Hansard·Lords Chamber·Vol. 860

Pensions Triple Lock

Thursday, 15 October 2026

38 contributions12 members

Contributions

  1. Statement

    View contribution permalink →

  2. The following Statement was made in the House of Commons on Tuesday 13 October.

    View contribution permalink →

  3. “With permission, I will make a Statement on the Government’s plan for the future uprating of the state pension. Security and dignity in later life is a mission that has run through every Labour Government. Harold Wilson was the first to introduce the statutory link with earnings. The creation of pension credit in the early 2000s increased the incomes of the poorest pensioners and saw pensioner poverty halve under the last Labour Government.

    View contribution permalink →

  4. In our 2024 manifesto, we said we would keep the triple lock for the duration of this Parliament—that is a promise that we will keep to pensioners. Keeping that promise means that this year the full new state pension is rising by £575. It is set to be over £2,000 a year more by the end of this Parliament compared with when we took office in 2024. That will take the new state pension to over 30% of average earnings by the end of the Parliament and it is forecast to be a record high. In the future, we will adjust the triple lock to make those gains permanent but also to put the state pension on a sustainable basis.

    View contribution permalink →

  5. Let me set out how that will work and deliver a state pension that rises each and every year. The uprating mechanism will retain its current three elements. There will be a universal state pension that protects against inflation, ensures a material rise every year, and enables pensioners to share in the wealth of the nation as wages go up. From April 2030, the state pension will continue to go up by the highest of inflation, 2.5% or what is required to maintain its record high level against average earnings. That will lock in for the future all the gains from the triple lock up until April 2030.

    View contribution permalink →

  6. The adjusted mechanism will mean that the state pension grows in line with earnings over time, instead of outpacing them as is the case with the current triple lock. It will end what is known as the ratchet effect, which makes the triple lock consume a greater share of national wealth over time, making reform at some stage inevitable. In simple terms, it will mean the state pension will continue to rise but not to permanently grow as a share of average earnings.

    View contribution permalink →

  7. We know that people want security in retirement and we are committed to protecting the poorest pensioners. Under our plans, pensioner poverty is set to fall. In addition, we have asked the Pensions Commission to include suggestions on further supporting lower-income pensioners in its final report, to be delivered next year.

    View contribution permalink →

  8. A good retirement, however, is about more than income. It is about security and peace of mind too, which is why it is so important that the savings from the change will make a significant contribution to a new settlement for older people: a rising, more sustainable state pension alongside free personal care through a new national care service. This is a policy that is better for pensioners, better for families and better for the NHS. It is better for pensioners because so many worry about what will happen to them in their final years; better for families because those worries are shared by children and grandchildren who want to know that their elderly relatives will be looked after when they need it; and better for the NHS because it will ease the pressure we see today, where failings in our social care system mean many pensioners are kept in hospital longer than they need to be because social care beds are unavailable. The cost of inaction—the cost of turning away from this—is more pressure on the NHS, more ambulance call-outs, more A&E admissions, more corridor care and more people stuck in hospital when they do not have to be. That is why change is needed.

    View contribution permalink →

  9. The triple lock has of course been the subject of much debate. Economists and commentators have proposed a range of options—as has the Conservative Party, over the years—from removing the earnings link to scrapping the triple lock altogether. Some have called for the state pension to be means tested. We have rejected those proposals. We believe that our plan is the right answer to a difficult question that has been ignored for far too long.

    View contribution permalink →

  10. I am enormously grateful to my honourable friend the Minister for Pensions for his work in this area, which has helped to ensure that we can have a system going forward that is sustainable and retains, in an adjusted way, the three current elements of the triple lock system. It will mean that the state pension will not continue to outpace average earnings as it would have done under the current triple lock. The savings from the changes will reduce spending by an estimated £15 billion a year by the end of the next decade, rising substantially to around £50 billion a year by 2050.

    View contribution permalink →

  11. The pension and social care changes are a new settlement that puts the universal state pension on a more sustainable footing, so that it is there for decades to come, while giving pensioners and older people a better deal on social care. Pensioners can be confident that they will have a rising state pension every year. They can also be confident that we are sorting out one of the most difficult problems the country has faced for a long time—the issue of social care. A new settlement for pensioners, a rising pension, a sustainable system, and a plan to fix our social care system: that is what we will deliver. I commend this Statement to the House”.

