colleges clear and specific support when it comes to how and when controversial and sensitive issues should be discussed.

    View contribution permalink →

  11. We will update and strengthen Holocaust education, so that this generation and the next can better understand the horrors of the Holocaust, how it came about, and why that should matter to us today. I can confirm that such education will continue to be compulsory in the national curriculum. However, as Sir David has recommended, while it is right that every child should know about the Holocaust, that should not be the only thing that they know about Jewish people and their history. We will ensure, through the curriculum, that the contribution, culture and history of Jewish people in Britain are well understood and appreciated. Judaism is a diverse, modern and generous faith tradition, and the curriculum should reflect that as well.

    View contribution permalink →

  12. However, this is not just about what happens in the classroom. One of the most shocking findings of Sir David’s review was that following the Heaton Park synagogue terrorist attack, educational visits to the Manchester Jewish Museum in my constituency fell by half, just when those visits were needed most. We will boost opportunities for engagement with Jewish cultural experiences. The testimonies of Jewish teachers and leaders in Jewish schools about how much of their time was spent on safety and not teaching were particularly concerning. We cannot build ever higher walls around our Jewish institutions, but we will continue to work with the Community Security Trust and the Home Office to ensure that children and staff can be safe, happy and supported.

    View contribution permalink →

  13. Sir David looked closely at the issue of political symbols displayed by staff and students. He found it not to be a widespread issue, and therefore concluded that extending existing legal duties on schools would be disproportionate. I accept his recommendation, but as Education Secretary, I should make it clear that I would not expect to see teachers coming to school or college wearing or displaying any political material.

    View contribution permalink →

  14. There are further important recommendations for leaders of schools and colleges, and for teachers, staff, parents and unions, among others. I will ensure that we work to do what needs to be done and to maintain momentum. I have set up an implementation group, which will get to work immediately, and I have asked Sir David to conduct a one-year review of the implementation of his recommendations.

    View contribution permalink →

  15. Although universities are not in the scope of the review, I want to make it clear to the House that the rise in antisemitism on our campuses is completely unacceptable. I wrote to all vice-chancellors earlier this month about the steps that they need to take to combat antisemitism, and I will continue to act wherever I can.

    View contribution permalink →

  16. This is an incredibly important moment for education and for our country. It falls to our generation to educate the next on what can happen to a society when antisemitism is allowed to take hold, and why we all have a duty to root it out. I commend this Statement to the House”.

    View contribution permalink →

  17. Baroness Cash (Con)

    My Lords, I thank the Minister for the Statement and Sir David Bell, his team and those who gave evidence, often at real personal cost. We on these Benches welcome the review and the Government’s acceptance of all 27 recommendations. Every school day, British children are abused for being Jewish, in the one place their parents should be able to trust that they are safe. We heard the headlines yesterday: nearly three in five Jewish students have experienced antisemitism and half of Jewish teachers experienced it at work in the past year—racism in their classroom and workplace. It is intolerable. There is worse in the report’s annex; 16% of this racism is inflicted by teachers, and 38% of the antisemitism students witnessed took place during lessons. Only 18% say an antisemitic incident is actually recorded as such. Two-thirds of Jewish respondents said that antisemitism is not even treated as racism in their school. Yesterday, the Secretary of State told the other place that teachers hear “age-old tropes in the classroom” and do not tackle them “for fear of reprisals”. She said: “The fears about not being politically impartial are hampering our teachers and school leaders, preventing them from doing what they need to do ”.—[ Official Report , Commons, 21/10/26; col. 1151.] It is their job to do this and what they must do, because political impartiality is a statutory duty under Sections 406 and 407 of the Education Act 1996. It is not discretionary. Helpfully, the annex to the Bell report shows us why there is fear about acting against this evil racism. More than half of teacher respondents could not say whether the impartiality guidance helped them. Over a third named fear of a negative response from pupils or staff, and over a third named fear of community tensions. In the wake of this report, we need absolute clarity about what teachers must and will be supported to do. Will the Minister confirm that challenging antisemitism is challenging racism and is never politically partial? Will she confirm that Sections 406 and 407 will be annexed to the letter to be sent by the Secretary of State to every school? The Secretary of State told the other place that the unions are “keen to put things right ”.—[ Official Report , Commons, 21/10/26; col. 1151.] Within hours, she had been let down by the general secretary of the National Education Union, Daniel Kebede, who had rejected a central recommendation of the review. He called the IHRA definition “the wrong approach” and warned of a “chilling grip” on classroom discussion of Gaza. He deployed the Secretary of State’s own argument against the review. No wonder that 40% of respondents reported negative experiences with education unions. Days after 7 October, this union’s teachers circulated lesson plans asking pupils whether they would fight back if they lived in Gaza—the very definition of political partiality. In 2022, the last Conservative Government suspended all engagement with the National Union of Students over antisemitism. Will the Government now suspend the National Education Union from all departmental engagement on this issue—I know it has to be involved in funding discussions—including communications with the group implementing this review, until it has accepted Sir David’s recommendations in full? In answer after answer yesterday, the Secretary of State turned to the curriculum: citizenship, Holocaust education, Jewish history, media literacy and, again, the curriculum review. But much of this is already in place and Holocaust education is already compulsory. Parents Against Antisemitism has reported endless incidents, including one child being told to his face, “Gas the Jews”, straight after Holocaust Memorial Day. What is missing is enforcement and consequence. Will the Government restore Ofsted’s capacity to scrutinise all areas of the curriculum which are subject to and vulnerable to politicisation? For at least the next three years, will they undertake mandatory inspection of the written records of every school’s antisemitic incidents and the action taken? The importance of this moment is not to be underestimated. It is an issue of national security. Recommendation 8 of the review states clearly that antisemitism in a child can be an indicator of radicalisation risk. With only 18% of incidents recorded as antisemitic, the chance to identify this risk is lost at great cost to our national cohesion and national safety. The Independent Reviewer of Terrorism Legislation, Sir Jonathan Hall, has called attacks on Jews “the biggest national security emergency” in almost a decade. Will the Minister please commit to publishing national data on antisemitic incidents in schools every term, starting this academic year, so we can get to grips with this urgently? I look forward to her responses.

