B

Baroness Finlay of Llandaff (CB)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 9 November 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Neville-Rolfe, for having brought this to our attention. As my noble friend Lady Gerada said, continuity of care is incredibly important. A relationship with a clinician is a two-way process. As a patient, you need to have confidence in that clinician and they need to understand the complexity of you as a person. It is very easy to think that this is all about facts that we write down: observations and things that go in patient notes. However, it is important to remember that about 80% of communication is non-verbal. Therefore, the way that you have seen a patient and the way that you observe them later on become absolutely critical. In my own time when I was a GP, we used to take all our own calls up until midnight and then quite often we were in the pooled rota with other practices. However, that meant that whoever phoned up during the evening was somebody we already knew and understood, and I think we were able to give much more appropriate advice or decide to go straight out to see them than happens now with the 111 screening process. In my own discipline of specialist palliative care, that continuity is incredibly important. We are looking after patients with very complex needs, often very young people, and conversations with children about the fact that their parent is dying is not something that you can have from one person to another. It has to be the same clinician, whether that is a specialist nurse, the doctor or a specialist social worker, who then follows through. Building up confidence with that family as they face the ultimate disaster is really important, and most of that is non-verbal and interpersonal. We have seen the advent of Martha’s rule, which has come about because parents have observed that their child was looking and behaving less well, and they were alert even though the staff around had not noticed or picked up on the signs. In a terribly sad way, that is an overwhelming testament to the importance of some continuity, rather than simply looking at observations and exchanging facts. I can see that perhaps the wording of the amendment could do with a little modification. However, we have raised a very important subject tonight and there is a core principle, and that will mean stripping out some of the bureaucracy that is stopping clinicians from having the continuity that they want to have and that their patients want from them. The noble Baroness, Lady Neville-Rolfe, spoke about patients getting letters. In fact, it is now standard practice across the NHS in secondary care that a patient will get a letter. Sometimes it is dictated at the time when the patient is still in the room and then they will get the hard copy afterwards. Some clinicians will tape-record the conversation—although not so much now—and allow the patient to listen to it again at home later on, and then see them for questions to be asked. That has come about, but it does not substitute for this core principle of actually being able to have continuity. The one thing that is important is that we do not force patients to be locked into continuity with somebody who they do not feel comfortable with or have confidence in, and who, really, they never want to see again. They need to be able to choose to see somebody different.

More from Baroness Finlay of Llandaff (CB)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.