    View contribution permalink →

  12. Baroness Stedman-Scott (Con)

    My Lords, the triple lock was introduced by a Conservative Chancellor to tackle the very serious problem of pensioner poverty. Its introduction reflected a fundamental principle: those who work hard, pay their taxes and contribute to our country throughout their working lives should be able to enjoy security and dignity in retirement. Many have planned on that basis. The Labour Government have now abandoned that commitment. Although the existing triple lock will remain in place until April 2030, the Government’s plan would thereafter remove the guarantee that pensioners receive the full benefit of annual earnings growth whenever earnings are the highest of the three existing measures. This is a material reduction in the protection currently afforded to pensioners. The Government say that the savings generated by this change will contribute towards the cost of their proposed nationalised care service, but the numbers have already started to unravel. Can the Minister say how much the Government intend to raise from their plan to abandon the triple lock, and how much they expect a national social care service to cost? Linking this decision to the national care service policy also raises a serious question about timing. The Government have cited savings of £15 billion in 2039-40 and £50 billion in 2049-50, but a national care service offering free personal care will require substantial expenditure much sooner than that. Those long-term figures do not explain how the Government intend to meet the upfront transitional cost of introducing nationalised, free personal care in the next Parliament, particularly if removing charges leads to increased demand, as one would expect. What will happen, for example, to the huge amount of informal and family care that is currently provided? I hope the Minister can answer that in her response. The wider reason for this decision is not difficult to discern. The Government’s appalling mismanagement of the economy, combined with their ever-growing spending commitments, has placed our public finances under mounting and increasingly unsustainable pressure. These pressures are, in turn, compounding one another: the rising cost of borrowing means that an ever-greater proportion of public expenditure is being consumed simply by servicing our national debt, leaving less money available for the public services and priorities on which people depend. The Government could choose to prioritise economic growth and abandon their unemployment Bill and job-killing national insurance hike. Instead, this Government have chosen to pursue the same old tax-and-spend agenda. According to the Department for Work and Pensions’ own figures, total welfare expenditure in the United Kingdom was forecast to reach £333.7 billion in the 2025-26 financial year, compared with approximately £315 billion in the preceding year. By 2030-31, expenditure is projected to approach £409 billion. That represents an increase of almost £75 billion. When will Ministers have the courage to take the difficult decisions and tackle the unsustainable growth in welfare spending? This week, the Times reported some shocking stories, which were referred to in Oral Questions: of those on sickness benefits who want to come off them but have been told by DWP that they cannot; and of the more than 120,000 teenagers with autism, ADHD and depression who are claiming disability benefits, at a cost to the taxpayer of more than £1 billion a year. The welfare system is haemorrhaging money to people who do not want it, who do not need it, and who should be in work but are not. Rather than confronting these fundamental problems and addressing the drivers of rising welfare expenditure, the Government have chosen to revisit the protections afforded to those who have worked hard, paid into the system and contributed to our country throughout their lives. I find that choice difficult to understand. It is fundamentally a political choice. Following the deeply damaging decision to restrict winter fuel payments, and the subsequent U-turn, it is difficult to see how this latest announcement can do anything other than further erode the confidence of pensioners in the Government’s commitment to them. I conclude by putting several questions to the Minister. First, why have the Government made a decision of this scale before the Pensions Commission has published its final recommendations on retirement adequacy? Was the commission consulted before the decision was made, and will it now be required to revise its projections? Secondly, why has the Casey commission been given a clear role in designing a nationalised care service while the Pensions Commission appears not to have been given an equivalent role in assessing the effect of this decision on retirement adequacy? Will the Minister explain how the Government will finance the upfront cost of nationalised free personal care in the next Parliament when the savings cited today will build only gradually over decades? Finally, the Government describe this policy as an adjustment to the triple lock, while the Prime Minister says that the state pension will continue to track average earnings over time. But if the new arrangement will produce substantial savings, it must necessarily leave future pensioners worse off than they would have been under the existing triple lock. Can the Minister confirm that this is correct? Pensioners deserve security in retirement. Many of them will feel profoundly disappointed, quite justifiably, and some even betrayed by this decision.

