Contribution
My Lords, I am grateful to the Minister for explaining or setting out the case for these regulations, which make the legal adjustments needed for British Steel to operate under public ownership. I am also very grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Mohammed of Tinsley, and my noble friend Lord Redwood for their contributions and detailed questions.
We still do not know how nationalisation will make this business financially sustainable. During the passage of the Steel Industry (Nationalisation) Act, we repeatedly challenged the Government to explain why public ownership was the answer, and we never received a convincing economic case. We heard and we have just heard again the arguments for preserving steel-making, protecting jobs and maintaining strategic capability. I believe the Minister called it foundational. But those objectives do not in themselves demonstrate that nationalisation is the best means of achieving them.
A separate question—and perhaps a brief digression— is that the impact assessment says:
“Steel is also critical for defence, expected to rise by an annualised rate of 4.8% to 58kt in 2050, with increasing defence spending targets”.
We have not got those defence spending targets yet, so how can such precision in that assertion be justified? I am afraid that it rather looks as if the Government are inventing post facto reasons for taking these steps. The Government have pressed ahead with their nationalisation agenda, but now the Public Accounts Committee has warned that they have not yet set out a credible plan for British Steel’s financial sustainability. Why is that plan still missing?
The committee recognised that the initial intervention bought time, but buying time is an expensive exercise when taxpayer support continues at about £1.3 million a day. Given the fiscal pressures facing this country—pressures that this Government’s uncontrolled spending over the last two years caused—the public deserve more than another open-ended commitment. How much is it expected to cost to put British Steel on a financially sustainable footing? What investment will be required over what period and from whom? What evidence do the Government have that nationalisation will reduce operating costs or improve productivity?
There is also the cost of decarbonisation. Transitioning to electric arc furnace steel making requires substantial investment. Tata’s transformation programme at Port Talbot amounts to approximately £1.25 billion, which includes £500 million of government support. But even today in Politico we read a story that that investment is at risk. When the first blast furnace at Scunthorpe was built in 1939, I do not believe that environmental concerns were foremost in people’s minds. I imagine that the decarbonisation and decommissioning costs of these when we finally transition to electric arc furnaces will be enormous. We have asked the Government before, and we have never really heard a convincing argument. Can we please have some idea of a breakdown of potential costs?
Meanwhile, the Government still intend to reduce their carbon border adjustment mechanism in January 2027. That will impose a carbon charge on specified imported steel products, which will create additional costs and administrative obligations for businesses that rely on those imports, including products that they cannot obtain from British suppliers. Will the Government reconsider this measure before adding yet another burden to British manufacturing? What assessment have they made of its combined effect with existing steel tariffs?
The Business Secretary warned last week against pursuing net zero at the expense of British jobs and industry. Will the Government apply that same principle to steel, ensuring that their policies preserve industrial capability rather than price it out of existence? The tariffs that are already introduced illustrate the danger. Measures presented as support for domestic steel-makers have not resolved British Steel’s underlying viability problem, while downstream businesses face higher costs. We have repeatedly warned Ministers about those consequences.
When asked by the Public Accounts Committee whether the tariffs could put smaller firms out of business, the department’s response was that they are
“afraid that may well be the case”.
What an extraordinary response to the prospect of businesses closing and livelihoods being lost. They have not helped boost domestic steel and are killing jobs across other sectors. Will the Government now reverse these damaging tariffs rather than treating the consequences on the downstream industry as an unfortunate detail?
Finally, as the Minister said, these regulations exempt the publicly owned company from freedom of information and public procurement legislation. If the Government seek those exemptions while committing substantial public money, the case for clear financial reporting and parliamentary scrutiny becomes stronger still, as my noble friend Lord Redwood explained very clearly. The public deserve transparency. How and on what is their £1.3 million pounds per day being spent?
The Government need to produce a credible plan, a realistic assessment of costs and an explanation of how they will protect jobs across the whole supply chain. When will we receive that plan? I will reiterate a few other questions to which we need answers. Where are we now? How much money has been spent? What is the plan for the blast furnaces? I understand that a new chairman has been appointed for British Steel; if he is not willing to change these transparency rules, could we persuade the Minister to invite the new chairman in for a chat with interested Peers, to find out his views on the viability of the business? My noble friend Lord Redwood asked an extremely interesting question about defining sustainable and what it means in this context.
Finally, if the noble Lord, Lord Mohammed of Tinsley, thinks that the EU would ever help us export steel, even when we were members, I have a bridge to sell him.