B

Baroness Merron (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 13 October 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I am grateful for the considered contributions from all sides of the House. They have, to put it mildly, been wide ranging, informative and challenging, as I would expect. I ask for the understanding of noble Lords that the time available to me will not allow me to answer every point made. Indeed, more questions will doubtless be unanswered than answered. But I restate my commitment to work with noble Lords as the Bill progresses and we will revisit many of the topics in the weeks to come. I will also reflect on the points made, particularly those that are not within the remit of the Bill, because a number of them were extremely helpful. I make the general point that not all matters that have been raised, as I know noble Lords are aware, are for primary legislation or necessarily for this Bill, though I blame not one noble Lord for taking the opportunity to raise them. Again, that is as I would expect. We should also resist the urge to do something here in legislation when there are other means that could achieve the same outcome, as is usual when it comes to legislation. There are quite a lot of health warnings there. I particularly thank noble Lords who brought not only their professional experience but their personal experience or that of those who are near and dear to them. They included my noble friend Lord Winston, the noble Baronesses, Lady Maclean, Lady Barker and Lady Grey-Thompson, and the noble Lords, Lord Bird and Lord Scriven. Our personal experiences absolutely inform how we see the way forward. I also associate myself with the congratulations on five excellent maiden speeches, from my noble friends Lord Jabbar, Lady Lowe and Lord Smith, and the noble Lords, Lord Wormald and Lord Singh. I associate myself with many of the points made by our new colleagues, including that where we start does not determine where we have to end up—that resonates very much with me—and that we should be proud of those who work in public service, and indeed we are. We are blessed to have all five of our new colleagues join us in your Lordships’ House and we very much look forward to hearing more from them. A number of points have been made about where the National Health Service is at present, and it is important to make a few comments. I welcome those who have acknowledged the improvements that we have made and the position that we started from. As of March this year, we had met the interim target of 65% of patients waiting up to 18 weeks, when we were nowhere near that just over two years ago, and we will go further. Patient satisfaction is rising. When I was a Health Minister in the previous Labour Government, it was at its highest, but sadly it went to its lowest. We are rebuilding that, and I am glad about the improvement. Similarly, this summer, in June, July and August—noble Lords will know the extra pressure of the heatwaves that were experienced then—a record 4.7 million-plus treatments, procedures and appointments were carried out, more than in any previous summer. I would be happy to bore your Lordships’ House, if that is what it does to the House, with more evidence of the upward trajectory, but it is only fair not to talk down the NHS where we have improvements, and I am glad that so many noble Lords acknowledged that. I shall run through some of the points that were raised. I was most grateful for what I will call broad support for the Bill. There were many supporters, including my noble friends Lord Hunt and Lady Thornton, who both set out better than I would—so I do not need to repeat it—the impact of previous legislation and changes to the structure of the NHS. I also heard support from the noble Baronesses, Lady Coffey and Lady Neville-Rolfe, among others. I have heard the argument that much of this could be done without legislation. I suggest that it is far better for the law to reflect the reality of the system that we want, one that has clear roles and responsibilities. To make the point, as many noble Lords have supported the abolition of NHS England: that cannot be abolished without primary legislation. With regard to transition arrangements, points were raised by the noble Baronesses, Lady Gerada and Lady Wyld, and the noble Lord, Lord Scriven, among others. We are committed to transparency and parliamentary scrutiny throughout this process. We will continue to publish updates and revised impact assessments, and we will expect to be held to account, as I know noble Lords would expect. There are strong arrangements in place to monitor delivery, including oversight of workforce risks, knowledge transfer and service continuity, but these changes are not distracting from our focus on performance. I understand why that concern was raised, as I understand the reasons for all the concerns that were raised today, and I know we will work through them all. This summer, as I mentioned, has been the busiest in the history of the NHS, yet more patients than ever before were seen within four hours in A&E despite record demand. With regard to costs, savings and benefits, which were raised particularly by the noble Earl, Lord Howe, and the noble