    View contribution permalink →

  13. Lord Palmer of Childs Hill (LD)

    My Lords, I thank the Minister for setting out the Government’s plans for the future of the state pension. I have read it two or three times and I think I understand it. The triple lock is not simply an accounting method; it is a commitment to fairness between generations, to dignity in retirement, and to ensuring that people who have worked hard and contributed throughout their lives can look forward to an old age without fear of poverty. We on these Benches absolutely support and are proud to have been instrumental in introducing the triple lock, and the impact that it has had on reducing pensioner poverty and inequality within pension pots. When the triple lock was first introduced, it was clear that it should not be around for ever once it had achieved its aim of undoing the erosion of the state pension that we have seen over 30 years. We should seriously discuss the alternatives, and I hope we will. However, it is uncertain whether the triple lock has ever achieved its aim, especially with 1.9 million UK pensioners living in relative poverty. It is unclear what impact Prime Minister Burnham’s proposals would actually have. They sound good, but what would they actually mean? The Government’s estimate of savings from their new state pension system has been challenged by many groups, including the IFS, which said, first: “We should not expect this reform to save enough that it could fund universal social care in the next parliament” and, secondly, that the saving is very uncertain and, therefore, tax rises or other spending cuts will be needed to pay for social care. I hope that the Minister can deal with those comments made by the IFS and others when she replies. We are open to discussing how to make the state pension better, and how we can improve the triple lock in supporting pensioners and those saving for pensions, and for affordability. However, changing such a significant part of the economic support that we provide the British people cannot be done on a whim. We therefore ask the Government to publish far more evidence ahead of any changes. The comments made from the Conservative Front Bench as to there being a lot of unanswered questions need to be addressed before we make any fundamental changes which affect real people.