    View contribution permalink →

  18. Lord Mohammed of Tinsley (LD)

    My Lords, the findings of this review are deeply disturbing, with one in five students who responded to the survey reporting that they had witnessed antisemitism and three in five Jewish students saying they had experienced it. Behind these stats are young people who should be concentrating on their education, building friendships and planning their futures, but instead they face prejudice, intimidation and fear because of their religious identity. I say this as a member of a religious minority. I know at first hand from these experiences, whether as a parent or as a youth worker, what can happen to young people when they are discriminated against because of who they are and events over which neither they nor their parents have any control. No child should feel compelled to hide their faith to feel safe at school or college, and also on the journey to school and college. I was horrified to see a video of a parent with a young child from a Jewish community who was being harangued on the Tube. Ironically, it was a Muslim woman in a hijab who challenged it. I do not know how old that video was, but it was quite disturbing that our young people are also fearing facing that intimidation on public transport, and I hope the police take action. Educational institutions must be places where young people, regardless of their religious background or identity, feel valued and protected. We welcome the Government’s commitment to implement the recommendations. However, accepting recommendations is only the beginning. What matters is how effective that implementation is, proper accountability and the willingness to confront antisemitism wherever it occurs. I urge the Minister to consider coming back to us in a year or so with another review, having done another survey of how young people from all backgrounds now feel. As we have seen, there are issues of misogyny as well. Like I said, young people from all backgrounds should be able to go to school without fear. Teachers and school leaders cannot be expected to tackle these challenges without appropriate training, resources and guidance and we need a clear understanding of contemporary antisemitism, including its manifestation in online conspiracy theories, Holocaust denial and the spread of hatred, particularly on social media. We strongly support strengthening opportunities for schools to engage directly with Jewish communities, as this can help challenge stereotypes and build understanding between communities. As someone who believes passionately in education as a force for social cohesion, I am particularly concerned that some Jewish students do not believe that reporting antisemitism incidents will lead to action. This is a serious failure of confidence. Schools must have effective reporting systems and pupils must know that complaints will be taken seriously and dealt with fairly. At the same time, schools and colleges must remain places where difficult and contentious issues can be discussed openly and constructively. Tackling antisemitism must go hand in hand with protecting balanced debate, challenging all forms of racism and prejudice and ensuring that teachers feel confident facilitating sensitive discussions. I have a number of questions for the Minister. Will the Government provide additional funding to ensure that schools, colleges and local authorities can implement these recommendations effectively, rather than expecting them to be absorbed into costs that are already stretching budgets? Secondly, will they hold institutions accountable for implementation and ensure that students who report antisemitism see meaningful actions? Tackling antisemitism is not the responsibility of the Jewish community; it is a responsibility for all of us. We must move beyond statements of condemnation towards lasting cultural change, beginning in our classrooms and extending throughout our society. Every child deserves to learn without fear and every community deserves to live without hatred.

