Contribution
My Lords, I thank the Minister for introducing these two instruments and setting out their purpose. I confirm at the outset that we on these Benches welcome these changes and are pleased to support both instruments.
Mesothelioma, pneumoconiosis and other dust-related diseases cause immense suffering to workers and their families, often emerging decades after the original exposure to asbestos or other harmful substances. Many of those affected spent their lives working in industries such as mining, shipbuilding and construction, contributing enormously to our country’s prosperity, only to face devastating illness later in life. It is important to remember that the effects of these conditions extend far beyond those diagnosed. Families are often left to contend not only with the emotional toll of serious illness and bereavement but with substantial financial pressures.
The compensation schemes established under the 1979 and 2008 Acts therefore provide an essential safety net, particularly where a former employer has ceased trading or those affected cannot obtain compensation through other means. The central change introduced by these two instruments is welcome. It is right that dependants should receive compensation calculated at the same rates as sufferers themselves. A family’s need for support does not diminish because their loved one died before making a claim. I also welcome the provisions enabling payments to be made through a claimant’s personal representatives, where an individual dies after submitting a valid claim but before receiving compensation.
I want briefly to take this opportunity to recognise the tireless work of charities, campaigners and victims’ organisations that have advocated for these changes over many years, including Mesothelioma UK and the Asbestos Victims Support Group Forum UK. We support the principles underpinning both instruments, but I should be grateful if the Minister can provide further clarification on their practical implementation.
First, on the administration of payments following a claimant’s death, the regulations provide for compensation to be paid to personal representatives once the necessary evidence of probate, letters of administration or confirmation as executor have been supplied. Although those requirements are understandable, obtaining the necessary documentation can be a lengthy process, particularly for families dealing with bereavement. Can the Minister therefore explain what steps the department is taking to ensure that these requirements do not cause unnecessary delays. Will the Government introduce a target processing time for payment once the relevant documentation has been received? What guidance and practical assistance will be provided to bereaved families?
Secondly, I turn to the removal of existing supplementary payments under the pneumoconiosis scheme. The regulations remove a number of existing top-up provisions, including the provision relating to sufferers whose pneumoconiosis is accompanied by tuberculosis. The Government have suggested that the higher basic awards mean that claimants will benefit overall from the new arrangements. Can the Minister nevertheless give a categorical assurance that no individual claimant will receive a lower award as a result of these changes, including anyone who had previously qualified for the tuberculosis-related payment. If that assurance cannot be given, how many claimants does the department estimate could receive less? What is the maximum potential reduction and what transitional protection has been considered?
Thirdly, I turn to the transitional arrangements. Both instruments are intended to come into force on 31 October but they use different tests to determine who benefits from the new provisions. Under the 1979 Act scheme, the amendments apply where a person first fulfils the conditions of entitlement on or after that date. Under the 2008 Act scheme, the increased dependant rate applies where the sufferer dies on or after that date. Can the Minister explain the reason for using these different tests? How will the department treat cases in which a person fulfils the entitlement conditions or dies shortly before 31 October but the claim has not been determined by that date? In particular, what consideration has been given to families who may receive a substantially lower payment solely because the relevant event occurred shortly before the commencement date?
Fourthly, I turn to the speed of payments and awareness of schemes. These schemes are intended, wherever possible, to provide compensation to sufferers during their own lifetimes. Given the often rapid progression of these diseases following diagnosis, it is essential that applications are processed without unnecessary delay. Can the Minister tell the Committee the current average and median processing times under both schemes? How many claimants have died after submitting a valid claim but before receiving payment, in each of the past five years?