Contribution
My Amendment 219 addresses the deeply concerning and increasingly common practice of corridor care. No patient should be left receiving treatment, assessment or prolonged care in a corridor simply because there is nowhere else for them to go. A friend of mine only a couple of weekends ago showed me a picture of a relative in hospital, who was in a corridor. This is absolutely unacceptable. As we heard from the noble Baroness, Lady Finlay, it was on the news again today. Corridor care undermines patient dignity, compromises privacy, increases clinical risk and places additional strain on hard-working NHS staff who are trying to deliver safe care in environments that were never designed for that purpose.
We all recognise the immense pressures our hospitals are facing, from rising demand to workforce shortages and delayed discharge, but corridor care must never become normalised, as I fear it has, as an acceptable feature of our health service. Dr Ian Higginson, president of the Royal College of Emergency Medicine, has described corridor care as
“dangerous, undignified, and a source of national shame”.
Survey data published by the royal college only on 20 July shows that 61% of clinical leads in England said that their trusts did not even capture corridor care accurately, with many saying that patients who were on chairs and in waiting rooms waiting for admission were not counted towards their corridor care figure.
There is significant variation in reporting between hospitals and emergency departments. Consultants are concerned about patients who wait on chairs in waiting rooms, off-the-clock assessment units and the repurposing of space as “non-corridor” places, where they put chairs so that patients can wait and not be counted. I have even been told of somebody being sat on a chair in a cupboard because that would not count towards corridor care figures. This is also not counting patients waiting in ambulances or on corridors on the way into departments. It is simply unacceptable. This amendment would help shine a light on the true scale of the problem and support genuine efforts to ensure that patients are treated in appropriate clinical settings with the dignity, safety and respect that every person deserves when they turn up to their hospital in their time of need. We need this to lead to the end of this practice.
My Amendment 229 seeks to address another visible symptom of the pressures that our National Health Service faces: the growing difficulty in securing timely admission from accident and emergency departments into appropriate hospital beds. When patients have been assessed and a clinical decision has been made that they require admission, prolonged waits in A&E not only are frustrating but can lead to poorer outcomes, increased risk to patient safety and greater distress for patients and their families. These delays also contribute to serious overcrowding in emergency departments, making it harder for clinicians to deliver care to all those who come through their doors. While we know that the causes are complex—bed capacity, workforce shortages, which we talked about earlier, and the difficulty of discharging medically fit patients into the community and social care settings, as we heard from the noble Baroness, Lady Finlay—we should be clear that long waits for admission are just not acceptable.
This amendment would provide greater transparency and accountability and help ensure that the health system focuses on reducing delays and delivering the safe, timely and dignified care that patients have every right to receive. Putting this right in the NHS constitution would focus efforts and make sure that we address this serious issue. We do not want patients avoiding A&E because they fear endless hours of waiting. We know that is happening; we hear about it. Sorting out admissions and ending corridor care would transform the patient experience and, most importantly, patient outcomes.
The amendment tabled by the noble Lord, Lord Patel of Bradford, on prohibiting minimum waiting times is important. We discussed this in a group only last week. We need to see waiting times minimised and patients receive the diagnostics and treatment that they need in a timely manner—one that is led clinically rather than by budget rationing, which we see too often today. The amendment from the noble Baroness, Lady Coffey, talks about ambulance services. I commend the recent work by the Public Services Committee, which looked at the response and reaction between ambulance services and emergency departments, but it only scratched the surface of that issue. A lot more could be done with that workforce and those teams to ensure that patients get to the right door for further clinical care. I look forward to the Minister’s response to this important group, as this is really on the minds of the public today.