    View contribution permalink →

  14. The Minister of State, Department for Work and Pensions (Baroness Sherlock) (Lab)

    My Lords, I thank both noble Lords for their contributions. I will respond to some of the more specific points in a moment, but it is important to set out the context behind what we are doing. We are fulfilling our promise to keep the triple lock for the duration of this Parliament. Because of that, the full new state pension is projected to be £2,000 higher by the end of it than it was at the start. That is forecast to be a record high, not only in cash terms but as a percentage of average earnings, at around 30%. I hope that is the point that the noble Lord, Lord Palmer, raised just now about the job of the triple lock. I shall let the parties opposite argue about who is responsible for bringing it in—it is probably not for me to intrude on private grief, but I may listen in later—but we have been very pleased to support it for the duration of this Parliament. From April 2030, we are proposing an adjusted triple lock. It will retain its current three elements; that is because we believe in a universal state pension that protects pensioners against price rises, that rises materially every year, and which enables pensioners to share in the wealth of the nation as wages go up. We are not abandoning the triple lock. To be clear, under the adjusted triple lock, the state pension will not only continue to rise each year by the rate of inflation or by 2.5%; it will go up by more than that when needed to protect its value relative to earnings. That ensures that the gains made under the lifespan of the current triple lock are protected. But we will adjust the earnings element to avoid the ratchet effect that is baked into the current design. When the state pension increases faster than earnings, that becomes permanent. There is no mechanism through which wages can ever catch back up. That means that, left as it is, the state pension would continue to rise faster than earnings indefinitely. Our adjustment means a rise in the state pension above the level of earnings in one or more years will mean that future increases will track inflation or 2.5% until wages catch up. The state pension will increase at a more sustainable rate because it will rise in line with earnings over time instead of outpacing them. In response to the noble Baroness, Lady Stedman-Scott, we have been up front about the fact that this means the state pension will rise more slowly over time than it would otherwise have done under the current triple lock. But for pensioners and their families, peace of mind comes not only from the state pension but from knowing that they will be able to get the care that they need. This adjustment to the triple lock will help us as we build up a national care service, with estimated savings of £15 billion a year by the end of the next decade and £50 billion by 2050. This is a new settlement for older people—a better deal for them, for their families and, indeed, for the NHS, which too often bears the brunt of a social care system whose failures have been ignored for far too long. It is a state pension that still rises every year, while the gains of almost 20 years of the current triple lock will be locked in, alongside free personal care from a national care service. I turn to some of the specific points raised by noble Lords. I realise that the noble Baroness, Lady Stedman-Scott, has to land some punches, but let me just push back gently. I have listened carefully to her opposition to our proposals. I remind her gently that many in her own party, of course, agree with the case for change. Let me cite just a couple. The shadow Foreign Secretary has called the current system “simply not affordable” and described it as a “Ponzi system”. The shadow Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster said we should unpick the triple lock. The noble Lord, Lord Gove, told LBC, on which he was appearing with Stella Creasy, that if Andy Burnham changed the triple lock he would “declare that I will be campaigning at the next general election exclusively for Stella”. I look forward to going to Walthamstow and watching the enjoyment of that particular bit of entertainment. The noble Lord, Lord Hague, said that the triple lock is “ultimately unsustainable. Somehow the main political parties have to give themselves, and each other, the space to amend it”. I could go on for some time, but I will not. The noble Baroness will have to reflect in her own time as to how her party would fund its opposition to our plans. Would it be, as previously, that they would fund it through an ever-rising state pension age, with people having to work into their 70s? How would they fund the future of social care—or is it just another of the many unfunded commitments that we are seeing, alongside everything from inheritance tax, stamp duty, national insurance and private schools, all funded from fantasy welfare savings, none of which they achieved when they were in office? Now that I have got that off my chest, let me look at some of the specifics. The noble Baroness asked why we have made the change before the Pensions Commission has finished its final report. The Government needed to act now to sort out one of the most difficult problems that the country has faced for a long time—social care. The introduction of a new national care service that provides older people with free personal care and the adjustment of the triple lock are, as I have said, part of a new settlement for older people that puts the state pension on a sustainable footing. The Pensions Commission is there to do its job; it has been specifically asked to make recommendations on further support for lower-income pensioners and we look forward to its report next year. The noble Baroness asked specifically about social care and what the national care service will do. I am not sure whether it is on at the moment, but my honourable friend the Minister for Social Care, Alison McGovern, is making a Statement in the other place. It may indeed be right now; if not, it will be very soon, so I commend the contents of that to noble Lords who want to know more about that matter. I shall just give some headlines on this. The costs of the national care service will be determined after the review by the noble Baroness, Lady Casey, has reported. That review will make its recommendations next summer. Those recommendations will include how and when we build up the national care service, as the savings from the triple lock will increase over time. Of course, as we have indicated, the changes we have announced today will actually result in savings of £50 billion a year by 2050. I should also just say that we are not simply waiting and doing nothing on social care now. Staff will be the backbone of the national care service, so we are already improving pay and conditions for care workers and introducing the first ever national collective pension scheme for care workers. Later this year, we will publish a social care workforce plan. We are building the foundations today for that service, which will be built up over time. The key difference it will make is that people will not only be able to get the support they need but, crucially, they will get free personal care on top of the nursing care that they get from the NHS at the moment. That will take such a pressure off so many. In terms of the detail of this, we have committed to keeping the triple lock until the end of this Parliament, so the new system will start from 2030. We will legislate, obviously, for changes to social care, and any legislation we publish will have detailed impact assessments at that point. Before we get to that point, the noble Baroness and noble Lord will have answers to all their questions about the shape of that. We deliberately set out to allow a careful and thorough examination of the options, and we had really hoped that this would be a cross-party conversation; I know that some parties have been willing to engage in conversations with the noble Baroness, Lady Casey, and to look together at how we can try to build up a care service. This is one of those issues on which it is easy for different parties to take lumps out of each other and never solve it, but we have to do it together. The country needs us to get that right. We are happy to have those conversations once the report comes out, and indeed in the run-up to it. I commend those parties which have been willing to engage in trying to do the right thing for the sake of our country. Ultimately, we need to make a difference to what is happening in this country. The final thing I will say is that, if noble Lords really believe that nothing should ever change, it is incumbent upon them to come out and say how would they pay for it in future. We are determined to make the state pension sustainable, and we are determined to address the evils of the lack of social care and the crisis it is creating for so many of our families, for individual carers and for our NHS. Can we all try to address the full range of those issues? If noble Lords do not like what we are doing, I look forward to hearing their solutions. In the meantime, I commend ours to them.

