T

The Lord Bishop of Newcastle

Speaking in the House of Lords on 15 October 2026

Debate

Local Government: Democratic Accountability, Participation and Electoral Reform

Contribution

My Lords, I thank the noble Lord, Lord Shipley, for securing this debate and for the considerable experience he has brought to your Lordships’ House from his time in local government. He was a former leader of Newcastle City Council, and I pay tribute to him for that. He leaves this House with, from these Benches, our warmest thanks and every good wish for the future. It is an honour to follow the noble Lord, Lord Redwood. I also congratulate the noble Lord, Lord McCobb, and look forward to his maiden speech. As Bishop of Newcastle, I serve communities across the city and Northumberland. The questions are consistent: who listens to us, who decides, and what can we do when those decisions fail us? These are questions about dignity, belonging and trust. My firm conviction is that every person has worth and something to contribute to our common life. Democratic institutions should give practical expression to that conviction. I will highlight three priorities: accountable devolution, meaningful participation and fair representation. Beginning with the first, I note that the North East Mayoral Strategic Authority offers an opportunity to bring decisions about transport, housing and skills closer to the communities they serve. Newcastle and Northumberland have connected economies but distinct circumstances. Transport policy must serve both someone crossing Newcastle to work and someone in rural Northumberland whose opportunities depend on whether a bus runs at all. The recent bus franchising consultation makes this concrete. Decisions about routes, timetables and fares determine whether people can reach work, college, healthcare and one another. Greater control brings greater responsibility: the mayor’s mandate must be accompanied by effective council scrutiny, accessible spending information and clear responsibility for delivery. There is a legitimate concern about cost. As additional layers of representation and governance develop, residents are entitled to ask whether these arrangements represent value for money, avoid duplication and genuinely improve decision-making. Democratic accountability must be clear, not lost between institutions. I recognise the public service of councillors across parties and of independents. Effective scrutiny requires time, resources and access to information. Secondly, I turn to meaningful participation. An invitation to participate does not, by itself, make participation possible. Someone working shifts, caring for children or living without reliable internet access may struggle to contribute. In rural Northumberland, an evening meeting is inaccessible if there is no return bus. Public bodies need to go where people already gather: schools, libraries, community centres, churches and other faith communities. Newcastle’s Pride in Place sessions at West End Women and Girls Centre in Elswick and the Wor Hoose Community Project in Walker offer examples of this approach. Town and parish councils connect regional decisions with local knowledge. Young people, too, must help shape decisions that will determine their futures. The noble Lord, Lord Shipley, referred to these points in his speech, and I wholeheartedly agree. Such participation strengthens community resilience, which is increasingly important amid global instability. When emergencies arise, trusted local relationships matter: knowing who needs help, who can offer it and how reliable information reaches people. Local resilience forums have an important co-ordinating role, but preparedness must draw on the knowledge and networks of communities themselves, particularly in isolated rural areas. Participation is therefore not simply about consultation; it is about building relationships, sharing responsibility and enabling communities to shape their own futures. Thirdly, I turn to fair representation. Electoral reform should strengthen the relationship between people and those who govern them. There is a serious case for considering proportional representation in English local government, so that councils better reflect the range of views within their communities. However, changing electoral systems alone will not restore trust. At a time when polarisation is increasingly evident, building a culture of consensus and co-operation requires time and intentionality. I remember that dynamic from my time living and working in New Zealand, which operates an MMR system. We need institutions capable of holding differences constructively and representatives willing to work across them. Further devolution and electoral reform must be judged against the same principles: transparency, accountability, accessibility and fairness. Trust grows when people know their voice matters, can see the difference that participation makes, and are confident that decisions can be challenged and that those entrusted with power remain answerable. That trust strengthens our capacity to face uncertainty together. Ultimately, local democracy is not simply about where power sits but how it is exercised, who participates and whether it serves the common good.

More from The Lord Bishop of Newcastle

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.