Contribution
My Lords, I declare my interest as a patron of the Wheelchair Alliance. I support the Hugh’s Law campaign and I am a member of the APPG on Spinal Cord Injury. I thank the Spinal Injuries Association for its work. My husband had a spinal cord injury 40 years ago, and I have made many friends once they have had an injury, but a few years ago a non-disabled friend had a traumatic injury, and it was stark to see how some services had changed—and not for the better.
My experience of the NHS as a patient has generally been excellent, but over the summer I was quite unwell and had two stays in hospital. There is currently an ongoing discussion about the treatment I did and, possibly more importantly, did not receive. Let me give a top-line summary. I was asked three times why I had a wheelchair beside my bed. My notes are quite clear: I am paralysed. Specialist dressings had to be brought in from home. The district nurse was able to order them—I could even get them with next-day delivery—but they were not available on the ward. Earlier, the noble Lord, Lord Winston, explained how he was able to intervene to help somebody; that is not the norm. Worryingly, I was also asked why I did not tell anyone that I sit in your Lordships’ Chamber. That should not impact my care, and it is not okay.
This Bill should improve integration, reduce bureaucracy and strengthen patient care, with patient safety being not just simplified, as the impact assessment states, but improved. We cannot lose national expertise, clinical standards and accountability, upon which patients with rare and complex conditions depend. Spinal cord injury services require highly trained multidisciplinary teams, specialist rehab facilities and co-ordinated care pathways extending well beyond individual integrated care boundaries. I am concerned that we could be preparing individuals to be looked after by the care industry rather than developing independence.
The Bill envisages transferring further specialised commissioning responsibilities to integrated care boards and retaining national service specifications and clinical policies, supported by seven offices for pan-ICB commissioning. The question that we must answer is how consistently the national service specification which currently exists and covers children and adults will be maintained and enforced under the proposed arrangements. National standards are effective only if there are clear mechanisms for monitoring compliance and addressing failures.
The Spinal Injuries Association, working with the APPG on Spinal Cord Injury, clinicians and patients, has raised concerns about the potential fragmentation of services, geographical inequalities and the sustainability of specialist centres. These concerns require careful examination before further commissioning responsibilities are transferred. Will His Majesty’s Government publish a service-specific impact assessment before transferring responsibility for spinal cord injury services, including on the implications for patient outcomes, workforce capacity, specialist centres and geographical access? How will the offices for pan-ICB commissioning be held accountable for maintaining national standards? Who will intervene where commissioning decisions result in unacceptable regional variation? Will the Government commit to publishing comparable national data on access to specialist rehabilitation, waiting times, capacity and patient outcomes so that it is possible to assess whether these reforms are delivering equitable care?
Specialist charities and voluntary organisations provide essential peer support, advocacy and practical assistance with rehabilitation, housing, employment and independent living. The single patient record has been raised many times. The benefits and projections have been outlined, but will it include mechanisms, subject to explicit patient consent and appropriate data protection safeguards, specifically to improve referrals and connections to these specialist organisations? Who owns the data and how it will be used needs to be transparent so that it cannot be used against patients in any future insurance schemes.
The central issue is not simply where commissioning responsibilities sit but whether the new arrangements can demonstrate that national standards are maintained, specialist expertise is protected and patients receive equitable access to care. I look forward to examining this further in Committee.