Contribution
My Lords, I am grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Patel, and the noble Baronesses, Lady Harding of Winscombe and Lady Cass, for their support for this amendment. In moving Amendment 28, I want to make a very simple argument. The Bill gives Ministers direct responsibility for training and educating the NHS workforce. I believe that it should also make Ministers responsible for setting out what workforce they believe the NHS requires and for developing a training and education plan to deliver that workforce.
This is not a controversial proposal—Amendments 92, 252 and 253 in this group make a very similar case—nor is it a new proposal. In 2022, your Lordships’ House passed a very similar amendment to the Health and Care Bill, not once but twice, with support from the Labour Benches, the Liberal Democrat Benches and the Cross Benches. In 2023, the Conservative Government published a long-term workforce plan and asked the National Audit Office to scrutinise the modelling behind it. In 2024, the Labour Party manifesto promised “regular, independent workforce planning”, and Ministers subsequently committed to producing a new workforce plan with independent scrutiny.
Therefore, in theory, we all agree. But in practice, we are now more than two years after the election and Ministers have set aside the Conservative Government’s 2023 plan, understandably, but have still not published their own. In June, Ministers said it was coming imminently. We are now told that it will arrive in due course.
An insufficient NHS workforce is a problem that has been many years in the making. At the end of June, the NHS in England had more than 100,000 vacancies. But vacancies are not the whole story. Since 2015, the number of patients registered with GP practices has risen by more than 10%, but the number of fully qualified full-time GPs has gone down. Others in this House can describe far better than I can what workforce shortages mean on the front line, so I will not talk about how hard it is to plan services when you have insufficient staff to deliver them or the toll on healthcare professionals when we constantly ask them to cover gaps or the impact on patient care. But I hope that others in this debate will do.
Instead, I want to talk about how we ended up here. I believe that all Governments understand the importance of NHS workforce planning. But experience shows that very few are able to develop and deliver a comprehensive plan. That comes down to the very simple fact that training must be paid for today and the benefits of training are realised only in the future. It takes three years to train a nurse, around 10 years to train a GP and up to 15 years to train a consultant. So Ministers constantly face a choice between the pressures of today and the prospect of a better NHS in three, 10 or 15 years’ time. Every £1 spent on a GP for 2035 is £1 not spent this winter or on this year’s political priorities. At any one moment, choosing to prioritise today makes sense. But, repeated year after year, that choice leaves us with a workforce that cannot possibly meet the demands it faces.
Of course, politicians can and sometimes do take long-term decisions. As chair of the Health and Social Care Committee, Sir Jeremy Hunt championed independent workforce forecasts. As Chancellor, he was in a position to fund an NHS workforce plan and did so. That 2023 plan was backed by over £2.4 billion. It set out ambitions to double medical school places, increase GP training places by half and almost double adult nursing training places. It was not a perfect forecast, and the NAO kindly pointed that out when it was asked to scrutinise it, but it was a baseline and it showed that, when the political will exists, it is possible to plan for and invest in the future. However, hoping for sufficient political will is not a strategy. We will not often have a Chancellor who was previously Health Secretary.
This amendment would make long-term workforce planning a duty and not a matter of personal commitment. It would require independently verified assessments of what staff the NHS needs and a 10-year plan to train and educate the staff needed. The first assessment and plan would have to be published within one month of Royal Assent to the Bill. Both the plan and assessment would be kept under review and would have to be revised at least every five years.
In 2022, the noble Baroness, Lady Merron, told the House that
“without mandated forecasts of staff numbers, meaningful workforce planning—something that every other efficient organisation undertakes—cannot take place”.—[Official Report, 26/4/22; col. 223.]
I really agree with her and hope that she will support this principle from the Government Benches as she did from the Opposition Benches, and back this amendment or one along similar lines.
I would be grateful if the Minister could also answer two questions. First, when will the Government publish their own workforce plan? Secondly, who will undertake the independent scrutiny of that plan?
Every Government must have the right to set their own spending priorities. But every Government should be transparent about the workforce they believe the NHS needs and what the decisions they are making today about education and training will mean for tomorrow’s workforce. I hope the Committee will agree. I beg to move.