    View contribution permalink →

  15. Baroness MacLeod of Camusdarach (Lab)

    Can the Minister set out exactly what will happen to the state pension in Scotland? If possible, can she confirm that the Scottish Government will get extra money to spend on social care of whatever they wish?

    View contribution permalink →

  16. Baroness Sherlock (Lab)

    I thank my noble friend for that question. Yes, I am very happy to do that, because I gather that there have been some confusing statements coming out. Scottish pensioners will have a rising state pension every year, as will pensioners across our country. It is really important that everybody knows that. There is no question that the pension will be different in Scotland. Scottish pensioners will find their pensions rising each year by the higher of inflation or 2.5%, and higher if necessary to maintain the links with earnings. It is Scotland’s place in the UK that has secured a record financial settlement for the Scottish Government, and it is Scotland’s place in the UK that means that there will be more funding for social care in Scotland as a result of the changes we have announced. Scotland will benefit from both of those and can then address the challenges. I know, for example, that there are almost 10,000 Scots waiting for social care assessments or packages—perhaps they might put some of the money towards addressing that issue.

    View contribution permalink →

  17. Lord Stoneham of Droxford (LD)

    My Lords, I commend the courage of the Government in questioning the triple lock at this time if there is to be a deal to help with social care. The hypocrisy of the Opposition Benches, having lost control of public spending and welfare spending in their term of office, is deplorable, as is not being prepared to look at this. It looks like we will not get enough money from revising the triple lock. Will the Government look at other means, such as state insurance or auto-enrolment schemes, as a way of raising money to deal with social care costs in future?

    View contribution permalink →

  18. Baroness Sherlock (Lab)

    I thank the noble Lord for calling that out; I am grateful to him—I will not go back there, as I will only get worked up again. I will stay on the other point that he is raising. I am afraid that I am not able to give him the answer that he wants, simply because we cannot pre-empt the report from the noble Baroness, Lady Casey. We have asked her to look at options and make recommendations about how the issues can be solved and how this can be built up. After that, we will have a sense of what the costs are and we will look at the options. As I say, we are really open to conversations about the best way to do this.

    View contribution permalink →

  19. Baroness Coffey (Con)

    My Lords, the legislation is to be introduced in this Parliament, but the obvious question is: why do the Government not wait to put it in their manifesto and then introduce the legislation in the next Parliament once they have a national mandate? I turn specifically to trying to understand how the figures are being calculated for the OBR. The response today to the Written Question that I tabled was: refer back to the analysis. I am afraid that is smoke and mirrors. There was no substance given on how these figures were plucked out and, I assume, handed to the OBR so that the Government can do something in the upcoming Budget without it being an issue. Can the Minister please explain it in terms of the 30% of average earnings that she set out? Right now, 59% of pensioners are on the lower basic state pension. How will this work in the future? I appreciate that, in four years’ time, it will be only 43%, but the very lowest-income pensioners will not necessarily be getting the increases that they had hoped for when some of them perhaps voted for a Labour Government.

    View contribution permalink →

  20. Baroness Sherlock (Lab)

    I can assure the noble Baroness that there were no smoke and mirrors in the Answer that I gave her. The Answer made it clear where those figures came from. The modelling is based on Pensim3, which, as she will remember from her time in my department, is a dynamic model that the department uses. It uses the projections that are out there and projections forward on CPI. I slightly missed whether she was asking about the earnings measure, but that will be determined before any legislation is made on the way earnings are measured, but the projections were based on that and we have indicated that in the note that we put out. I cannot be any clearer than that.

    View contribution permalink →

  21. Baroness Lister of Burtersett (Lab)

    My Lords, the noble Baroness, Lady Stedman-Scott, asked when Ministers will have the courage to take difficult decisions. I am proud that we have a Prime Minister who has taken a difficult decision that politicians have been avoiding for years. We all know that the ratchet effect of the triple lock cannot continue for ever. I very much welcome what the noble Lord opposite said. When we have more information, can my noble friend make sure that it includes the gender dimension of the implications of the change? This is something that we should be congratulating the Government on.

