Hansard·Grand Committee·Vol. 860

Code of Practice on Access and Unfair Practices During the Recognition and Derecognition Process

Tuesday, 13 October 2026

20 contributions3 members

Contributions

  1. Considered in Grand Committee

    View contribution permalink →

  2. Moved by

    View contribution permalink →

  3. Lord Leong

    That the Grand Committee do consider the Code of Practice on Access and Unfair Practices During the Recognition and Derecognition Process.

    View contribution permalink →

  4. The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department for Business and Trade (Lord Leong) (Lab)

    My Lords, I start by sharing with the Committee why we are introducing the code for noble Lords’ consideration today. The plan to make work pay included a commitment to simplify the process for trade union recognition. The Employment Rights Act 2025 updated the legal framework for statutory trade union recognition, ensuring that workers have a meaningful right to organise through trade unions. Last April, the requirements for unions to demonstrate likely majority support at the application stage and to have at least 40% of the workforce supporting union recognition were removed. The 2025 Act also makes changes to improve access arrangements for unions and aims to deal more effectively with unfair practices during the recognition and derecognition processes. The Government are therefore updating the 2005 version of the code to ensure that all parties, including employers, workers and unions, understand how the legislative change on access and unfair practices affect them. We consulted on the revised code from 4 February to 1 April 2026. The consultation asked for feedback on the clarity of updates to the legal framework, structural amendments from the Employment Rights Act and other changes to the code, including updated guidance to reflect modern work practices. A number of revisions to the existing 2005 code have been made following consultation. Previously, the 2005 applied only to the recognition or derecognition ballot phase. Now, the code reflects the changes made by the 2025 Act to access and unfair practices, and applies from the point at which the Central Arbitration Committee—the CAC—accepts an application for recognition or derecognition. The code sets out a clear timetable for negotiations on access—20 working days from the date the CAC accepts a trade union recognition application. If no agreement is reached, the CAC will have 10 working days to determine a reasonable access agreement. Further, the code has been revised to reflect that the 2025 Act allows five working days after the closure of the recognition ballot for companies alleging unfair practice to submit to the CAC. Where such a practice is alleged, the Act makes it easier to determine such complaints by requiring the CAC to consider only whether an unfair practice has occurred without considering the effect it may have had. The updated code increases the suggested frequency of access meetings and minimum length of meeting to once every five working days and 45 minutes respectively during the access period. During the consultation, employers expressed reservations about the proposed increases in the frequency and duration of access meetings. However, these changes will create more opportunities for meaningful engagement between the union seeking recognition and workers in the bargaining unit. This will allow union representatives to answer any questions the workers may have before the balloted workforce decides whether to agree to statutory union recognition. Of course, employers will have similar opportunities to engage with their workers. Additionally, we want to reassure employers, especially small businesses. For instance, we have clarified that the statutory recognition process does not apply to employers with fewer than 25 workers. We have also ensured that the revised code will not require employers to breach general data protection requirements, giving them peace of mind. The updated code provides guidance on good access agreements, detailing key areas such as eligibility, access methods—including digital—timing, privacy and communication. Finally, the Government have taken the opportunity to bring the code up to date with changes in digital communications. The code now provides significantly more detailed guidance in this area, including guidance on digital access. The revised code before the Committee reflects the updated legal framework for statutory trade union recognition. Together with the 2025 Act, these changes strengthen the collective voice in the workplace, enhance workers’ representation, and help to foster a new partnership of co-operation between trade unions and employers. I beg to move.

