B

Baroness Finlay of Llandaff (CB)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 11 November 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I shall address Amendments 219 and 229, tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon. I have already had a brief discussion with her, because I would have liked to have signed Amendment 229, except for a bit of the wording. She is absolutely right that corridor care is one of the scandals of our time. In fact, it was on the news at lunchtime today, with patients being filmed in corridors still. We also still have social care problems arriving in emergency departments. These are people who really need to be looked after; they cannot just be sent out. One thing about emergency departments is that people arrive, attend and then, after they are assessed, there is a decision about whether they are to be admitted. There is a clear line in the way that the figures are collected. That becomes important because roughly 25% of the people who attend are actually admitted. We have to be really careful that there is no gaming around these figures, which can happen by managers if targets are put in that become difficult to reach for one reason or another. There are terribly long trolley waits at the moment. In each of the past three years, over half a million patients have been waiting on trolleys. As we touched on at Oral Questions yesterday, the flow through hospitals is a problem, with very high bed occupancies. We have far fewer beds in our NHS than the average across the EU—we have below half of that average. Also, the countries that have lower bed numbers often have other services in place. For example, in the Netherlands, the numbers of beds in hospitals are not that high but it has the discipline of nursing home medicine, with a large number of beds and staff trained to a very high level. One problem that we face is the flow through hospitals —in, through and out of them. In simply addressing the front door, we are not addressing the problem properly, because there are a number of patients who are deemed to be medically fit for discharge but remain in hospital. That number is estimated at nearly 13,000 patients a day, which is huge. These patients are deemed to have been medically optimised but no longer need to remain in the hospital. The design of our emergency departments does not help in relation to corridor care or other care. I had the privilege of spending some time in Groningen in the north of the Netherlands and was astounded at its emergency department, which was superbly laid out. There were two direct resus rooms from the ambulance bay, fully equipped so that they could be turned into emergency operating theatres for very major trauma, with CT scanners in them. They had moved from the open front door, which we have, to being able to move major trauma and other problems straight into much more appropriate environments than we have been providing. I commend the Government for taking on the problem of modernisation, but I hope that we look at the whole issue of patient experience and patient flow and recognise that, unless we do something about our emergency departments, the more than 90% of staff who feel that they cannot cope in the longer term will be on their knees and we will have more problems going forward.

More from Baroness Finlay of Llandaff (CB)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.