    View contribution permalink →

  22. Baroness Sherlock (Lab)

    I am very grateful to my noble friend for that fine question. I absolutely share her admiration for the Prime Minister in this, because these are difficult decisions. The country needs and deserves leadership, and it needs and deserves leaders who are willing to look at the hard problems and make some hard choices. In this case, the Prime Minister has clearly said that, as a Government, we are committed to pensioners. We are committed to making sure that the state pension continues to rise and that it keeps pace with earnings, in order that pensioners can not only see a material benefit each year but are able to share in the wealth of the nation alongside those of working age. On my noble friend’s question about gender, the department published poverty projections on 29 September. Within that, we included the indications of a gender dimension of poverty, because there have been changes—actually, let me start again; I am sorry. We are projecting that poverty will fall from 14% in 2024-25 to 8% by 2050, which would be a record low. Within that, there will be a significant shift for a range of reasons, including the impact of the new state pension and the number of people building up a full pension, which makes a significant difference to closing the gap between men and women. My final point on that is that it is of course the Pensions Commission’s job to report on how we can deal with questions around low-income pensioners; there will be a gender dimension to that too.

    View contribution permalink →

  23. Lord Redwood (Con)

    My Lords, the plan would clearly require a very heavy care tax because the savings under the pension in the early years would be nowhere near the cost of that service. Would the intention be to abolish the contributory principle of the state pension and to abolish the National Insurance Fund?

    View contribution permalink →

  24. Baroness Sherlock (Lab)

    My Lords, please do not set any hares running. If the noble Lord believes that that is a good way forward, I encourage him to join the conversation and make those proposals to the noble Baroness, Lady Casey. I am sure she will be very glad to receive those and any other suggestions. We have been really clear that we will look at the proposals that come out of the Casey review. We will look at the suggestions and will then look at the costs and the best ways to fund that. Of course, the savings will build up over time, but it will take time to build up a national care service as well. We are laying the foundations now: we are investing in the social care workforce and in laying all the foundations to build a national care service, but it will be built up following the proposals that come out and the judgment that is made by the Government. I am really happy to look at any suggestions that the noble Lord may have.

    View contribution permalink →

  25. Lord Reid of Cardowan (Lab)

    My Lords, I echo the comments made by several noble Lords commending the Government and the Prime Minister for the courage to suggest opening up this debate. It is timely and it is long overdue, not least because the primary purpose of the triple lock, which was to reverse the disproportionate decline in pensions as compared to wages, has now been largely fulfilled. I think it is therefore timely that this should be opened up, and I hope it will be a genuine cross-party discussion. To cut to the chase, there will be many people who are worried about the stories that are being spread about this discussion. Will she confirm: first, that there will be no cuts to pensions over the next few years; secondly, that pensions will increase over the next few years, and, thirdly, that, by 2030, today’s pension will have increased by an average of £2,000 for every pensioner? I think it is absolutely essential that we get that through. Finally, it is not just a matter of whether we can provide money from this for social care—personally, I cannot make the figures add up, but we will see the outcome of the discussion. However, it is more than that: it is a matter of fairness between the generations. It is a matter of being fair to the people who work and produce the surplus that is diverted towards our pensions, not just to the pensioners themselves. I wonder if the Minister can respond to the three questions I asked. I know she said it before, but it is absolutely essential to kill the scare stories.

