Contribution
My Lords, we have before us an enormous Bill that upends the functioning of the NHS. We are less than six months away from the abolition of NHS England and we do not yet have clarity on the future operating arrangements. On 8 September, the Secretary of State promised to update Parliament shortly on next steps, but this has not yet happened. Parliament, and much more importantly NHS staff, are still in the dark. In the words of the NHS Alliance:
“There is an urgent need to resolve the division of responsibilities … and to clarify the future role of the national centre, NHS regions and ICBs”.
I would be grateful if the Minister could tell us when this update will come.
I raise my concerns from the moral low ground. In government, I saw the reorganisations brought about by the Health and Social Care Act 2012 and the Health and Care Act 2022. On both occasions, I believe we underestimated the wider cost of reform, and I fear that this Government are falling into the same trap. Of course, there is the financial cost: NHS England’s accounts show more than £530 million on exit packages in 2025-26 alone. However, even more difficult to manage, as the noble Lord, Lord Scriven, reminded us, is the frictional cost of change. Uncertainty means talented people leave, decisions are paused and capacity is lost. Finally, there is the opportunity cost—the “dilution of leadership bandwidth”, to borrow a phrase from my noble friend Lord Howe. What else could this ministerial time and official energy have delivered?
Take the NHS workforce plan, which was originally promised for 2025 and then spring 2026. In June, Ministers promised publication imminently. Now we are told that we will be updated on the publication timetable in the usual way, in due course. We have gone from imminent publication to no date for even announcing a publication date, but Clause 7 makes the Secretary of State entirely responsible for workforce planning and training. The workforce should be at the heart of any reorganisation, so, again, I would be grateful if the Minister could tell us when the workforce plan will be published.
Although the Bill promises local responsibility, it significantly expands ministerial powers, as other noble Lords have pointed out; indeed, the noble Lord, Lord Hunt of Kings Heath, and my noble friend Lady Coffey welcomed more direct ministerial control. I have great regard for the current Secretary of State. I also have great regard for the Secretary of State who introduced the Bill and for the Secretary of State who took it through Second Reading in the other place. The Minister would, I am sure, profess confidence in every future Secretary of State appointed by her Government. However, as the noble Lord, Lord Stevens, reminded us, no one in your Lordships’ House could honestly say that they would trust the judgment of any and every Secretary of State appointed by any and every future Administration. So we must debate whether checks and balances are needed to temper these new powers.
Let me give three examples. First, Clause 10 allows the Secretary of State to pursue changes in the public/private provider balance if they consider that to be in the interests of the health service—not in the interests of patients but of the health service. This could potentially be used to significantly increase private provision, as the noble Lord, Lord Sikka, pointed out, or to significantly reduce it. The clause requires no consultation, no published explanation and no parliamentary approval. Are we really comfortable giving any and every future Secretary of State that power?
Secondly, Clause 11 allows the Secretary of State to direct integrated care boards even when they are performing well. No failure needs to be established and no appeals process is being created. If the Government wanted a top-down NHS, I could understand this approach, but the Minister told us that the Government’s aim is to ensure that decisions are made as close to the community as possible. Why create this power without safeguards to prevent its misuse in future?
Finally, Clause 52 establishes the framework for a single patient record. I am a passionate supporter of this proposal, but supporting the SPR cannot mean leaving its crucial design choices to this, or a future, Secretary of State. I echo other noble Lords in asking how sensitive mental or sexual health information will be recorded. Who will be liable if errors occur? What security protections are necessary? These questions, and many more, remain unanswered in the Bill. Future regulations may require our approval, but they cannot be amended, and arrangements set out in guidance will receive even less parliamentary scrutiny. Given the enormous risks of bringing together such sensitive information, Parliament should settle the basic protections now.
It is in all our interests for this reorganisation to deliver for patients, and I know that the Minister will work constructively with this House to improve the Bill. I very much hope that we will be able to agree that the test for any new ministerial power is not whether we trust those who would hold it today but whether we would entrust it to those we would oppose tomorrow.