Contribution
My Lords, the triple lock was introduced by a Conservative Chancellor to tackle the very serious problem of pensioner poverty. Its introduction reflected a fundamental principle: those who work hard, pay their taxes and contribute to our country throughout their working lives should be able to enjoy security and dignity in retirement. Many have planned on that basis. The Labour Government have now abandoned that commitment. Although the existing triple lock will remain in place until April 2030, the Government’s plan would thereafter remove the guarantee that pensioners receive the full benefit of annual earnings growth whenever earnings are the highest of the three existing measures. This is a material reduction in the protection currently afforded to pensioners. The Government say that the savings generated by this change will contribute towards the cost of their proposed nationalised care service, but the numbers have already started to unravel. Can the Minister say how much the Government intend to raise from their plan to abandon the triple lock, and how much they expect a national social care service to cost?
Linking this decision to the national care service policy also raises a serious question about timing. The Government have cited savings of £15 billion in 2039-40 and £50 billion in 2049-50, but a national care service offering free personal care will require substantial expenditure much sooner than that. Those long-term figures do not explain how the Government intend to meet the upfront transitional cost of introducing nationalised, free personal care in the next Parliament, particularly if removing charges leads to increased demand, as one would expect. What will happen, for example, to the huge amount of informal and family care that is currently provided? I hope the Minister can answer that in her response.
The wider reason for this decision is not difficult to discern. The Government’s appalling mismanagement of the economy, combined with their ever-growing spending commitments, has placed our public finances under mounting and increasingly unsustainable pressure. These pressures are, in turn, compounding one another: the rising cost of borrowing means that an ever-greater proportion of public expenditure is being consumed simply by servicing our national debt, leaving less money available for the public services and priorities on which people depend.
The Government could choose to prioritise economic growth and abandon their unemployment Bill and job-killing national insurance hike. Instead, this Government have chosen to pursue the same old tax-and-spend agenda. According to the Department for Work and Pensions’ own figures, total welfare expenditure in the United Kingdom was forecast to reach £333.7 billion in the 2025-26 financial year, compared with approximately £315 billion in the preceding year. By 2030-31, expenditure is projected to approach £409 billion. That represents an increase of almost £75 billion. When will Ministers have the courage to take the difficult decisions and tackle the unsustainable growth in welfare spending?
This week, the Times reported some shocking stories, which were referred to in Oral Questions: of those on sickness benefits who want to come off them but have been told by DWP that they cannot; and of the more than 120,000 teenagers with autism, ADHD and depression who are claiming disability benefits, at a cost to the taxpayer of more than £1 billion a year. The welfare system is haemorrhaging money to people who do not want it, who do not need it, and who should be in work but are not. Rather than confronting these fundamental problems and addressing the drivers of rising welfare expenditure, the Government have chosen to revisit the protections afforded to those who have worked hard, paid into the system and contributed to our country throughout their lives. I find that choice difficult to understand. It is fundamentally a political choice. Following the deeply damaging decision to restrict winter fuel payments, and the subsequent U-turn, it is difficult to see how this latest announcement can do anything other than further erode the confidence of pensioners in the Government’s commitment to them.
I conclude by putting several questions to the Minister. First, why have the Government made a decision of this scale before the Pensions Commission has published its final recommendations on retirement adequacy? Was the commission consulted before the decision was made, and will it now be required to revise its projections?
Secondly, why has the Casey commission been given a clear role in designing a nationalised care service while the Pensions Commission appears not to have been given an equivalent role in assessing the effect of this decision on retirement adequacy? Will the Minister explain how the Government will finance the upfront cost of nationalised free personal care in the next Parliament when the savings cited today will build only gradually over decades?
Finally, the Government describe this policy as an adjustment to the triple lock, while the Prime Minister says that the state pension will continue to track average earnings over time. But if the new arrangement will produce substantial savings, it must necessarily leave future pensioners worse off than they would have been under the existing triple lock. Can the Minister confirm that this is correct?
Pensioners deserve security in retirement. Many of them will feel profoundly disappointed, quite justifiably, and some even betrayed by this decision.