    View contribution permalink →

  26. Baroness Sherlock (Lab)

    I am very grateful to my noble friend, because there have indeed been scare stories, and some of them have been downright dishonest and I am disappointed to have seen them—not from anyone in this House, obviously, I hasten to add. But I am very happy to say yes to all of those things. There will be no cut to pensions: in fact, quite the reverse. We will guarantee the triple lock for the rest of this Parliament, and under the adjusted triple lock, pensions will continue to rise every single year by the higher of inflation or 2.5% and, if necessary, by even more than that if necessary to keep pace with earnings. I am really clear about that. He is absolutely right about the fact that the state pension will be around £2,000 higher at the end of this Parliament than at the beginning. The crucial point he made is about where it locks into average earnings, so by the time we get to April 2030, the full new state pension is set to be around 30% of average earnings. That is a record high, and the adjusted triple lock will then look at maintaining a link with earnings from that point onwards. It is really important to say to anyone who is out there talking to pensioners or hears pensioners talking: please do not believe the scare stories. The state pension is not being cut; the triple lock is staying in place. The IFS put it well: it is triple and so there are three things: they are inflation; 2.5%; and maintaining the links with earnings. The link with earnings is really important because it has to be sustainable and it also has to be something that is fair across the country. I have never believed in an intergenerational war. I think that young people and old people both want pensions to be appropriate. Young people want to know that they will have a pension when they come to retire, and they want the older members of their own families and their friends to be decently looked after. However, they also want them to be cared for, and our job is to give a new settlement to older people that will give them a pension that they can live on that will carry on going up, but also the guarantee of free personal care, so they need not be afraid of what happens when they get old and weak.

    View contribution permalink →

  27. Lord Purvis of Tweed (LD)

    My Lords, when the coalition introduced the triple lock, it also implemented the Liberal Democrat policy of lifting the personal allowance threshold. Subsequent Governments have frozen the personal allowance and not kept increasing it, so we have seen over the last decade more than a million pensioners on very modest incomes being captured within the tax system. It now means that a female pensioner with a very modest widow’s public sector pension of £13,000 will now be paying income tax. That cannot be right if we want a fair system with predictability for those who are on extremely modest pension incomes. In the last decade, we have seen tax increases on the most modest pensioners. Surely, part of fairness would be reversing that, so if the Government are considering changes to the lock, we also need to ensure that the personal allowance is increased as well.

    View contribution permalink →

  28. Baroness Sherlock (Lab)

    The noble Lord raises an important point. Obviously, it has always been the case that pension income from both private pensions and the state pension is taxable. The UK is not unusual in that approach. The majority of pensioners already pay tax, as they receive either state pension increments or additional occupational or private pensions. Under the previous Government, I think, more than 8 million pensioners paid income tax. However, at the moment, pensioners whose only income is the basic or new state pension without increments do not currently pay income tax because, of course, they are both below the threshold. But the noble Lord will remember that the then Chancellor made a commitment at Budget 2025 that pensioners whose incomes only just exceed the personal allowance will not have the burden of paying small amounts of income tax in this Parliament. They will be protected. I look forward to hearing more information about that, perhaps, at the upcoming Budget.

    View contribution permalink →

  29. Lord Balfe (Con)

    My Lords, if the Minister looks back to the foundation of the NHS, she will see that virtually every estimate of costs was wildly out of line. The cost of the new proposed service for domiciliary care is going to be enormous. I have spoken to people at Addenbrooke’s Hospital, and they do not even know what it is going to cover. I hope the Casey report takes us some way forward. May I also say that I regret the way in which we are drifting towards a very high-tax economy? I would ask particularly that the Treasury looks at ways of releasing some of the built-up wealth of my generation, because at the moment all the incentives are to sit on the money and not give it to the children. We could have a look at ways in which we could free up some of the capital that is already in the system but is locked in by IHT rules and the like. We could also look at exactly what is meant by a care service. What will it do? Will it come to your home and help you to dress, which the NHS does on occasions? Will it feed you? What will it actually do? We need to go a long way further forward, but I ask the Government to keep in mind that the taxpayer—and here I really do sound like Mrs Thatcher—is not a bottomless pit. There is a limit, and you get to positions like I regularly come across, where people who have worked extraordinarily hard—let us say, as an airline pilot—cannot afford to send their children to a private school, even though they are earning £120,000 a year. We have really got to look at the way in which we reward the people who work hard in this society, many of whom have come from quite humble backgrounds, but they do need to be looked after much better.