    View contribution permalink →

  5. Lord Hunt of Wirral (Con)

    My Lords, I am grateful to the Minister for opening this important debate on the draft Code of Practice: Access and Unfair Practices During the Recognition and Derecognition Process. By way of background, as the Minister knows, the Government have committed to cutting the administrative burden on businesses by 25% by the end of this Parliament. It is right, therefore, that this Grand Committee should consider what the draft code means for the businesses expected to implement it. Employers will be required to navigate earlier union access, negotiate access arrangements within prescribed timescales, organise more frequent meetings and manage digital communications. How does adding these responsibilities help to deliver that important government ambition to reduce the amount of bureaucracy? Under the revised framework, a union normally has five working days after notification of the Central Arbitration Committee’s acceptance of an application to request access, as the Minister just explained. There then follows approximately 15 working days to negotiate an agreement. If the agreement cannot be reached, the CAC will determine the arrangements. For a large employer with an established industrial relations team, that may be manageable, but for a smaller business encountering the statutory recognition process for the first time it means that it will have to find advice, understand unfamiliar obligations and negotiate arrangements while continuing to serve customers and pay its staff. The code also increases the suggested frequency of access meetings from once every 10 working days to once every five, and their suggested minimum duration from 30 to 45 minutes. More meetings means more scheduling, more arrangements for staff cover and more time away from ordinary business activity. Employers made their concerns abundantly clear. In the consultation, 98% opposed the proposed meeting frequency and 97% opposed increasing the minimum duration to 45 minutes. Yet the Minister has not sought to justify why the Government have retained both these proposals in the face of such outright opposition. The concerns extend beyond meeting arrangements. Employers feared that ordinary performance management, quarterly reviews and shift changes could become entangled in allegations of unfair practice. Some 96% of substantive respondents said that the draft provided insufficient guidance on unfair practices. Even ACAS issued the following warning: “We are particularly concerned about recognition requests and decisions being legally challenged because of unclear language and guidance in the Code”. ACAS also identified risks of accidental non-compliance, inadequate practical guidance and disproportionate difficulties for employers unfamiliar with trade unions. Its consultation response called for much more detailed guidance on digital access, including privacy, cyber security and online intimidation. The Minister will realise that digital access adds another layer of administration. The code envisages online meetings and union material being circulated through email or the employer’s intranet, normally within two working days of a request. On Report on the Employment Rights Bill, the Government expanded the Bill’s general access provisions to include digital communication. That was only on Report in the other place. Employers examining the Bill as originally introduced could not have assessed obligations that were subsequently added. Whether Ministers discussed those proposals with trade unions beforehand is something that only the Minister will be able to clarify. I invite him to do so. Businesses deserved a clear explanation of what the implications for them were. It seems once again that this Government regard employers’ concerns as something to acknowledge and then disregard. Businesses need clear, workable rules, particularly when they are being asked to assume unfamiliar responsibilities. I ask the Minister not only to answer the questions which I have already posed but to deal with the very serious concerns that I outlined. Additionally, will he commit at the very least to publishing better practical guidance for employers, with clear examples distinguishing legitimate day-to-day management from unfair practices and explaining how digital access can be provided securely? I invite the Minister to respond to that point in particular, as well as the other questions I have raised.

    View contribution permalink →

  6. Baroness Bousted (Lab)

    My Lords, I will speak in praise of the guidance that has been produced by ACAS. I declare my interests as a former general secretary of a major teaching union and as a former president of the TUC. I read the guidance over the last few days. It is balanced, useful and clearly delineates the respective responsibilities of unions and employers. It is very clear and suitably detailed, and it has got the tone right, with the emphasis on unions and employers working together, respectful relationships between unions and employers, and clarity of detail. All those things are absolutely essential for effective and productive workplace relations. It is really important to realise that unions should have the right to organise and to represent workers in the workplace, and that barriers to that right should not be artificially erected, as they have been with previous trade union legislation. The draft ACAS code strengthens the collective voice in the workplace. The guidance is really clear. For example, paragraph 40 says that nothing should militate against “the employer’s responsibility for health and safety, safeguarding and security issues and, where relevant, the need for the employer to protect commercial confidentiality”. It also says that these issues are generally not insurmountable and should be resolved through negotiation. Parties are encouraged to take a “practical problem-solving approach”.

    View contribution permalink →

  7. There is clear guidance about digital access. I emphasise here that we live in the 21st century; it is not the case any longer that you can reach most of the workforce through vast workplace meetings. Most employees deal with a lot of their working lives through digital access. The factors to take into account are clearly delineated in the guidance, which says:

    View contribution permalink →

  8. “The union should ensure that disruption to the business is minimised”.

    View contribution permalink →

  9. It is absolutely clear that nothing in the code encourages the employer to go against their legal obligations. The employer is not required to disseminate material that is

    View contribution permalink →

  10. “harassing, discriminatory, threatening or defamatory”.

    View contribution permalink →

  11. Equally, the employer should not refuse to distribute the union’s materials simply because the content is contrary to the employer’s wishes.

    View contribution permalink →

  12. When it comes to digital communication, the guidance is really clear. Paragraph 59 states:

    View contribution permalink →

  13. “The employer should allow the representative to make reasonable use”

    View contribution permalink →

  14. of internal electronic communications, particularly if

    View contribution permalink →

  15. “the employer uses such forms of communication to send to the workers information arguing against the union’s case for recognition”.

    View contribution permalink →

  16. In conclusion, the guidance is clear and very sensible. It commits and encourages employers and unions to discuss how each party will work together and campaign to avoid ill-judged activity which can damage trust and long-term employment relations. It is absolutely essential that this guidance is implemented in order for employers and unions to work together and negotiate productively, which will reduce workplace stress and the number of disputes. It will enable employers to manage their businesses correctly and enable unions to organise and represent their members, as they have a democratic right to do.