Lords, Lord Stevens and Lord Kamall, with the abolition of NHSE and the restructuring of ICBs we expect savings of up to £1 billion a year by the end of this Parliament. That will be driven primarily by reductions in headcount, and we expect that savings will build year on year rather than being realised immediately. On the impact assessment, as usual the focus will be on the impacts of primary legislation rather than secondary and consequential decisions. Our approach to the impact assessment—which the noble Lord, Lord Stevens, kindly raised—is in line with the HM Treasury Green Book guidance and the Better Regulation Framework, as I am sure noble Lords recognise. I was glad that my noble friend Lord Carter made the point about the need to rightly be focused on outputs. The input of money has clearly not delivered what any of us would have wanted over some considerable time, and our focus on and measurement of outputs is absolutely crucial. I confirm to my noble friend Lady Nargund that, as I said earlier, integrated care boards will be the strategic commissioners of health services. They will take ownership of areas that are currently delegated to them, such as primary medical care and dentistry, as well as delegated specialist services, such as adult HIV services—as was raised by the noble Lord, Lord Black, and the noble Baroness, Lady Barker—and dialysis. To support ICBs and ensure national consistency, we will use the power of direction over ICBs to set out the expectations of, for example, access criteria or the types of services to be commissioned. On ICB membership, the Bill will reform the required membership of ICB boards to align them more closely with their role as strategic commissioners. I assure my noble friend Lord Bradley that the requirement for a member of an ICB to have mental health experience—as he referred to—remains unchanged. On the accountability of ICBs—which was raised by the noble Earl, Lord Howe, and the noble Baronesses, Lady Redfern, Lady Walmsley, and Lady Shawcross-Wolfson—integrated care board commissioning will continue to have clear performance and accountability arrangements in legislation, including a requirement to publish annual reports and accounts setting out how they have discharged their functions and delivered against their targets. I wrote a very long list of noble Lords who referred to Healthwatch and the patient voice. I had to strike a pen through that, because, unsurprisingly, nearly every noble Lord referred to it. We do not believe that the current structures consistently and effectively connect patient voice or lived experience to the decisions that shape services and deliver outcomes. As I mentioned earlier, our feeling is that, by placing responsibility directly with ICBs and local authorities, we will enable patient insight to inform commissioning, service planning and improvement. That said, we recognise—as I said at the outset and re-emphasise now—the strength of feeling about these changes and the reasons that noble Lords are raising their concerns. I have already stated our commitment to work with noble Lords to review these measures and ensure that any arrangements really do empower local communities and provide transparency on what people have told the system and on how it responded. This is an area for further work. A number of noble Lords—including the noble Baronesses, Lady Manzoor, Lady Pidgeon and Lady Watkins, and the noble Lords, Lord Patel and Lord Lansley—raised HSSIB and patient safety. As I stated at the outset, I cannot overemphasise our commitment to listening to noble Lords on this important matter. I want to see a strong link between investigation, system learning and improvement, and helping safety insights lead more directly to lasting change. I agree that patient safety depends on a culture in which concerns can be raised, lessons are learned and meaningful improvement follows. I therefore emphasise our commitment to listening further to noble Lords. Most noble Lords, rightly, also raised the single patient record. I am grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Kamall, and the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, for their support from their Front Benches for this, which is central to our ambition for a modern, joined-up NHS. I know that noble Lords understand the reason that we have raised it. The noble Lord, Lord Tarassenko, was helpful in raising the important issue of health data for research. We know that data from the single patient record could offer significant opportunities, including more intelligently planning our health services and conducting life-saving research. However, the primary focus of the SPR is to offer and support direct care. The Bill does not create any new legal gateways to accessing health data for secondary purposes, such as planning and research, important though they are; nor does it enable data to be collected for these purposes. But it does contain a savings provision that the SPR can be a source of data for secondary uses, such as planning and research, where there is a separate legal basis to do so. This will ensure that we do not miss opportunities but guarantee that strict legal security and confidentiality standards—which are the concerns, rightly, of