    View contribution permalink →

  30. Baroness Sherlock (Lab)

    First, I want to thank the noble Lord for the work he has done with airline pilots over the years in his trade union capacity, and I commend him for that. It is good to hear that he is still talking to people and hearing the stories he has just told. I will do him a deal, which is that I am very happy to pass on his representations on the tax front to the Treasury if he would like to make representations to the leader of his own party about the impact of the inheritance changes that they are planning at the moment and what that might do to his concerns about people locking in wealth and not leaving it. The one thing I can be clear about is that the national care service will provide free personal care for older people based on need rather than ability to pay. That will cover help with things like eating or bathing or using the toilet, but that will come on top of the nursing care that the NHS already funds. There will continue to be means-tested council contributions for the bed and board elements of that. I think that is something that is important to be clear about. Further detail will need to follow on from the Casey review, as I have said to the point of tedium, and for which I apologise. One of the things that is easy to forget is that there are costs to a national care service, but there are huge costs to not having a national care service. The costs on the NHS that are being driven inside the NHS—the cost both to NHS provision and the cost to people who are waiting for NHS provision because of the consequences of the failure of our social care system—are really significant. What we are willing to do is take hard decisions such as adjusting the triple lock to make sure that we have the money to build the foundations of that. The rest the noble Lord will have to wait for.

    View contribution permalink →

  31. Lord John of Southwark (Lab)

    My Lords, listening to the noble Baroness, Lady Stedman-Scott, I was left with the impression that government debt began in July 2024, so I reminded myself of the profile of government debt, where it moved from a low of about 30% in the early 2000s up to where it is now—about 100%. Of course, there are two peak points, one during the financial crisis at the end of the 2000s, when the Government acted properly and promptly, and one during Covid, where we saw another spike. The reality of those correct but tough decisions is that we are left with high government debt now, which means that the Government have to take these tough but right decisions. Does my noble friend agree that government debt did not commence in July 2024 and that the decisions the Government are taking now on the triple lock are necessary given the profile of public debt that we face?

    View contribution permalink →

  32. Baroness Sherlock (Lab)

    My noble friend makes an excellent point. It is easy in politics to assume that all the problems started two years ago and that everything happened then; quite clearly it did not. I was very proud of myself for not mentioning the Liz Truss Budget, but I have just blown my record by doing it now. We must be clear about the consequences of decisions. One of the real challenges is that hard decisions are quite easy when you are in opposition. You can just say, “I’d cut this; I’d do all these things, and it would have no consequence”. But, of course, it would. It is much harder to take hard decisions when in government, and that is why I am so proud of Andy Burnham for doing just this.

    View contribution permalink →

  33. Lord Redwood (Con)

    My Lords, I need to clarify for the Minister that I support the triple lock, and I do not want a care tax. But will she answer my question: would the scheme also include ending the contributory principle for the pension to bring it into line with the care system and the abolition of the National Insurance Fund?

    View contribution permalink →

  34. Baroness Sherlock (Lab)

    My Lords, nothing like that has been suggested. I apologise if I misunderstood the noble Lord’s point; I am glad that he has clarified that he is fully in favour of the triple lock and not in favour of the changes he meant—he was pushing at me, not for him.

    View contribution permalink →

  35. Baroness Coffey (Con)

    My Lords, the noble Lord, Lord Reid, referred to potential dishonesty or scare stories. The reality is that, before the 2024 election, the Labour Party wrote to pretty much every pensioner across the country saying that the Conservatives were going to cut the state pension, so, frankly, I will not take lessons from there. But it was helpful for the Minister to say that the estimate is that by 2030 30% of earnings will be in relation to the new state pension. The basic state pension operates only at about 75% of the new state pension, which means that 43% of pensioners on the old basic state pension will not be getting the 30% of earnings. Will the Government look to rectify that and recognise that, as this was not in their manifesto, it may not be subject to the Salisbury convention?

    View contribution permalink →

  36. Baroness Sherlock (Lab)

    My Lords, the great difference for people who are on the basic state pension is that they have the great advantage, if they are only on the basic state pension, of potential access to pension credit. Pension credit is one of the great inventions of the last Labour Government—its creation absolutely reduced pensioner poverty. It is there to lift up those who are either on the basic state pension or have an income below the level of pension credit. That and pension credit will stay in place, and we will make decisions about that. It has never been the subject of the triple lock, either in previous Governments or in the current Government, but decisions have always been made on that in the light of those decisions and that will continue to be there.

    View contribution permalink →

Source: UK Parliament Hansard API. Debate ID: 5417788.