Contribution
My Lords, it was very good to hear the noble Baroness, Lady Campbell, in her own voice, and a real privilege to hear five excellent maiden speeches.
I welcome this Bill, which I believe will protect and strengthen our NHS as it is modernised and made more accountable with more innovation. I fully support the abolition of the NHSE, which should never have been there in the first place. It is ludicrous that one arm’s-length body should be responsible for nearly one-tenth of the economy. That cannot be right.
I am concerned, however, about the disruption of more reorganisation and job cuts for an overstretched workforce, while understanding the need for ICBs to take on many more responsibilities. There appears to be a misalignment with the recent cost reduction requirement to reduce the ICB headcount by 50%. More skills, not fewer, are necessary, including in driving innovation. The close link between the NHS and mayoral strategic authorities is welcome, but one representative on each ICB is not enough.
I would be grateful for an assurance from my noble friend the Minister that ICBs will have the necessary capacity to deliver at local level and that implementation of the Bill will not delay the development and delivery of health priorities. The proposed reforms to NHS structures and employment arrangements could leave some healthcare professionals without consistent statutory employment protections when services are reorganised. Successful reform depends on retaining the specialist expertise, experience and commitment of the workforce. This is particularly concerning to smaller specialist professions, where workforce stability is particularly important. Restructuring must support staff and not hinder their ability to care.
One health priority is the implementation of the Government’s very welcome commitment to universal access to fracture liaison services, which will reduce unnecessary hospital admissions. I support the noble Lord, Lord Black, and everything he said. As is so often the case, it is those already facing disadvantage who suffer most. The UK’s health inequalities are wider than ever. The gulf in life expectancy between the most and least deprived parts of England is now 19.4 years for men and 20.3 years for females. As the Health and Social Care Committee in the Commons recommended, the Bill presents an opportunity to strengthen the duties on the Secretary of State and other Ministers to reduce inequalities through cross-government action.
Silo working does not deliver equality. Such changes should ensure consistent duties across central and local government, ensuring the necessary balance between prevention and healthcare, supporting the strategic shift which is central to the 10-year health plan and devolution agenda. Many noble friends have spoken of inequalities, so I hope that we will be able to make progress in the House on this, remembering that prevention and inequality are inextricably linked.
Men face huge inequalities when it comes to the diagnosis and treatment of prostate cancer, the most common cancer in the UK. There is a stark north-south divide in PSA blood tests to check for early warning signs, and there is a postcode lottery on early diagnosis. Those living in areas of high deprivation are 29% more likely to find out that they have prostate cancer when it has already spread. The disease kills one man every 45 minutes in the UK. But many of these deaths are preventable, so I will be tabling an amendment requiring the Secretary of State to lay before Parliament a prostate cancer early detection implementation plan, including a funding assessment, a service specification, workforce implications and an equality impact assessment.
Much has been said about the single patient record—long in gestation—which is much needed. I will get to that in Committee, but I believe that the independence of a strong patient voice is vital. The link between citizens and their local Healthwatch organisations is invaluable. It is a bridge between people and what can feel like an alien system. I acknowledge that the current system is wanting, but reform, not abolition, is the answer. We should build on the excellent example of Healthwatch Leeds, which demonstrates the power of the local voice. I ask the Government to work with local councils to develop an improved model.
I end by agreeing with all noble Lords who have said that the test of this Bill will be whether it can be trusted to deliver for the patients in this country, in the future, whoever may be in power.