    View contribution permalink →

  19. The Minister of State, Department for Education and Department for Work and Pensions (Baroness Smith of Malvern) (Lab)

    My Lords, as both noble Lords have strongly identified, antisemitism is a scourge that has no place in modern Britain and in our schools and colleges. Yet Sir David Bell’s independent review makes it clear that it is a growing and increasingly normalised form of hatred, with too many Jewish pupils, students and staff experiencing its effects in schools and colleges. The findings are a stark reminder that we cannot be complacent. That is why the Government welcome Sir David Bell’s report, thank those who took part—in some cases at considerable risk and detriment to themselves, as the noble Baroness said—and accept all 27 of its recommendations. The review provides a clear and practical blueprint for action. It recognises, as noble Lords have said, that every school, college and teacher has a responsibility to identify, challenge and prevent antisemitism wherever it occurs, ensuring that all young people can learn in an environment that is safe, respectful and free from discrimination. Our focus must now be on implementation. Accepting the recommendations is only the beginning. Delivering meaningful and lasting change will require sustained effort across the sector. To support this work, the Government have established an implementation group, bringing together key stakeholders to drive progress, share best practice and help ensure that the recommendations are delivered effectively. In the light of the point made by the noble Lord, Lord Mohammed, I am also pleased that Sir David Bell has agreed to undertake a further review in one year’s time. His independent assessment will help ensure that momentum is maintained, that progress is scrutinised and that we remain firmly focused on turning these recommendations into real improvements for Jewish children, students and staff across our education system. I turn to the other questions that have been raised. Of course it is true that all teachers have a responsibility to tackle antisemitism. We are completely clear about that. Teachers’ standards, which are used both for training and for misconduct procedures, are clear about their responsibilities to tackle this issue. If necessary, when those standards are reviewed, we will strengthen them to make that clearer. We understand the need for further training and will develop the resources and training asked for by Sir David Bell in his review. We will review the impartiality guidance to ensure that teachers understand both their requirement to be impartial and their responsibility to enable discussion and debate about difficult issues within their schools while protecting all those who take part in them. The noble Lord, Lord Mohammed, is right that schools must facilitate discussion on these difficult issues. In recent years, they have too often been put off that by a fear about what it means about their political impartiality. The noble Baroness raised particular points about the National Education Union. Sir David did not find that there was opposition to important work to tackle antisemitism across the unions but, as an active member of an NEU predecessor trade union, I wholly disagree with its position on the IHRA definition. The Secretary of State has been clear, in accepting Sir David’s recommendation, that we believe that is the definition that should be used across the education system. In the case of the MP for Bristol North East, which particularly raised concern around this, Ofsted could have examined the aspects of the incident that fell within its inspection remit, and it did so. It could not act as a general investigator into all the surrounding events, campaign activity or motives of external individuals. Those matters sit outside of Ofsted’s statutory inspection powers. We think that both Ofsted and the Independent Schools Inspectorate—we will work with them on this—could do more thematic work, examining how schools and colleges identify, prevent and respond to antisemitism, with the aim of highlighting effective practice, identifying areas for improvement and strengthening the national evidence base. Every young person in school must not only feel able to report incidents of antisemitic abuse or speech within the school but, as the noble Lord said, be confident that those are recorded and that action is taken. That is part of the renewed set of support and guidance that we will provide to schools, but the expectation is clear that all incidents should be recorded and action should be taken. We will consider the points made by the noble Baroness with respect to national reporting of those incidents. On the point about funding, the Government have already made available £7 million to tackle antisemitism in our schools and colleges, which are already responding to some of the issues both in higher education and across our schools. There has been work to tackle mis- and disinformation and conspiracy theories; to develop interfaith discussion; and to enable young people to understand the need to disagree appropriately and to engage in difficult conversations and controversial issues without resorting to antisemitism or racism. Other innovations through the innovation fund are being supported through all this, as are training and new resources for teachers. The Government will support this through their action to put into operation all 27 recommendations of Sir David Bell’s very important report.

    View contribution permalink →

  20. Lord Pickles (Con)

    My Lords, as the former chairman of the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance, I welcome the report with some degree of enthusiasm. Sir David has produced a very thoughtful report. Does the Minister agree that, vital though it is to adopt the IHRA working definition, the greater challenge is to ensure that it is properly understood and implemented? In particular, the definition is intended as an educational tool to assist in recognising and reflecting on antisemitism, rather than as an instrument to denounce or silence others. That is its strength; it is designed to make people think. The opponents of the definition are those who prefer slogans to thought. Will she ensure that the implementation of the definition this year will be very carefully monitored?

