Contribution
I thank the Minister for bringing forward these regulations. I will speak first to the electrical safety ones, which are largely a technical amendment to reflect other changes to regulation. Landlords do have that duty, and they will continue to have that duty.
First, I have some issues about monitoring the legislation, which sits with local housing authorities. I would be interested to hear from the Minister what impact local government reorganisation will have on local authorities’ capacity to do this. What will happen with the pause/non-pause, on/off reorganisation that we are seeing? Who will be responsible in the various interims?
Secondly, the noble Baroness, Lady Pinnock, raised the other key point I had. It is all very well being responsible for electrical safety, but you need to be able to deliver it. If the tenant is not enabling you to deliver it, how will that be addressed? I think we addressed that in the Social Housing Bill, but I do not think we yet have a clear answer from the Government.
I turn to the regulations on hazards in social housing. These are well-meaning regulations. The original Awaab’s law was introduced by the previous Conservative Government, rightly, to address a very important concern. We pay tribute to the family of Awaab Ishak for action they have taken, after that very unfortunate and sad death, to ensure that that it does not happen again. Phase 1 of this law is already in force, and these regulations seem to expand the scope of the existing law to cover additional hazards, as has been mentioned—whether they are temperatures, hygiene hazards, structural hazards and so forth. But we should take serious note of concerns raised by industry groups and key stakeholders on these matters.
The National Housing Federation has warned that there will be substantial increased costs to housing associations which could take resources away from more routine repairs and maintenance. Homeless Link has warned that there is no dedicated government funding for implementation for providers already operating on thin margins. This is a real pressure, particularly as phase 2 significantly increases the volume of hazards in scope. Looking through the impact assessment, we can see an increase in costs of £213.6 million. However, as the noble Baroness, Lady Pinnock, alluded to, that is the administrative increase in cost, but not all increases were included, because a number of them were hard, if not impossible, to assess, so they were ignored, which I find slightly odd. As the noble Baroness, Lady Pinnock, pointed out, if this results in more work being needed to be done, those costs could be very substantially higher.
We are at a point in time where many RPs and social landlords are not expanding their estate because they are spending so much money meeting existing regulations. We find new developments not proceeding because RPs and social landlords cannot afford to take on the Section 106 housing agreement that those developments have. So there is a balance to be had here: do we want social housing or do we want to ensure that every last little thing is perfect about every house? There is a balance, and we do not want to see people homeless because we cannot build sufficient housing for them. I am not saying where the balance should be; we just need to reflect that in this measure. There is a real cost to families; housing is costing more money, whether it is private rented or buying your own home—or, for the RPs, bringing forward social housing.
I was hoping that the noble Baroness, Lady Taylor, would be here today, and I am very disappointed—sorry, that was the wrong phrase. I need to sound more empathetic, so I apologise, although I am disappointed that she is not here because I would much rather if she was fit and well and here. So yes, absolutely, it is the right phrase. But I have several times asked the question. The Government have frequently announced a very large investment over many years in social housing, and I have asked how much social housing the Government expect to be delivered and occupied by July 2029, the fifth anniversary of their coming into government. I do not expect the Minister to have the answer at his fingertips, but it would be tremendous if he could write to me afterwards.
I come back to some of the things that the noble Baroness, Lady Pinnock, said, which I totally agree with. What are the tenant’s responsibilities in this? Not everything is down to the landlord, and we need to consider that. We also need to consider the view of “reasonable”, which is a very ill-defined term unless it is defined. As the noble Baroness, Lady Pinnock, said, a tenant’s view of what is reasonable may be different from that of the landlord, and the views of different tenants may be very different. We need to get a balance here. Our key concern is balance. This will cost money; it will have an impact on social landlords. It is right that we provide safe and secure homes to people, but we also need to think of the balance of safe and secure with enough homes, and I want to ensure that that balance is correct. What plans do this Government have to support and incentivise responsible landlords to keep investing in the safe homes that are needed? I look forward to hearing the Minister’s response.