L

Lord Wallace of Saltaire (LD)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 15 October 2026

Debate

Local Government: Democratic Accountability, Participation and Electoral Reform

Contribution

My Lords, I agree strongly with the right reverend Prelate on community participation being fundamental to democracy. I shall miss my noble friend Lord Shipley, but he is entirely right to retire. I am strongly in favour of retirement from this House as a principle, and I shall follow him next year. It is correct that the House is close to an agreement on a retirement age. On electoral reform, I simply say to the noble Lord, Lord Redwood, that he probably missed the magnificent Liberal Democrat victory in a by-election in Cornwall some months ago, in which the Liberal Democrats won 18.9% of the vote in an election in which six candidates got more than 10% and one of the mayors elected as chair got one-quarter of the vote. When we are in that sort of situation, the question of the acceptability of that sort of democratic representation is one that we must all take on board. That is why it is entirely correct now to open a national conversation on where we go from here and not argue, as Dominic Cummings in the 2011 referendum did, that having more elections is a dreadful, additional cost that we should avoid if possible. I want to talk about democracy. Democracy, in a minimalist sense, means elections every five years and referendums every now and again. The rest of the time, those who have the money and campaigned the most effectively get on and do things. The Liberal Democrat version of democracy is active citizenship, with government at all levels trying to explain to an educated electorate what the difficult choices are and engaging the citizens as far as possible in public life. The noble Lord, Lord Redwood, believes that we should not have too many layers of government, but we have fewer layers of government in England than there are in almost any other established democratic country. I have lived in the United States, and I have worked in Germany and France. If you want an active democracy, you have to engage the public in it, and that starts at the local level. In the last 40 years, we have seen local democracy in Britain shrink in a number of ways. Mrs Thatcher deeply mistrusted local government and weakened it where she could. Central funding has become more and more important. Local taxation has shrunk to an unreformed council tax. Living as I have for the last 40 years both in Wandsworth and Bradford, under our system I usually pay more council tax on our house in Saltaire than I do on our house in Wandsworth, which is a crazy situation. Council tax is part of what needs to be reformed. We have also moved away from the local. The idea that the most efficient way to have local government is to have at least half a million people in every council area is crazy. I see my noble friend Lady Eaton—I do regard her as a friend—shake her head. The noble Baroness is a neighbour of mine in Yorkshire, and I have long admired her position not only as a former leader of the council but as someone who represents a very large rural ward, previously a rural district council, with five substantial villages within it. That is a really difficult task for the councillor concerned, and it is a difficult task for those who live in the villages to get to know or even to remember the name of their councillor. We need to re-establish the idea of local government, and that clearly involves establishing parish and town councils wherever we have them. Across Yorkshire, wealthy areas—middle class areas and areas with lots of graduates—have active parish councils. Former council house areas and areas where there are a lot of unemployed people tend not to have parish councils. That means that they are disengaged from politics. As council services shrink, many people hardly ever have any contact with government as such. That is the situation in which conspiracy theories grow and mistrust of government festers, which is very bad for democracy. So part of what I hope this Government will do, as they push through the previous Conservative Government’s insistence on single-tier local government that is oversized, is to insist or to encourage the extension of town and parish councils all the way across the country and to allow them to have some local powers and local funding so that local people can feel that they are engaged with politics in one form or another. When I was first involved in politics, the Conservative Party had several million members. As I remember from the small towns in which I lived as a teenager, the local councillors formed the fundamental structure of the local Conservative Party. There was a period in which my own party had 300,000 members. Neither it nor the Conservative Party has 100,000 members now, I am told. That is a setback for democracy. We have a very low level of public trust and public participation. Last year, the strategic defence review talked about the need to re-engage the public on national security and homeland defence. We have heard a certain amount over the past year or two about the need to rebuild resilience in our society, which means local volunteers, looking after each other and rebuilding local community, local engagement and local leadership. In the way in which local government has shrunk, we have lost the sense that politics, security and community start at the local level. Devolution to mayors on their own is not enough. It works well in metropolitan areas, but it works a great deal less well outside metropolitan areas. I was one of the many in Yorkshire who resisted the Conservative Government’s insistence that we should have a mayor for North Yorkshire and a mayor for East Yorkshire, each now with no more than two subsidiary authorities over which to be strategic. We need, therefore, to rebuild the sense of local democracy.

More from Lord Wallace of Saltaire (LD)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.