Contribution
My Lords, this has been a wide-ranging debate with excellent contributions from across the House. I particularly pay tribute to the high-quality maiden speeches from the noble Lords, Lord Wormald, Lord Smith of Ranmoor, Lord Singh of Solihull and Lord Jabbar, and the noble Baroness, Lady Lowe of Armley. I look forward to working with them on this Bill and beyond. I also thank my noble friend Lady Barker for describing her very real experience of being a carer and navigating the health service with her wife.
Anyone who has had any interaction with the National Health Service knows that it is creaking at the seams. People are struggling to get GP appointments. Access to NHS dentists is impossible in many parts of the country. People are waiting for hours and hours for care in our stretched A&E departments. The shocking state of our maternity services we have discussed many times in this Chamber. The country is crying out for change in our health service. The Bill does bring changes, but mostly structural ones. It will do nothing in the short term to improve patient experience and outcomes, as the noble Lord, Lord Carter of Coles, highlighted. As the King’s Fund has rightly pointed out, as was mentioned by my noble friend Lord Scriven:
“Evidence from previous reorganisations suggests structural reform alone … rarely improves care unless it is clearly linked to practical changes in … services”.
The narrative from the Government is about neighbourhoods, and I welcome the neighbourhood health plans in the Bill, but plans and rhetoric are not enough. The money has to follow if we are to deliver services at the most appropriate level centred around patients and their needs—not simply for the convenience of the commissioner and the large trusts. We on these Benches believe that a primary care investment standard should be in the Bill to increase spending on primary care services to support this shift to neighbourhood health.
As the Royal College of General Practitioners has pointed out,
“the current system focuses too much on hospitals and not enough on general practice. This has led to the proportion of the NHS budget spent on general practice falling to its lowest point in at least 10 years”.
This is not sustainable. As I have raised several times in this House, there are around 600,000 people waiting for hospital eye appointments. Many of these could easily be dealt with on the high street locally, if commissioning for these basic services was universal and genuine patient choice was supported. As ICBs develop their commissioning roles, it would be helpful to understand the level of basic foundation services that everyone should have a right to, wherever they live. This is a concern that the noble Baroness, Lady Redfern, also raised. My noble friend Lady Janke raised the important role of community pharmacies as another part of primary care. Primary care must be fully at the table with ICBs if neighbourhood health is truly to work, and this needs to change in the Bill. Continuity of care is crucial, as the noble Baroness, Lady Gerada, set out.
As we have heard loudly and clearly, there are serious concerns about the abolition of NHS England, with the Secretary of State becoming the decision maker in micro decisions throughout the NHS—a politician getting involved in decisions that are for management. Government needs to remain strategic, not operational. Blurring the distinction between day-to-day NHS management and political accountability is not going to end well. That is why the new operating model needs to be published as soon as possible, clearly setting out the responsibilities of the Secretary of State, the department and ICBs, so that we can better scrutinise the Bill. Perhaps the Minister can advise when we might see this important model.
So many charities I have met are concerned about specialist commissioning and the capacity and capability of ICBs in this area. Too often NICE guidelines are being ignored and there are concerns that this may also happen with NICE recommendations, with delays in implementation. The Bill is an opportunity to strengthen confidence in access to innovation and strengthen implementation of NICE recommendations across the NHS. I hope the Government will support amendments in this area.
Charities are also concerned about the potential loss of central clinical expertise. How will the Minister ensure that sufficient expert clinical roles and expertise are incorporated into the department beyond the five cross-cutting national priority programmes? Diabetes is one such area, as outlined by my noble friend Lord Rennard.
A number of other important health matters have been raised, such as public health and vaccinations, by my noble friend Lady Walmsley; the need to reduce inequalities in mortality for people with a learning disability and autistic people, by my noble friend Lord Scriven, also raised by the noble Baroness, Lady Hollins; and the issue of unpaid carers, including respite care, by my noble friend Lady Tyler, also raised by the noble Baroness, Lady Lister. My noble friend Lady Leaman talked about the impact of these structural changes on those with ADHD and autism—important issues to consider as we scrutinise the Bill. The noble Baroness, Lady Cass, and others flagged the absence of children and young people.
The Bill as it stands plans to abolish Healthwatch England and local Healthwatch organisations, stripping away the independent patient voice. For over 50 years, there has been a statutory independent patient voice in the health and social care system, and this needs to continue. The Government have confirmed that they are reviewing this part of the Bill. I hope they will remove this section and go further and strengthen Healthwatch organisations across the country.