    View contribution permalink →

  21. Baroness Smith of Malvern (Lab)

    I completely agree with the noble Lord. He is right. If anywhere should be enabling careful consideration and education it is our schools and colleges. That is why we are clear that they should not only adopt the definition but, in the way he has described, use it to support teaching and deeper understanding among their pupils.

    View contribution permalink →

  22. Baroness Deech (CB)

    My Lords, the report by Sir David Bell has finally brought to national attention the defects in Holocaust education as it exists today. The report says that antisemitism should be at the heart of it, yet this Government shamefully rejected an amendment from the noble Lord, Lord Verdirame, and me earlier this year that would have confined the proposed learning centre in Westminster to antisemitism. In other words, the Government sought to water it down. That should be changed. We need to review Holocaust education. As the report said, we need teaching about Judaism, contemporary antisemitism and contemporary Jewish life. The little cramped underground learning centre proposed for Victoria Tower Gardens does not tackle that at all; it is about some niche interest relating to the British reaction to the Holocaust. We need fresh thinking. The funds are there. The Government must lead the way and make sure that children are taught about today’s Jews and not, as the report said, that everything ended at the end of the Second World War.

    View contribution permalink →

  23. Baroness Smith of Malvern (Lab)

    There is nothing niche about the responsibility for our schools to teach about the Holocaust. That is within the current national curriculum and will be retained in the future national curriculum. We are clear that education about Jewish life and Jewish people should not start and end with the Holocaust. Sir David made a very important point about how we need to do more to educate our children about Jewish lives, culture and contributions in this country and internationally. That will be a key part of the work we take forward.

    View contribution permalink →

  24. Baroness Hayter of Kentish Town (Lab)

    My Lords, we quite rightly never accuse Muslims or give them responsibility when an Islamic state hangs gay people from a crane in Iran or denies women their rights in Afghanistan, yet there seems to be something about a Jewish state doing something that people do not like that enables them to take it out on Jews altogether. This report will need our teachers to do the work, and we are already hearing that some of them are denying this report. Therefore, my question to my noble friend is: will she ensure that every teacher is given proper antisemitism training, because otherwise this will never happen? If they do not understand the pogroms of the 19th century or the events before the Second World War or actually going back even further, how are they going to be able to make sure that our children are also taught properly?

    View contribution permalink →

  25. Baroness Smith of Malvern (Lab)

    Just to be clear, I do not think it is fair to say that the vast majority of teachers are denying this report; nor are, in fact, the vast majority of trade unions or their members. It is important to be clear about that. My noble friend is right to say that this will need support for teachers. That is why this Government have already, as part of the £7 million invested in tackling antisemitism, provided support, sponsorship, champions and resources that will enable teachers more effectively to tackle antisemitism and teach the full range of issues that I touched on in my previous answer. It is why the revision of teacher standards and the focus in teacher training is also something that we will take forward as part of the approach to implementing Sir David’s recommendations.

    View contribution permalink →

  26. Baroness Ludford (LD)

    My Lords, Judaism is a religion, but Jewishness is a racial identity, as has long been recognised in UK law. As this report says, antisemitism needs to be treated like any other form of racism. Recently, however—within the last month, I think—the hate crime statistics were published, in which, if memory serves, antisemitic abuse was classified only as religious hate. Will the Minister ask the Home Office to go back and look at this, because to classify it only as a religious hate crime is not sufficient? Perhaps antisemitism needs to have its own category in the hate crime statistics, but in any case the racial dimension of antisemitism needs to be recognised alongside any religious dimension.

    View contribution permalink →

  27. Baroness Smith of Malvern (Lab)

    My Lords, I think the noble Baroness’s point is right, which is one of the reasons why my right honourable friend the Secretary of State will also be working with the Office for Equality and Opportunity to ensure that the issues identified in this report are taken forward across government.

    View contribution permalink →

  28. Baroness Spielman (Con)

    My Lords, we have seen the unintended consequences of removing direct curriculum scrutiny by Ofsted in 2005, and it is under the current Government that the partial reinstatement made in 2019 was once again removed. Can the Minister commit to reversing these decisions, which have made it too easy for politicisation and failures of impartiality in curriculum and teaching to go undetected, thus creating the environment in which antisemitism can flourish?

