T

The Minister of State, Department for Education and Department for Work and Pensions (Baroness Smith of Malvern) (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 22 October 2026

Debate

Antisemitism in Schools and Colleges

Contribution

My Lords, as both noble Lords have strongly identified, antisemitism is a scourge that has no place in modern Britain and in our schools and colleges. Yet Sir David Bell’s independent review makes it clear that it is a growing and increasingly normalised form of hatred, with too many Jewish pupils, students and staff experiencing its effects in schools and colleges. The findings are a stark reminder that we cannot be complacent. That is why the Government welcome Sir David Bell’s report, thank those who took part—in some cases at considerable risk and detriment to themselves, as the noble Baroness said—and accept all 27 of its recommendations. The review provides a clear and practical blueprint for action. It recognises, as noble Lords have said, that every school, college and teacher has a responsibility to identify, challenge and prevent antisemitism wherever it occurs, ensuring that all young people can learn in an environment that is safe, respectful and free from discrimination. Our focus must now be on implementation. Accepting the recommendations is only the beginning. Delivering meaningful and lasting change will require sustained effort across the sector. To support this work, the Government have established an implementation group, bringing together key stakeholders to drive progress, share best practice and help ensure that the recommendations are delivered effectively. In the light of the point made by the noble Lord, Lord Mohammed, I am also pleased that Sir David Bell has agreed to undertake a further review in one year’s time. His independent assessment will help ensure that momentum is maintained, that progress is scrutinised and that we remain firmly focused on turning these recommendations into real improvements for Jewish children, students and staff across our education system. I turn to the other questions that have been raised. Of course it is true that all teachers have a responsibility to tackle antisemitism. We are completely clear about that. Teachers’ standards, which are used both for training and for misconduct procedures, are clear about their responsibilities to tackle this issue. If necessary, when those standards are reviewed, we will strengthen them to make that clearer. We understand the need for further training and will develop the resources and training asked for by Sir David Bell in his review. We will review the impartiality guidance to ensure that teachers understand both their requirement to be impartial and their responsibility to enable discussion and debate about difficult issues within their schools while protecting all those who take part in them. The noble Lord, Lord Mohammed, is right that schools must facilitate discussion on these difficult issues. In recent years, they have too often been put off that by a fear about what it means about their political impartiality. The noble Baroness raised particular points about the National Education Union. Sir David did not find that there was opposition to important work to tackle antisemitism across the unions but, as an active member of an NEU predecessor trade union, I wholly disagree with its position on the IHRA definition. The Secretary of State has been clear, in accepting Sir David’s recommendation, that we believe that is the definition that should be used across the education system. In the case of the MP for Bristol North East, which particularly raised concern around this, Ofsted could have examined the aspects of the incident that fell within its inspection remit, and it did so. It could not act as a general investigator into all the surrounding events, campaign activity or motives of external individuals. Those matters sit outside of Ofsted’s statutory inspection powers. We think that both Ofsted and the Independent Schools Inspectorate—we will work with them on this—could do more thematic work, examining how schools and colleges identify, prevent and respond to antisemitism, with the aim of highlighting effective practice, identifying areas for improvement and strengthening the national evidence base. Every young person in school must not only feel able to report incidents of antisemitic abuse or speech within the school but, as the noble Lord said, be confident that those are recorded and that action is taken. That is part of the renewed set of support and guidance that we will provide to schools, but the expectation is clear that all incidents should be recorded and action should be taken. We will consider the points made by the noble Baroness with respect to national reporting of those incidents. On the point about funding, the Government have already made available £7 million to tackle antisemitism in our schools and colleges, which are already responding to some of the issues both in higher education and across our schools. There has been work to tackle mis- and disinformation and conspiracy theories; to develop interfaith discussion; and to enable young people to understand the need to disagree appropriately and to engage in difficult conversations and controversial issues without resorting to antisemitism or racism. Other innovations through the innovation fund are being supported through all this, as are training and new resources for teachers. The Government will support this through their action to put into operation all 27 recommendations of Sir David Bell’s very important report.

More from The Minister of State, Department for Education and Department for Work and Pensions (Baroness Smith of Malvern) (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.