Contribution
My Lords, the Government made clear in their child poverty strategy that:
“Tackling child poverty is at the heart of the government’s Health Mission and its ambition to raise the healthiest generation of children ever”.
The size of the challenge is underlined by the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health. Most indicators of children’s health and well-being show a worsening situation or stalled progress, with children in deprived areas experiencing the poorest outcomes.
It is therefore welcome that the child poverty strategy states that
“Addressing healthcare inequity is at the heart of the 10 Year Health Plan”,
and refers to a
“new statutory duty to improve health and reduce health inequalities”.
Yet despite the Government’s laudable commitment to tackling health inequalities and their understanding of the importance of this to their child poverty strategy, as we have heard, such a statutory duty to take action is conspicuous by its absence in this key piece of health legislation.
In the Commons, Minister Smyth reiterated that
“reducing health inequalities remains a priority for this Government”. —[Official Report, Commons, 7/9/26; col. 820.]
However, she did not give a very convincing explanation as to why simple empowerment to treat this as a priority is sufficient. In contrast, the Health Equals coalition, supported by a wide range of organisations, including a number of the royal colleges, argues that a statutory duty is essential if the Bill is to provide the legislative framework to enact the 10-year health plan, and that it is key to the preventive approach, emphasised by my noble friend Lord Babudu, which Minister Smyth herself prayed in aid when opposing an amendment that would have required a cross-government health inequalities strategy.
An important dimension of health and other inequalities are the difficulties faced by marginalised groups, such as homeless people, in making their voices heard. The Government have taken important steps to address this—for instance, through the co-production of the Timms PIP review and the ongoing engagement with parents and children in poverty in the development and implementation of the child poverty strategy. In a foreword to the strategy, some of the parents involved in Changing Realities wrote:
“Our involvement in this strategy has strengthened our belief that lasting solutions come when policies are shaped with people, not just for them”.
It is thus disappointing that the homeless and inclusion health charity Pathway warns that the Bill goes in the opposite direction in removing independent oversight of the NHS and failing to ensure that ICBs seek the views of inclusion health groups.
The Government have given an assurance that the new arrangements will ensure that the experience of “seldom heard” groups and diverse communities inform service design and delivery, thereby contributing to a reduction in inequalities, but once again there are no statutory provisions in the Bill. Can my noble friend the Minister therefore explain what mechanisms are proposed to ensure that the views of “seldom heard” groups are able to inform service design and delivery? It was encouraging that on Report in the Commons there was a commitment to look at this issue again with Members in both Houses. Can my noble friend tell us what is now being proposed on this?
One group vulnerable to poverty and ill health are carers, who we have heard about, yet there is no statutory duty for ICBs to identify carers and there is no co-ordinated approach to carers’ support across the NHS. I therefore support Carers UK’s call for a clear duty to be placed on ICBs to identify unpaid carers and ensure that records of them are kept.
In conclusion, given the Government’s clear commitment to reducing health inequalities and to raising the healthiest generation of children ever, not least as an important element in their child poverty strategy, I hope they will be open to strengthening the Bill to make a reality of these commitments, as called for in many of the helpful briefings we have received.