Contribution
My Lords, I will speak to my Amendment 61A before speaking to support Amendment 43. My amendment aims to increase transparency in ICB commissioning of community-based services that assess and manage urgent and minor eye conditions. At present, there is a significant and unwanted variation in access to these services: around one in four people cannot access them locally. The postcode lottery can persist even between neighbouring communities, where patients with the same condition may find that services are available on one side of an integrated care board boundary but not on the other. In some cases, these services are being decommissioned altogether.
Eye-related conditions account for 780,000 A&E attendances each year, yet analysis by the Association of Optometrists suggests that up to 400,000 of these can be managed in community optometry services. Importantly, the capacity already exists. Around 8,000 optometrists provide NHS care on high streets and in communities across the country, and are well-placed to assess and manage many eye conditions closer to home. This amendment does not seek to mandate commissioning decisions or require integrated boards to adopt a particular model of care. Rather, it seeks greater transparency on which services are available and whether commissioning decisions align to population need.
I am delighted to support Amendment 43, and I pay tribute to the convincing speech made by the noble Baroness, Lady Neville-Rolfe. I wholeheartedly endorse her point that continuity is one of the most researched interventions that we can implement to reduce premature mortality and improve health outcomes at a far lower cost to the NHS. As we have heard, this amendment would ensure that continuity is not merely an aspiration but a principle to consider whenever decisions are made about delivering NHS services. The NHS Act already places duties on the Secretary of State in relation to quality and reducing health inequalities. Continuity underpins both and deserves the same statutory recognition.
As a GP, continuity of care was the tool of my trade. It allowed me to remain close to my patients and to observe the onset and progression of illness within particular life contexts and stories. I came to understand that no two individuals ever experience illness or disease in the same way. Continuity allowed me to develop a rich understanding of the inconsistent relationship between suffering and pathology.
As I have just remarked, continuity was the tool of my trade. For patients, it is sadly now becoming the exception rather than the rule. In general practice, the end of personal lists marked a long drift towards anonymity, as described by the phrase “martini medicine”: any time, any place, anywhere, with on-demand access, transactional care, and plurality of providers. For too many patients, contacting their surgery has now become a call centre experience. They speak to whoever is free and tell their story again and again to people who do not know them. Even in hospitals, continuity is lacking. Patients are moved from wards, teams and shifts, often without anyone taking responsibility for their whole care.
I am also concerned that the development of neighbourhood health services and hubs risks creating a new form of fragmentation. We are increasingly organising services around particular conditions, age groups and needs. There are women’s health hubs, mental health hubs, children’s hubs, urgent care hubs and one I heard of today: genomic hubs. Each may have a good rationale, but consider a family with a woman attending a women’s hub for her menopause and a mental health hub for her depression, while her son attends a children’s hub for his asthma and her elderly father attends the urgent care hub—four front doors, four sets of clinicians and potentially nobody who sees the family as a whole. That is exactly what the family doctor used to do, and we must not confuse the integration of services with continuity of relationships. Joining up buildings, budgets and IT systems is not the same as ensuring that the patient has the same clinician each time.