Contribution
My Lords, Amendment 43 proposes a duty to promote continuity of care for patients by health professionals, including by GPs and in hospitals. I am particularly grateful to the noble Baroness, Lady Gerada, and the noble Lord, Lord Patel, for supporting the amendment. They know much more than I do about the potential value of continuity of care and the costs and complexities involved.
There is much academic and anecdotal evidence that continuity of care improves health outcomes. My own medical experience supports that, although I acknowledge the problem posed by the tension between seeing patients quickly and seeing the same doctor—I will come back to this later. The noble Baroness, Lady Gerada, will address the issue from a more expert perspective, but I very much enjoyed her speech at Second Reading and her comment that
“Continuity of care is the golden thread of healthcare”.—[Official Report, 13/10/26; col. 186.]
and that evidence shows that a patient’s ongoing relationship with a clinician who knows them makes the “biggest difference” to success. We need to make that golden thread more of a reality. I believe that the best way to improve healthcare would be to restore the effectiveness of the GP service, which is now less well-resourced than hospital care, and that greater continuity of care would make a substantial contribution. It would also help in hospital care, especially for complex conditions, and indeed in maternity care and with health visitors.
The truth is we need an across-the-board effort. Once I have set out the case for change, I will come on to how best to achieve this. I have had the benefit of advice from the Library on academic research going back 15 years. According to Denis Pereira Gray and colleagues, numerous studies have found that higher continuity is associated with fewer hospital admissions. Some studies have shown lower mortality with higher levels of continuity. Others have shown continuity associated with patient satisfaction and better outcomes for patients with diabetes, better care for those with dementia and greater adherence to medical advice more generally. Patients reported greater involvement in decisions about their care and a greater readiness to manage their health in partnership with their GP. This all echoes my own family’s experience. Continuity improves patient confidence, less time is wasted as multiple professionals get themselves up to speed, and it mostly delivers better outcomes.
There are, however, exceptions; for example, analysis of the GP database found a seven-day delay in diagnosis for some cancers. The academics concerned thought this might be the result of GPs focusing on known diagnoses, but we rightly have new systems for cancer care and have made good progress as a result with lots of common cancers.
Against this academic background, continuity of care in the UK has unfortunately been falling to very low levels. This reflects the shortage of GPs, more part-time working and working from home, more mobile populations and more delegation to nurses. Mergers of GP practices leads to bigger practices, making it less likely for an individual to see the same GP. Yet with more patients living for longer and with multiple conditions, it is even more important.
Above all, I understand from a doctor friend that today’s problems with GP continuity reflect a highly bureaucratic system of targets. He believes that the single most effective healthcare intervention, without exception, is continuity of care. However, continuity of care has become extremely difficult largely because of the existence of other targets and the detail of funding arrangements. Slots are set aside for urgent cases and to reflect the need for a clinician to respond to all emails received each working day. Added to this, there are elaborate reporting requirements which act as a diversion. As a result, even the most devoted advocate of continuity of care, as he was, finds it difficult to achieve.
My research suggests that many other countries manage continuity better, including Canada, Belgium and Norway. With the resources of the NHS, we should be able to do so too, even if it means changing the targets and the GP contract.
As to hospitals, thanks to my employer, I have had access to private care for many years. This is based around continuity with your consultant. There is also more focus on efficiency and timeliness, and the results are better. Private consultants also have excellent records which they copy to the patient. I remember saving my husband from an emergency procedure at A&E at St Thomas’ by producing some coronary charts from his consultant. I have also had four lots of excellent NHS maternity care, but I know it is less well-resourced today.
I am personally familiar with cases where outcomes would probably have been better if it had proved possible to provide greater continuity of care in the NHS. I have also been influenced by doctor friends, such as the noble Lord, Lord Patel, as to the value of continuity in hospital care and by my own experience in a tricky maternity situation. Health visitors are often dealing with new mothers or vulnerable people, and the constant rotation of professionals is a highly negative factor.
I believe that we have a problem. It has three aspects, as a paper by Jeannie L Haggerty and others has argued in a multidisciplinary review. The first aspect is informational continuity: the use of information on past events and personal circumstances to make current care appropriate for each individual. We are making progress here with better NHS systems, the single patient record and the NHS app. The second aspect is management continuity: a consistent and coherent approach to the management of a health condition that is responsive to a patient’s changing needs. There is more to do here as the Government’s reforms bed in. The third is relational continuity: an ongoing therapeutic relationship between a patient and one or more providers. This has been eroded in the British system. That is why I have proposed a new duty which I hope would improve care over time.
I suggest the evidence is sufficiently robust for us to seek to encourage continuity of care throughout the NHS system. But there are many bureaucratic details of that system which put obstacles in the way. I recognise that all these details were put there for a purpose, even if some of them have been found to be unnecessary over time. Certainly, it would be folly to advocate simply sweeping them away.
My conclusion is that the best course would be to require all within the NHS to have regard to the desirability of continuity of care and to use their best endeavours to achieve it. Amendment 43 has this intention, though I am sure the drafting could be improved. I would welcome help from all in improving it, including help from the Government, if they agree that a provision strengthening the role of continuity of care within the NHS is a desirable aim. This would lead to a change in culture and allow those concerned in any particular case to do their best to achieve continuity within the constraints that they face. In her recent letter to me, the Minister said that continuity of care was an important priority for the Government, but she recognised there was more to do. Therefore, I hope this will be the start of a productive conversation. I beg to move.