T

The Minister of State, Department for Work and Pensions (Baroness Sherlock) (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 15 October 2026

Debate

Pensions Triple Lock

Contribution

My Lords, I thank both noble Lords for their contributions. I will respond to some of the more specific points in a moment, but it is important to set out the context behind what we are doing. We are fulfilling our promise to keep the triple lock for the duration of this Parliament. Because of that, the full new state pension is projected to be £2,000 higher by the end of it than it was at the start. That is forecast to be a record high, not only in cash terms but as a percentage of average earnings, at around 30%. I hope that is the point that the noble Lord, Lord Palmer, raised just now about the job of the triple lock. I shall let the parties opposite argue about who is responsible for bringing it in—it is probably not for me to intrude on private grief, but I may listen in later—but we have been very pleased to support it for the duration of this Parliament. From April 2030, we are proposing an adjusted triple lock. It will retain its current three elements; that is because we believe in a universal state pension that protects pensioners against price rises, that rises materially every year, and which enables pensioners to share in the wealth of the nation as wages go up. We are not abandoning the triple lock. To be clear, under the adjusted triple lock, the state pension will not only continue to rise each year by the rate of inflation or by 2.5%; it will go up by more than that when needed to protect its value relative to earnings. That ensures that the gains made under the lifespan of the current triple lock are protected. But we will adjust the earnings element to avoid the ratchet effect that is baked into the current design. When the state pension increases faster than earnings, that becomes permanent. There is no mechanism through which wages can ever catch back up. That means that, left as it is, the state pension would continue to rise faster than earnings indefinitely. Our adjustment means a rise in the state pension above the level of earnings in one or more years will mean that future increases will track inflation or 2.5% until wages catch up. The state pension will increase at a more sustainable rate because it will rise in line with earnings over time instead of outpacing them. In response to the noble Baroness, Lady Stedman-Scott, we have been up front about the fact that this means the state pension will rise more slowly over time than it would otherwise have done under the current triple lock. But for pensioners and their families, peace of mind comes not only from the state pension but from knowing that they will be able to get the care that they need. This adjustment to the triple lock will help us as we build up a national care service, with estimated savings of £15 billion a year by the end of the next decade and £50 billion by 2050. This is a new settlement for older people—a better deal for them, for their families and, indeed, for the NHS, which too often bears the brunt of a social care system whose failures have been ignored for far too long. It is a state pension that still rises every year, while the gains of almost 20 years of the current triple lock will be locked in, alongside free personal care from a national care service. I turn to some of the specific points raised by noble Lords. I realise that the noble Baroness, Lady Stedman-Scott, has to land some punches, but let me just push back gently. I have listened carefully to her opposition to our proposals. I remind her gently that many in her own party, of course, agree with the case for change. Let me cite just a couple. The shadow Foreign Secretary has called the current system “simply not affordable” and described it as a “Ponzi system”. The shadow Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster said we should unpick the triple lock. The noble Lord, Lord Gove, told LBC, on which he was appearing with Stella Creasy, that if Andy Burnham changed the triple lock he would “declare that I will be campaigning at the next general election exclusively for Stella”. I look forward to going to Walthamstow and watching the enjoyment of that particular bit of entertainment. The noble Lord, Lord Hague, said that the triple lock is “ultimately unsustainable. Somehow the main political parties have to give themselves, and each other, the space to amend it”. I could go on for some time, but I will not. The noble Baroness will have to reflect in her own time as to how her party would fund its opposition to our plans. Would it be, as previously, that they would fund it through an ever-rising state pension age, with people having to work into their 70s? How would they fund the future of social care—or is it just another of the many unfunded commitments that we are seeing, alongside everything from inheritance tax, stamp duty, national insurance and private schools, all funded from fantasy welfare savings, none of which they achieved when they were in office? Now that I have got that off my chest, let me look at some of the specifics. The noble Baroness asked why we have made the change before the Pensions Commission has finished its final report. The Government needed to act now to sort out one of the most difficult problems that the country has faced for a long time—social care. The introduction of a new national care service that provides older people with free personal care and the adjustment of the triple lock are, as I have said, part of a new settlement for older people that puts the state pension on a sustainable footing. The Pensions Commission is there to do its job; it has been specifically asked to make recommendations on further support for lower-income pensioners and we look forward to its report next year. The noble Baroness asked specifically about social care and what the national care service will do. I am not sure whether it is on at the moment, but my honourable friend the Minister for Social Care, Alison McGovern, is making a Statement in the other place. It may indeed be right now; if not, it will be very soon, so I commend the contents of that to noble Lords who want to know more about that matter. I shall just give some headlines on this. The costs of the national care service will be determined after the review by the noble Baroness, Lady Casey, has reported. That review will make its recommendations next summer. Those recommendations will include how and when we build up the national care service, as the savings from the triple lock will increase over time. Of course, as we have indicated, the changes we have announced today will actually result in savings of £50 billion a year by 2050. I should also just say that we are not simply waiting and doing nothing on social care now. Staff will be the backbone of the national care service, so we are already improving pay and conditions for care workers and introducing the first ever national collective pension scheme for care workers. Later this year, we will publish a social care workforce plan. We are building the foundations today for that service, which will be built up over time. The key difference it will make is that people will not only be able to get the support they need but, crucially, they will get free personal care on top of the nursing care that they get from the NHS at the moment. That will take such a pressure off so many. In terms of the detail of this, we have committed to keeping the triple lock until the end of this Parliament, so the new system will start from 2030. We will legislate, obviously, for changes to social care, and any legislation we publish will have detailed impact assessments at that point. Before we get to that point, the noble Baroness and noble Lord will have answers to all their questions about the shape of that. We deliberately set out to allow a careful and thorough examination of the options, and we had really hoped that this would be a cross-party conversation; I know that some parties have been willing to engage in conversations with the noble Baroness, Lady Casey, and to look together at how we can try to build up a care service. This is one of those issues on which it is easy for different parties to take lumps out of each other and never solve it, but we have to do it together. The country needs us to get that right. We are happy to have those conversations once the report comes out, and indeed in the run-up to it. I commend those parties which have been willing to engage in trying to do the right thing for the sake of our country. Ultimately, we need to make a difference to what is happening in this country. The final thing I will say is that, if noble Lords really believe that nothing should ever change, it is incumbent upon them to come out and say how would they pay for it in future. We are determined to make the state pension sustainable, and we are determined to address the evils of the lack of social care and the crisis it is creating for so many of our families, for individual carers and for our NHS. Can we all try to address the full range of those issues? If noble Lords do not like what we are doing, I look forward to hearing their solutions. In the meantime, I commend ours to them.

More from The Minister of State, Department for Work and Pensions (Baroness Sherlock) (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.