B

Baroness Pidgeon (LD)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 11 November 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, this has been a really interesting and important debate, trying to tease out many of the issues and concerns with specialist commissioning in the new structures set out in the Bill, and the worries about ICBs—their capability and capacity—and the access to services across the country. I have two amendments in this group, which I will try to talk to briefly. Amendment 59, to which the noble Baroness, Lady Cass, and the noble Lord, Lord Hunt of Kings Heath, have added their names, seeks to require the Secretary of State to have regard to the specific needs of children and young people when considering devolving responsibility for specialist commissioning services. This has wide support across the sector. Children and young people make up around 20% of the overall population. Therefore, commissioning arrangements designed at a scale for adults just do not work for the small scale required to be effective for children. Many children are dependent on specialist commissioning, and it is essential for the provision of care for rare diseases and complex conditions, such as childhood cancers. Children are disproportionately affected by rare diseases: 75% manifest in children. The benefits of specialist commissioning being centralised and co-ordinated at a national level are clear, given the small number of patients. The Health Bill’s direction to split commissioning is of huge concern. There is huge uncertainty out there. We have been in this position before because specialist commissioning, as was mentioned earlier, had been devolved to primary care trusts. They experienced many of the concerns that have been raised today. The previous report by the noble Lord, Lord Carter, recommended that specialist commissioning should be overseen at a national level. We need to learn the lessons from this and not repeat the same mistakes. I hope that before any delegated arrangements are made for children and young people’s specialised services, full consideration is given to the impact on those services. The other amendment I have in this group is Amendment 279N. I still cannot believe that access to IVF treatment is not equal across the country. Your chance of being able to have a baby is decided by NHS bureaucracy and where you live, rather than clinical guidance and your health. You can have people living in roads next to each other and they can have one round of IVF or three rounds of IVF, despite NICE having recommended three rounds of IVF. We have seen the provision continuing to be reduced. Kent and Medway cut its services earlier this year from two to one and also lowered the age when someone can have treatment from under 40 to under 38. Sussex slashed its services last year from three cycles to one, and now all 10 boroughs in Greater Manchester are reduced to one. Only two of the 38 ICBs offer the NICE-recommended number of three cycles of IVF. Fertility challenges affect one in six people. The physical and psychological impact is huge. I know the Minister is hearing all our concerns that we keep raising throughout the Bill. I do not feel we are getting much back from the Minister. But surely this is one area where there might be some movement. I urge the Government to look carefully at this and the other amendments in this group. I look forward to the Minister’s response.

More from Baroness Pidgeon (LD)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.