Contribution
My Lords, I feel like a mere iron filing after the magnet of wisdom and knowledge from the noble Baroness, Lady Gerada, on primary care and continuity of care, but I will be a little iron filing that does its best. I will speak to Amendment 60, which would insert a new clause after Clause 14, and Amendment 62 to Schedule 1. They are both in my name and I thank the noble Lord, Lord Holmes of Richmond, who is not in his place at the moment, for adding his name to them.
These amendments are about people who the NHS too often fails to see and who, too often, cannot see well for themselves. SeeAbility has campaigned on this for many years and I am particularly grateful to Scott Watkin and Donna O’Brien for their help, research and guidance on these amendments. Research for the Royal National Institute of Blind People and SeeAbility found that adults with a learning disability are 10 times more likely than the general population to be blind or partially sighted. Nearly one in 10 is blind or partially sighted and around six in 10 need glasses. For children with a learning disability, the risk of serious sight problems is 20 times higher.
The conditions are cataracts, glaucoma, diabetic retinopathy and keratoconus. The last of those conditions affects as many as one in 10 people with Down syndrome. According to the Down’s Syndrome Association, if it is not caught early it can take sight for good, yet those at greatest risk are among the least likely to be tested. Around half of adults with a learning disability have not had a sight test in the recommended two years.
When SeeAbility tested children in special schools, more than four in 10 had never had their eyes checked at all. Many people with a learning disability cannot tell us that their sight is failing; instead, it shows up as withdrawal, distress or falls, and too often this is put down to the learning disability itself. This is called “diagnostic overshadowing”: people labelled as challenging when the real problem was that they could not see.
When an adopted pathway was piloted in three London boroughs, over half of those tested had an eye problem that could lead to sight loss, and nearly two-thirds ended up in glasses. Amendment 60 would change Regulation 3 of the Primary Ophthalmic Services Regulations 2008, which lists who gets free NHS sight tests: children, people over 60—probably including many noble Lords—people with diabetes or glaucoma, and people over 40 with a family history of glaucoma. The logic is clinical risk. By that logic, people with a learning disability should be on the list. Today, an adult with a learning disability, however profound, gets a free eye test only by qualifying some other way, often through a means-tested benefit.
So my first question to the Minister is: what is the clinical justification for giving a free eye test to somebody over 40 with a family history of glaucoma but not an adult with a learning disability, who is 10 times more likely to go blind or be partially sighted? The amendment deliberately covers people eligible for the GP learning disability register, not those already on it. The registers undercount, and no one should be denied a test because a practice has not updated its list. It also links to the annual health check, where GPs can prompt for that eye test.
There is also a data problem. NHS sight test claim forms have not recorded disability, so we cannot know how many people with a learning disability get a test. Can the Minister confirm whether that data is now recorded and, if not, how the department can say it is reducing an inequality when it does not measure it? Will it add this field to the data collection?
Amendment 62 deals with assessing need and commissioning services, because a free test is necessary but not enough. The NHS sight test fee is £24.13, and the Association of Optometrists estimates that it covers only about half the cost of a standard test. It pays nothing towards the longer appointments or Easy Read results that many people with a learning disability need. Many are sent to overstretched eye hospital services that are not appropriate to their presenting need. The Easy Eye care pathway, with longer appointments from specially trained optometrists, works, but it is commissioned only in south-east London, parts of the north-west and Durham. Everywhere else, the system is literally blind to the need. Can the Minister say what the plans are to try to ensure that every integrated care board now commissions this type of test? What will the Government do to ensure that it becomes standard across England?
This Bill moves NHS functions, including primary ophthalmic services, to the Secretary of State. This amendment would require the Secretary of State to assess the need and to direct ICBs—I know what I have said previously, but it is still in the Bill—to improve and measure the eye health of people with a learning disability through targeted action. As I said, I am wary of open-ended powers of direction, but I have argued that the Secretary of State should set clear outcomes and hold the system to them. This is exactly the kind of outcome that I would like.
I give the Government credit: the Special Schools Eye Care Service has £12.7 million of recurrent funding to reach up to 165,000 children. However, schools must opt in, rollout is uneven and, at 19, these young people fall off the cliff edge into an adult system not built for them. Will the Minister confirm by what date the service will be available to every ICB in England and what will happen to those young people’s eyecare when they leave school?
The NHS rightly recognises that people with diabetes need regular eye checks because they are at higher risk. People with a learning disability are at much higher risk and far less able to tell us when something is wrong. These amendments would bring them into line with the clinical risk profile that they face with their eyes. No one should lose their eyesight because the system was not designed with them in mind. I hope the Minister will look favourably at these amendments and I look forward to her response.