    View contribution permalink →

  29. Baroness Smith of Malvern (Lab)

    I am not sure that I quite agree with the noble Baroness about the chain of causation that she suggests in that question, but I have already been clear about the way in which we expect there to be accountability of teachers and representation of the issues in this report in standards. I have also outlined the work that we will do with Ofsted on this.

    View contribution permalink →

  30. Baroness Blackstone (Lab)

    My Lords, I very much welcome Sir David Bell’s report, and I congratulate him on his recommendations. I am also delighted that the Government have decided to support them all. There are just two points I would like to raise with the Minister. The first is that we must remember that this report is not just about schools; it is about colleges as well. It is interesting that the noble Baroness, Lady Cash, speaking for the Opposition, did not say a single word about colleges; she only talked about schools and teachers, and she did not mention lecturers either. I hope, therefore, that the Minister will ensure that they do not get forgotten. My second point is that Sir David Bell quite rightly said that we should not just be teaching about the Holocaust. We must get a better understanding among children and young people of the enormous contribution that the Jewish population has made, not just to the economy but to science, literature, the arts and the creative industries as well. Will she ensure that the implementation group particularly looks at this issue and determines how we are going to get the curriculum to adequately reflect the great contribution the Jewish community has made, both historically and today?

    View contribution permalink →

  31. Baroness Smith of Malvern (Lab)

    Yes, my noble friend is absolutely right. We need to tackle antisemitism not only by confronting hatred when it occurs, but also by helping more young people in our schools and—she is right—in our colleges to encounter and understand Jewish life, culture and history, building understanding and challenging prejudice before it takes hold. That will be an important part of this work.

    View contribution permalink →

  32. Baroness Finn (Con)

    My Lords, every one of Sir David Bell’s 27 recommendations is framed as “should” and not “must”—a Civil Service device I remember well from my own time in government. Schools, like civil servants, treat “should” as advisory rather than compulsory. Without firm requirements, practice will vary from school to school; so which recommendations will the Government place on a statutory footing, and will antisemitism training for staff be mandatory?

    View contribution permalink →

  33. Baroness Smith of Malvern (Lab)

    The noble Baroness may have tried to get out of her responsibilities in that way when she was in government, but this Government will not. We have been very clear about the spirit and the word of accepting the recommendations in this report. That is why we are setting up the implementation group, and we will expect Sir David Bell to report on how well the recommendations are being implemented in a year.

    View contribution permalink →

  34. Baroness Falkner of Margravine (CB)

    My Lords, I declare an interest as the former chair of the Equality and Human Rights Commission in the past year. It is, of course, the Equality and Human Rights Commission upon which it falls to investigate antisemitism in political parties, which is taking root and is reflected in society and in educational institutions, as we have heard. I am concerned that the Government’s newly framed Islamophobia definition seems to be treated within government—and therefore permeating through to civil society groups—as equivalent to the definition of antisemitism, which, of course, as we have heard this morning, is defined in statute as part of race as well as religion. In the hierarchy of a non-statutory policy, which they say anti-Muslim hostility is, versus antisemitism, there is no comparison of the gravity. Antisemitism in relation to discrimination has to be the policy which the Government take forward at speed and with alacrity. Will she please speak to her colleagues to say that there is no parity of esteem between a policy adopted by government and the law of the land as it stands today?

    View contribution permalink →

  35. Baroness Smith of Malvern (Lab)

    I hope that the noble Baroness can see that the seriousness with which the Government have taken the issue of antisemitism, the Government’s response to Sir David’s recommendations and the work that will follow will show the priority that this Government are giving to tackling antisemitism, given its prevalence and, sadly, its growth in recent years. We are absolutely clear on the priority that we are giving to this work.

    View contribution permalink →

  36. Baroness Altmann (Non-Afl)

    My Lords, I thank the Secretary of State for stating clearly that targeting British Jews and blaming them for events in the Middle East or for actions of the Israeli Government is antisemitism. Can the Minister, then, commit to setting out this principle explicitly in the strengthened political impartiality guidance? I welcome the acceptance of Sir David Bell’s timely recommendations, but following the question of the noble Baroness, Lady Finn, what consequences will there be for breaking these guidelines or for continuing antisemitic behaviour in schools?

    View contribution permalink →

  37. Baroness Smith of Malvern (Lab)

    The question about accountability is very fair. That is why I took some time in my first response to spell out the placing of these issues, both within teacher standards and teacher training, and in the work of Ofsted and the Independent Schools Inspectorate on the thematic work that I identified. Of course, the Government will take accountability in asking Sir David Bell to report back after a year on the progress that is made on these recommendations as well.