noble Lords—are met. That will include existing data protection legislation. I heard noble Lords, including the noble Baroness, Lady Kidron, and the noble Lord, Lord Kamall, among others, raise important points about data, security, public trust and privacy. When it comes to health data in particular, trust is everything, as many noble Lords, including the noble Baroness, Lady Harding, have said, which is why the SPR will be designed with the highest standards of cybersecurity and information governance. Let me emphasise this: access to patient information will be restricted to authorised users only, with an audit trail of who has accessed the patient’s data, to clamp down on some of the serious transgressions that we have seen of late. I will come back to the noble Lord, Lord Patel, on the point about the common law duty of confidentiality. With regard to the federated data platform, I heard concerns from the noble Lord, Lord Scriven, and the noble Baroness, Lady Bennett, about Palantir. Let me say again that the single patient record is different; it is intended that it will be delivered through contracts with multiple suppliers. I heard my noble friend Lady Martin’s wish that those would be UK providers, on which I certainly would share her wish and intent. On women’s health and maternity, I am grateful for the acknowledgement from a number of noble Lords, including the noble Baronesses, Lady Wyld, Lady Sugg, Lady Manzoor, Lady Pidgeon, Lady Hodgson, and others. I appreciate the acknowledgement of the work that has already taken place and the direction that the Government are taking. We are, as we speak, working up the amendments for the maternity and neonatal commissioner. I look forward to engaging further on this, because it is a priority of this Government to urgently tackle the systemic issues across maternity and neonatal care which have been going on for so many years and are totally unacceptable. By the end of the year, we will be publishing a single national action plan. It will be overseen by the national maternity and neonatal taskforce, and it will drive improvement in maternity and neonatal care exactly where it matters—to families, to clinicians and to others. The plan will include recommendations from the independent investigation of the noble Baroness, Lady Amos. We are most grateful to the noble Baroness for her work. It will include findings from the Thirlwall report and from the reviews led by Donna Ockenden. We need a single national action plan which will fundamentally drive a systemic and sustained improvement that we have not seen. The taskforce will hold the system to account, and I look forward to this House holding us to account as well. The issue of health inequalities was raised by the right reverend Prelate, the noble Baronesses, Lady Hollins, Lady Cass and Lady Tyler, and my noble friend Lord Sahota. The Bill reaffirms our commitment to achieving greater equality in the provision of health services—both the ability to access these services and the outcomes achieved. ICBs will lead on improving services because of their clarified role as strategic commissioners. However, they have to deliver demonstrable improvements for disadvantaged groups and underserved communities, including those in the rural, coastal and deprived urban areas. We will also, as part of our 10-year health plan, distribute NHS funding to better align it with health need. That includes establishing a neighbourhood health centre in every community, beginning with—not ending with—places where health and life expectancy is lowest. Briefly, on adult social care, our commitment, emphasised by the Prime Minister, is on building a national care service, and that is why we have brought forward the timetable for the vital independent commission of the noble Baroness, Lady Casey. In the meantime, we are acting on early recommendations, including on dementia, motor neurone disease and safeguarding. I assure your Lordships’ House that the mental health investment standard will continue to apply, in the same way that this Government are committed to improving outcomes and reducing health inequalities for those with learning disabilities, autistic people and people with ADHD, as acknowledged by the noble Baronesses, Lady Hollins, Lady Browning and Lady Leaman. I am immensely grateful to noble Lords for their contributions in what has been a very helpful debate. I note, as others have done, that the Bill marks another ground-breaking moment for this House: the first use of AI, to give voice to the noble Baroness, Lady Campbell—I know that she is watching us online. I pay tribute, as we all do, to the work that the noble Baroness has done to make the rules of this Chamber more accessible. We are all very fond of Baroness Campbell mark 1, and we are looking forward to getting even more fond of Baroness Campbell mark 2, as she referred to her AI voice. Let us hear more of it. I assure her that we remain committed to personalisation and personal health budgets, as in the 10-year plan. I know that we will continue these discussions in Committee, both in and outside the Chamber. For now, I commend the Bill to the House.

More from Baroness Merron (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.