    View contribution permalink →

  17. Lord Leong (Lab)

    Before I respond to the questions from the noble Lord, Lord Hunt, I need to make a correction. When I referred to the small business exemption to the statutory recognition process, I said 25 workers, but it should have been 21 workers. I am grateful to my noble friend Lady Bousted for her support for the Code of Practice: Access and Unfair Practices During the Recognition and Derecognition Process. I will address some of the questions that the noble Lord, Lord Hunt, posed. In respect of the five days and 45 minutes, I have run businesses previously and I understand that staff time matters, but it is also really important that employers with fewer than 21 workers are outside the statutory recognition scheme. For those covered, the code’s suggested meeting frequency and duration allow flexibility over practical arrangements. Smaller meetings and arrangements suited to shift patterns will minimise disruption. Workers should have a meaningful opportunity to ask questions and businesses should have a workable arrangement for providing that. In respect of the level playing field, employers have access to the workforce throughout the recognition process. Granting the union access to the workplace from the point when the CAC accepts a recognition claim enables the union to also have access to the workplace from the start of the recognition process—at least, once the terms of access are agreed and determined. The code is statutory guidance; it does not impose further costs on employers beyond what Parliament has agreed to in the Employment Rights Act. The noble Lord, Lord Hunt, also asked about review. We will keep under review whether further non-statuary guidance is necessary alongside updated CAC guidance. We will also consider whether any further updates to the code are required, alongside revision in due course to reflect phase 2 of e-balloting in relation to recognition and derecognition ballots. We also recognise that many of the respondents who are less familiar with the statutory recognition process want additional guidance, so the Government intend to amend the existing guidance on the GOV.UK website to support employers and trade union representatives participating in the recognition process. The CAC also provides guides to the parties to enable unions and employers to navigate the statutory recognition and derecognition process. These will also be revised in time for the implementation of the changes to the 2025 Act. The noble Lord also asked about digital access. Times have moved on since the last revision of the code back in 2005 and the increased emphasis on digital access reflects that. Digital access is an important element of the access provisions in the application process, recognising that businesses increasingly rely on digital forms of communication and that, in many businesses, employees may not work from a physical business premises due to hybrid or home working arrangements. Digital access will give that ability to communicate with the workers. The Government are committed to simplifying and improving the recognition process, ensuring workers have a meaningful right to organise through trade unions. The revised code is part of that. It supports the Employment Rights Act by providing better access arrangements for unions and dealing more effectively with unfair practices during the recognition and derecognition process. We have listened very carefully to the views expressed during consultation early this year and have amended the code to aid clarity and support practical use as far as possible. I believe that the code before us will assist unions and employers in complying with the new statutory requirements regarding access and unfair practices.

    View contribution permalink →

  18. Lord Hunt of Wirral (Con)

    My Lords, I am listening very carefully to what the Minister is saying, but he still has not explained the extent to which such a huge percentage—nearly 100% of those consulted—did not feel that the Government had listened carefully to their points on the code. He also has not explained how we can ensure that digital access is proved to be secure. Allowing a trade union access into the internal mechanisms and lines of communication of any employer without establishing any evidence that the employees would like to entertain the idea of joining a trade union, as was previously necessary, is a huge change. It really must be provided securely. Allowing anyone to come into the internal mechanism of any employer in the UK is surely a step too far.

    View contribution permalink →

  19. Lord Leong (Lab)

    I thank the noble Lord for that. I will try to address the whole thing about security and additional access. The code does not require the employer to give the union, including any union official who is not one of the employer’s workers, information that would be in breach of GDPR. That is the safeguard, as are any other data protection law requirements. Nor does the code require an employer to give the union, including an employee of the union, access to the employer’s electronic system or to change its IT system to meet access requirements. That safeguard protects security and nothing will affect the GDPR rules, as stated earlier. I will respond to questions about the consultation and listening to employers. We have consulted and, yes, employers may not agree with some of the positions that we have taken, but in government we have to ensure the rights of workers and the rights around union recognition, while also ensuring that employers have an opportunity to consult their workers if they wish to do so. That is what we are doing: we are giving the unions and employers the opportunity to work within the framework either to recognise or to derecognise the unions. We may disagree with what the employers say but we believe that we are taking the right decision to give employers and unions that framework. Therefore, I believe that the code will assist both unions and employers in complying with the new statutory requirements regarding access and unfair practices during the recognition and derecognition processes.

    View contribution permalink →

  20. Motion agreed.

    View contribution permalink →

Source: UK Parliament Hansard API. Debate ID: 5415365.