Contribution
My Lords, I begin by thinking the Minister for the way she introduced the Bill, and all noble Lords who spoke in this debate. For reasons which noble Lords will understand, I will not name them all, but I was particularly touched by the speech of the noble Baroness, Lady Campbell of Surbiton, in her own voice thanks to AI, and moved by the speech of the noble Baroness, Lady Barker, in which she shared her personal sad experience.
I thank those who made their maiden speeches, including the noble Lord, Lord Jabbar, who spoke of the need for accountability; the noble Baroness, Lady Lowe of Armley, who shared her experience of Touchstone in Leeds and the importance of the independent patient voice; the noble Lord, Lord Wormald, with whom I worked when I was a Health Minister; the noble Lord, Lord Smith of Ranmoor, who spoke of the importance of a healthy diet; and my noble friend Lord Singh of Solihull, who humbly shared a hint of his considerable experience in psychiatry. Each maiden speech demonstrated the experience and wisdom that we can look forward to in future debates. If it is any reassurance to the noble Lords, I often still wonder what I am doing here—and, frankly, if I go over my speaking time I fear that many noble Lords will ask the same question.
Before I go further, I declare my interest as a professor of politics and international relations at St Mary’s University in Twickenham, where I recently taught an MBA course in healthcare policy. I am also helping the university with its new medical school.
As my noble friend Lord Howe said, we on these Benches support removing the unnecessary duplication of functions between NHS England and DHSC, as most noble Lords do. But as we heard from the noble Lord, Lord Stevens, and others, the reorganisation was announced without any clear idea of the costs and benefits. My first question to the Minister is this: when will these costs and benefits be explicitly published, and when will the operational model referred to by the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, be published, so that we can have a clearer idea of how this new world will work?
I do not doubt the Government’s good intentions, but legislation must be judged not on intentions but on whether it improves the patient experience and health outcomes. This means listening to patients when they tell us something is wrong and ensuring that those warnings result in change. That is precisely why an independent patient voice matters. As noble Lords have said, Healthwatch organisations provide that independent patient voice, gathering the experiences of patients and communities and ensuring that they are heard by those responsible. They speak truth to power.
While not perfect, the independent patient voice for health should not be seen as simply measuring satisfaction. It warns of failures in the quality and safety of care, and it raises flags for others to look at. Look at the volume of compensation from NHS Resolution, to the value of billions of pounds: behind each one of those figures are patients and families whose lives have been profoundly changed and, sadly, in many cases scarred. They may take many years to recover, if ever.
The Government’s proposals to bring that patient voice in-house to integrated care boards and local authorities raises important questions about independence. I understand the reasons for returning powers to Ministers, but if those responsible for a system are also responsible for gathering criticism of it, how can Ministers guarantee that patients will have the same confidence to speak candidly, especially those from more deprived communities who do not often get a chance to speak to those in power?
Given that the Prime Minister, when Mayor of Greater Manchester, wrote to the Secretary of State warning that dissolving Healthwatch would risk losing an independent and trusted patient voice, I wonder what conversations are ongoing within the new Government on proceeding with its abolition.
Similarly, we share the concerns of the noble Lord, Lord Hunt, about proposals to abolish independent health governors. They provide an important role in accountability and we must think very carefully about what happens if you remove that level of accountability.
That question of independence leads me to the proposed abolition of the Health Services Safety Investigations Body and transferring its functions to the CQC. HSSIB performs a different but equally important function, investigating patient safety concerns not to apportion blame or liability, and not to point fingers, but to understand systemic failures and prevent them happening again. Its investigations operate within statutory confidentiality protections.
Ministers have offered reassurance about maintaining autonomy, but legitimate questions remain. Will patients, families and healthcare professionals have the same confidence in the safe space principle when the investigating body sits within the regulator? How will its genuine independence be protected? These are questions that need to be answered.
And, frankly, is the CQC able and competent to take on these functions? During the Mental Health Bill, these Benches supported the Government on resisting calls for an independent mental health commissioner, instead supporting beefing up the CQC’s capacity on mental health. However, as the noble Lord, Lord Bradley, remarked, it is interesting that the Government have since decided to establish an independent maternity commissioner, rather than ask the Patient Safety Commissioner or the CQC to take on that role. Even more recently, I and other noble Lords have repeatedly tried to engage with the CQC on concerns that many healthcare providers have over the CQC’s understanding of, and its ability to regulate, sports and public events. To be frank, I have not been impressed. I do not say this lightly, but I currently have no confidence in the CQC to regulate these events.