    View contribution permalink →

  38. Baroness Berger (Lab)

    My Lords, I welcome this review and its very important 27 recommendations. It shines a spotlight on the horrors facing Jewish students, teachers and parents across our country in schools and colleges—horrors that I know all too well as the parent of two primary-aged children attending a Jewish school. To focus on modern manifestations of antisemitism, we know that antisemitism remains, in some instances, under the cloak of anti-Zionist rhetoric. We have only to look at the motion that was passed recently at the Green Party conference to see just one example of such antisemitism. Can my noble friend the Minister say what plans the Government have to ensure that this specific form of antisemitism, which I name anti-Zionist rhetoric, is appropriately captured and understood in all our classrooms?

    View contribution permalink →

  39. Baroness Smith of Malvern (Lab)

    That may well be an important element to reflect in the new curriculum in thinking about the way schools address this issue. I will not comment on the Green Party, although my noble friend is right about the very backward step that motion represents for that party and the sad impact that it will have on those people who most need our protection, not that type of political activity.

    View contribution permalink →

  40. Baroness Barran (Con)

    My Lords, I want to come back to the point raised by my noble friend Lady Cash on the NEU, and I welcome the comments from the Minister about her own opinion of its rejection of the IHRA definition. What does she think Jewish families, children and teachers will feel if that union is still allowed to attend meetings specifically on this topic?

    View contribution permalink →

  41. Baroness Smith of Malvern (Lab)

    The Secretary of State and I have been very clear about our position as Ministers and the support we will provide to those families. It is for the NEU to answer that question; I have made my views clear.

    View contribution permalink →

  42. Lord Hampton (CB)

    My Lords, I cannot speak for teachers as a whole but, as a teacher, I wonder whether the Minister agrees that the crucial part of the review was the sentence: “I do not believe that encouraging empathy or asking people to consider how others might feel amounts to a restriction on free speech; rather, it is an important part of living and learning together in a diverse society”. Sir David also talks a lot about updating Keeping Children Safe in Education . I once again implore the DfE to publish that in the summer term so that safeguarding leads can absorb it before the autumn.

    View contribution permalink →

  43. Baroness Smith of Malvern (Lab)

    The noble Lord identifies an important part of the report. I agree with his focus on that and with what I think was his view that the vast majority of teachers would also think that that was important. I also hear him on the key point about Keeping Children Safe in Education ; an important point in the report was that tackling antisemitism should be seen as a core element of safeguarding, which is why it should be included as a specific issue within the Keeping Children Safe in Education guidance.

    View contribution permalink →

  44. Lord Grade of Yarmouth (Con)

    My Lords, I start by registering my disappointment that there are no representatives of the Green Party here to hear this debate. That is a sadness and disappointing. I very much welcome this report, which is both chilling and timely. Also, more importantly, the Government’s response is overwhelmingly positive. We can all applaud them for that. I have one small concern, which is that the Government do not intend to measure the uptake of the IHRA definition until the 2027-28 survey, which leaves well over a year before there is any real scrutiny. Do the Government have any plans to monitor this in the meantime until that takes place? In the meantime, will there be some training for teachers to help them deal with real-life incidents in their classrooms while we await the measurement system?

    View contribution permalink →

  45. Baroness Smith of Malvern (Lab)

    Yes. Not only have we already started some of the training that the noble Lord asks about with the additional investment that we have put into tackling antisemitism in education, but it is an important element of the recommendations that we produce much clearer guidance and resources for teachers. We aim to do that as quickly as possible.

    View contribution permalink →

  46. Lord McCabe (Lab)

    My Lords, does my noble friend agree that, rather than risk slipping into a blame game in response to the report, what our schools and colleges may benefit from most is practical support to help them confidently identify what contemporary antisemitism looks like and the consequences for us all of failing to tackle it?

    View contribution permalink →

  47. Baroness Smith of Malvern (Lab)

    My noble friend is absolutely right. That is why I have emphasised—my right honourable friend the Secretary of State emphasised this yesterday and has been very clear in her leadership on it—that it is not enough to condemn what we see in our schools, which quite rightly has happened across the Chamber, notwithstanding some absences; it is also important to provide practical support for teachers in the classroom and for school leaders at times when they face difficult issues that they want to be able to respond to confidently. That is all part of the Government’s plan to respond to this report.

    View contribution permalink →

Source: UK Parliament Hansard API. Debate ID: 5423191.