We have received report after report of failings in the health service. Patients often will not take action, even when they have experienced poor care, as they fear it will impact their ongoing treatment. That is why we need an independent patient voice to listen to patient feedback, expose challenges and drive change locally. Other noble Lords have supported this, including the noble Lord, Lord Hunt of Kings Heath, the noble Baroness, Lady Jay, the noble Lord, Lord Patel, and the noble Baroness, Lady Lowe, who made a passionate speech outlining what was happening in Leeds—and many others.
The Healthwatch organisations I have spoken to and heard from have been effective in working with local communities and being able to bring to health and care organisations any concerns, or wider issues that need to be addressed. This cannot be done by an internal team in a trust or council. We await movement from the Government ahead of Committee.
Let us talk about safety. The Health Services Safety Investigations Body was established to investigate specific cases or incidents of severe harm and to produce lessons rather than blame, rather like the model used for aviation and rail safety investigations. It established the safe-space model in law to encourage disclosures from professionals without fear of sanction, so the decision to scrap HSSIB is a major concern and is fraught with risk. A trusted and efficient safety investigation process is the best way of restoring trust, learning from system failure and preventing costly public inquiries. Dr Tim Meek, president of the Association of Anaesthetists, has said:
“It is vital that HSSIB retains its complete independence from the NHS, the organisation that it is principally tasked to investigate. This lesson has been learned in other high-stakes industries, and we should take note”.
We hope the Government will reconsider this proposal. Putting this as part of the CQC will not be acceptable to anyone, as has been expressed clearly by noble Lords today, including the noble Baroness, Lady Watkins of Tavistock.
Maternity services have rightly been a focus, and I know they are a real concern to the Minister. Recent figures show that 75% of the public are concerned about hospital birth standards following recent safety inspection ratings. Women are overwhelmingly worried, with 79% expressing anxiety over maternity care, especially given that not one NHS maternity unit in England has an outstanding safety rating and two-thirds of units have been flagged as unsafe. We want to see 24/7 consultants on every maternity ward and one-to-one midwifery care. To drive the change, we need a maternity commissioner with the right resources and powers to make change happen. The Government have indicated that they will support this proposal, and we hope that we can move forward to drive the change that is needed for women and babies. Perhaps the Minister can clarify how the role will sit with the national maternity and neonatal taskforce and what powers the commissioner will have to ensure the change that is needed.
The Liberal Democrats welcome the move to create a single patient record. This is potentially the only bit of the Bill that could transform patient experience and outcomes. People are tired of having to repeat their medical histories countless times to different medical and other professionals, and patient harm can occur when clinicians have not had a patient’s full medical history. However, as has been highlighted by noble Lords, this must come alongside new privacy protections and safeguards for patients. Patients do not want their health data sold and used. There are challenges in developing the single patient record, and we look forward to working with others to ensure that safeguards are in place that enable this development in a safe way. Data security and patient trust must be at the core, and the noble Baroness, Lady Kidron, set out some of the key concerns around data in this area.
My noble friend Lord Foster of Bath had hoped to speak in this debate, but unfortunately he has Covid—I think it must be going round. I know he has a particular concern about the current levels of medical support, not least mental health support, for prisoners, both in prison and when they leave, and has questions about how the new arrangements will improve the situation. I hope the Minister will agree to meet my noble friend to discuss this issue, and maybe the noble Lord, Lord Bradley, as well, who has also raised concerns today on that point.
The one glaring omission from the Bill is social care. We have a crisis. The new Prime Minister recognises this crisis. Fixing social care is crucial to enabling our health service to function better. Better support for the frail and vulnerable is essential. There is the opportunity while we consider the Bill to look at enabling options to help speed up delivering on social care. I hope the Government will consider this as the Bill progresses.
To conclude, in so many ways it is easy constantly to look at the structure of the NHS, and Government after Government have played with this time and again. In my view, the key is to get services out of hospitals into local communities and high streets centred around the patient, shifting resources to primary and community care, which helps with the preventive agenda and also frees hospitals to do what they do best. Will this Bill make a difference to patient care? Will it strengthen the patient voice? Will it improve patient safety and reduce bureaucracy? These are the measures of success, and we on these Benches will table amendments to improve safety, services and, most importantly, outcomes for patients.