It is worth noting that the widely respected incoming chair of the CQC, the noble Baroness, Lady Neuberger, told the Health and Social Care Committee only last month that the CQC was not currently a trusted and respected regulator. Given that assessment, what evidence can the Minister point to that demonstrates that the CQC is ready to take on the responsibilities currently held by HSSIB? The objective should be fewer safety failures, not fewer safety organisations.
A number of noble Lords have heard, and perhaps repeated, the mantra that you cannot solve healthcare until you fix social care. So we welcome the Prime Minister’s commitment to bring forward the Casey review, but I am sure that noble Lords will want to probe the Government further on their plans for social care during this Bill.
Like many other noble Lords, we support in principle the single patient record. As I found to my frustration when I was a Health Minister, patient information remains unconnected across different parts of the health and care system. The Government themselves note that clinicians can be left working with an incomplete picture while patients find themselves repeatedly giving the same medical history. A properly implemented single patient record could be transformative, giving clinicians access to the right information at the right time, improving continuity of care, supporting early intervention and ultimately improving patient safety.
But that does not mean that we will give the Government a blank cheque on this. There remain legitimate questions. Noble Lords may be aware of questions around what can be described as voyeur medical staff who access patient records after national scandals even though they have no medical reason to do so. Or there is the case of the senior consultant, as reported in the Guardian recently, who accessed and inappropriately shared the medical of information of her ex-boyfriend’s current girlfriend. Such stories beg the question of who will be able to access and edit a patient’s record. How will patients know who has accessed their records? In addition, how can inaccurate information be corrected, and what additional safeguards will protect particularly sensitive information?
I was contacted by a lady who found that notes from her psychotherapy at a south London trust, including correspondence on her concerns about a GP practice, were available through the London Care Record, including to the practice about which she had complained. She had been previously assured that this would not happen and she had to pause her therapy after making this discovery.
We are not against a single patient record. In fact, we are in favour of it, but there have to be the right safeguards. Different parts of the NHS continue to use different systems. Indeed, the Government acknowledge this, and so we have to look at this system of interoperability. While patients will benefit from a single patient record, they must have confidence that the most sensitive information that they provide will remain properly protected. Otherwise, we will be creating a health service that is better in sharing information but in which patients have less confidence.
We are discussing these reforms in the context of an ageing population, increased demand for health and care, a decline in people paying into the system relative to those who take out, and public scepticism about immigration to replace our ageing workforce and taxpayers. We have more doctors and nurses than ever before, but we need more capacity. The former Health and Social Care Secretary, Wes Streeting, recognised this and thought that AI could be the solution. But what are patients doing? They are turning to independent healthcare providers. This is not new. My father’s membership of the Transport and General Workers’ Union included treatment for him and my mother at an independent Premier Health hospital. Today, trade unions offer private health insurance or health plans as part of their membership package.
In seeking to increase the capacity supply of healthcare, is there a way that we can work together across the political divide on an increased role for non-state providers to complement the NHS, especially healthcare mutuals such as Benenden Health, charities, friendly societies, co-operatives, social enterprises, non-profit private providers and, where appropriate, private providers? If and where appropriate in this Bill, I hope we can agree to increase independent healthcare capacity to complement, not replace, the National Health Service. This will of course include appropriate access to the single patient record and appropriate safeguards.
These Benches accept that reform may deliver savings, yet we await a timeline and proper cost-benefit analysis. Removing unnecessary duplication, improving productivity and making better use of technology are objectives that we support, but the measure of successful reform is whether taxpayers receive value and patients receive better care. The prize is considerable, but so too is the responsibility. On these Benches, we will be constructive in our approach. Where the Government make a clear case, we will support them. Where we have concerns, we will challenge and scrutinise. We will work together with noble Lords across the House to deliver a Bill that enables a better system of healthcare for patients, no matter where they live and whatever their background.