L

Lord Hunt of Wirral (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 13 October 2026

Debate

Code of Practice on Access and Unfair Practices During the Recognition and Derecognition Process

Contribution

My Lords, I am grateful to the Minister for opening this important debate on the draft Code of Practice: Access and Unfair Practices During the Recognition and Derecognition Process. By way of background, as the Minister knows, the Government have committed to cutting the administrative burden on businesses by 25% by the end of this Parliament. It is right, therefore, that this Grand Committee should consider what the draft code means for the businesses expected to implement it. Employers will be required to navigate earlier union access, negotiate access arrangements within prescribed timescales, organise more frequent meetings and manage digital communications. How does adding these responsibilities help to deliver that important government ambition to reduce the amount of bureaucracy? Under the revised framework, a union normally has five working days after notification of the Central Arbitration Committee’s acceptance of an application to request access, as the Minister just explained. There then follows approximately 15 working days to negotiate an agreement. If the agreement cannot be reached, the CAC will determine the arrangements. For a large employer with an established industrial relations team, that may be manageable, but for a smaller business encountering the statutory recognition process for the first time it means that it will have to find advice, understand unfamiliar obligations and negotiate arrangements while continuing to serve customers and pay its staff. The code also increases the suggested frequency of access meetings from once every 10 working days to once every five, and their suggested minimum duration from 30 to 45 minutes. More meetings means more scheduling, more arrangements for staff cover and more time away from ordinary business activity. Employers made their concerns abundantly clear. In the consultation, 98% opposed the proposed meeting frequency and 97% opposed increasing the minimum duration to 45 minutes. Yet the Minister has not sought to justify why the Government have retained both these proposals in the face of such outright opposition. The concerns extend beyond meeting arrangements. Employers feared that ordinary performance management, quarterly reviews and shift changes could become entangled in allegations of unfair practice. Some 96% of substantive respondents said that the draft provided insufficient guidance on unfair practices. Even ACAS issued the following warning: “We are particularly concerned about recognition requests and decisions being legally challenged because of unclear language and guidance in the Code”. ACAS also identified risks of accidental non-compliance, inadequate practical guidance and disproportionate difficulties for employers unfamiliar with trade unions. Its consultation response called for much more detailed guidance on digital access, including privacy, cyber security and online intimidation. The Minister will realise that digital access adds another layer of administration. The code envisages online meetings and union material being circulated through email or the employer’s intranet, normally within two working days of a request. On Report on the Employment Rights Bill, the Government expanded the Bill’s general access provisions to include digital communication. That was only on Report in the other place. Employers examining the Bill as originally introduced could not have assessed obligations that were subsequently added. Whether Ministers discussed those proposals with trade unions beforehand is something that only the Minister will be able to clarify. I invite him to do so. Businesses deserved a clear explanation of what the implications for them were. It seems once again that this Government regard employers’ concerns as something to acknowledge and then disregard. Businesses need clear, workable rules, particularly when they are being asked to assume unfamiliar responsibilities. I ask the Minister not only to answer the questions which I have already posed but to deal with the very serious concerns that I outlined. Additionally, will he commit at the very least to publishing better practical guidance for employers, with clear examples distinguishing legitimate day-to-day management from unfair practices and explaining how digital access can be provided securely? I invite the Minister to respond to that point in particular, as well as the other questions I have raised.

More from Lord Hunt of Wirral (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.